San Jose gun owners could be required to purchase liability insurance

[Mac-7]

Driving is a PRIVILEGE. Gun ownership is a RIGHT--guaranteed by the constitution.

Thanks

I get that

my point was the ineffectiveness of gun taxes since the people causing the gun violence epidemic will ignore the law

 

[Concerned American]

You can get by without a gun.

If you can't drive, there are some places in America where you'll die of starvation. And you might not be able to get to work and back.

I don't really GAF how you "feel" about it. The fact of the matter is, driving is a privilege and as such you have to pass a test, receive a license and have insurance. Gun ownership is a RIGHT guaranteed by the second amendment of the constitution which states that the right to "keep and bear arms shall not be infringed" Requiring insurance is an infringement.

 

[Wild Bill Kelsoe]

Like abortion rights, shouldn't we let the state decide?

Federal law says the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.

 

[M14 Shooter]

You can get by without a gun.
If you can't drive, there are some places in America where you'll die of starvation. And you might not be able to get to work and back.

Doesn't change the fact his statement is correct.

 

[Wild Bill Kelsoe]

I think that's very much true. Look at this full auto grenade launcher.

How would you like to go up against something like that with your AR15?

Since he's firing from a static position and his field of fire is only about 45°, I'll flank his ass and take him out from 300 yards.

 

[Magnus]

Name any other protected right we have to pay to exersize? Then explain why rights are not paid to have or use.

Name any other protected right that can maim or kill you? Then explain how this is different from owning a car or other vehicles that can do the same.

 

[TNHarley]

Name any other protected right that can maim or kill you? Then explain how this is different from owning a car or other vehicles that can do the same.

No rights maim or kill people, retard

 

[sealybobo]

No rights maim or kill people, retard

Republicans love to talk about being free and rights.

But don't say gay! It's against the law.

Don't smoke pot or get an abortion.

 

[RetiredGySgt]

Name any other protected right that can maim or kill you? Then explain how this is different from owning a car or other vehicles that can do the same.

cars are not a right retard.

 

[dblack]

Mandated insurance is a terrible way to deal with public risk. It effectively outsources the job of government and makes our rights dependent on insurance company "sponsorship".

 

[Failzero]

But but I thought Republicans were the real Gungrabbers ???

 

[TNHarley]

But don't say gay! It's against the law.

Of course, that is a load of shit. But I agree with your premise.
You always throw repubs in my face like idk how they are lolz

 

[Magnus]

No rights maim or kill people, retard

LOL In other words, you use guns to masturbate? In the real world, guns are used to kill and or maim.

Let me know if you are still confused, retard.

 

[Magnus]

cars are not a right retard.

But they can still kill or maim in the wrong hands. Hence, the need for insurance.

So too, with guns. Let me know if you are still confused, retard.

 

[AMart]

Besides being illegal this law would be impossible to enforce lol. Stupid dems.

 

[Magnus]

Won't happen here, and I wouldn't live there. Annual fee is a nonstarter. Insurance is a good idea, but if you aren't a deadbeat and willing to stand for your own liability, it should be your choice. If you do not account for, control and secure your weapons in a reasonable manner, you should be liable for their use in crimes. If you own a weapon, you should be responsible for it, if you are actually negligent in securing it. None of this proposal would ever pass here in Tennessee and shouldn't.

That makes no sense. You need liability insurance because you are liable if you were to hurt or kill someone. If you can't pay, then you get insurance.

Same with having auto insurance.

And before some nitwit jumps in with Second Amendment "freedumb", no one is taking away the guns. Under our constitution, you have every right to keep guns. But with rights comes responsibility.

The responsibility to pay if you were to discharge your gun by accident. And if you are not a billionaire, you get liability insurance. What part of that is so hard to understand?

 

[M14 Shooter]

What part of that is so hard to understand?

The part where you think this requirement will pass the Bruen test.

 

[TNHarley]

LOL In other words, you use guns to masturbate? In the real world, guns are used to kill and or maim.

Let me know if you are still confused, retard.

wtf? You are fuckin weird dude. And dumb.

 

[Magnus]

wtf? You are fuckin weird dude. And dumb.

In other words, you couldn't respond? Not to worry, retard. I never expected you could.

 

[Magnus]

The part where you think this requirement will pass the Bruen test.

Go back and re-read Bruen. Paying insurance has nothing to do with taking away guns.