kyzr
Diamond Member
- Thread starter
- #41
That's a bad idea. Private companies have a profit motive to cut corners. We saw how that worked out at TMI.I'll support getting government out of the way to allow private companies to invest in building as many nuclear power plants as the market will bear.
Would you support investing in more nuclear power as part of US infrastructure upgrades?
Prove it! Because The reasons behind this malfunction are still unknown.
Causes and Effects of the Three Mile Island Nuclear Disaster
So where is your PROOF that "cutting corners" was the fault? Are you a nuclear engineer expert?
If you read these two explanations of the accident you will see that certain systems did not function as designed. Why was that? Who screwed up? These are critical "safety related" systems that are supposed to be guaranteed to work.
https://www.history.com/topics/1970s/three-mile-island
NRC: Backgrounder on the Three Mile Island Accident
But where is your proof that "cutting corners" was the fault? Was there any actual legal actions brought against those evil for profit companies?
Now this web site: Legal History of Three Mile Island explains in great detail TMI lawsuits,etc.
The point I'm making though is once again those evil profit making companies are at fault...according to anti-capitalists mentalities you exhibit.
In the meantime.. trillions of gigawatts of power has been generated by nuclear plants OPERATED by for profit utilities. But of course really dumb
people like you take those RARE, totally infrequent events as the RULE rather than the exceptions. I'm really tired of people like you taking an isolated,
RARE situation and making it sound like an evil for profit plot! How truly naive...stupid!
The fact that there was a settlement out of court proves that there was someone at fault for the TMI incident.
There were two units at TMI, unit-1 ran as-designed from startup in 1975 to shutdown before the end of this month
Three Mile Island Unit 1 To Shut Down By September 30, 2019
Why did Unit-1 run perfectly and Unit-2 melt down? What were the major differences?
Both had the same reactor designs, and both were built by the same constructor.
They were designed by two different companies. Did that matter? How did the designs differ?
Why were different design outfits used? Was it to save money? Is that a bad thing? Not normally.
Trust me, I'm a lot smarter than you are. I'm a professional engineer and the nuke plants that I worked on work great. I didn't work on TMI-2.
If you think serious nuclear incidents are rare, that just proves your stupidity.
Here is a list for you: Nuclear and radiation accidents and incidents - Wikipedia