Q: Will the SCOTUS weigh in before Biden’s redistribution from the working class to college-educated professionals is slated to happen?

[Lisa558]

When is Biden, likely illegally, going to wipe out $10,000 of debt to college-educated accountants, architects, engineers, etc., driving inflation and putting the cost on the working class?

Will the Supreme Court have an opportunity to weigh in before he waves his magic wand? Based on previous rulings, the SCOTUS is generally opposed to a power grab by the president when the issue is something that is normally determined by Congress.

And who could bring a challenge to a lower court, thereby starting the path up to the Supreme Court? i would think that any taxpaying American who is harmed by this, which are the majority.

Fact-check: Is Joe Biden's student debt forgiveness plan legal?

Legal experts say Supreme Court has been skeptical of agencies exerting broad powers like these in the absence of congressional consent.

www.statesman.com

 

[Dekster]

The GOP is just itching to blow their red wave, but no, the SCOTUS won't rule before October 31.

 

[Lesh]

So you’re counting on the radical Court to take away 10 to 20 thousand dollars of debt relief from essentially middle class folks after they have taken away reproductive rights from women?

 

[Sixties Fan]

Nothing illegal about it. Experts about the laws, like Professor Tribe, know it

 

[Biff_Poindexter]

When is Biden, likely illegally, going to wipe out $10,000 of debt to college-educated accountants, architects, engineers, etc., driving inflation and putting the cost on the working class?

Will the Supreme Court have an opportunity to weigh in before he waves his magic wand? Based on previous rulings, the SCOTUS is generally opposed to a power grab by the president when the issue is something that is normally determined by Congress.

And who could bring a challenge to a lower court, thereby starting the path up to the Supreme Court? i would think that any taxpaying American who is harmed by this, which are the majority.

Fact-check: Is Joe Biden's student debt forgiveness plan legal?

Legal experts say Supreme Court has been skeptical of agencies exerting broad powers like these in the absence of congressional consent.

www.statesman.com

So working class Americans don't go to college and have student loan debt?

So those who received Pell grants to get an education are members of the "elite"??

 

[Lesh]

So working class Americans don't go to college and have student loan debt?

So those who received Pell grants to get an education are members of the "elite"??

Tried for a Pell grant when my son went to college. I was making about $70k (combined with my wife’s income)

Not even close

 

[1srelluc]

Dems better get used to 6-3 disappointments.

 

[Lisa558]

Nothing illegal about it. Experts about the laws, like Professor Tribe, know it

Did you read the article I posted? The jury is out on whether a president can give a big break to college-educated professionals while making the majority - those with high school degrees - pay the consequences.

 

[Ralph Norton]

So you’re counting on the radical Court to take away 10 to 20 thousand dollars of debt relief from essentially middle class folks after they have taken away reproductive rights from women?

The Supreme Court took away nothing - they gave the abortion issue back to the states where it belongs.
But you knew that.
Now they can take back the unfair and selective (and possibly illegal) debt relief.

 

[ZZ PUPPS]

SCOTUS doesn't need to rule. All that is needed is for a federal judge to issue a nation wide injunction against implementation. That ruling would then go through the appellate process.

 

[Lisa558]

Tried for a Pell grant when my son went to college. I was making about $70k (combined with my wife’s income)

Not even close

That’s because $70k is Middle income. Pell grants are for lower-income.

 

[Lisa558]

So working class Americans don't go to college and have student loan debt?

So those who received Pell grants to get an education are members of the "elite"??

College-educated Americans, who chose a marketable career, are not working class. The working class are high-school educated folks, with working class jobs.

Why should the cashier at the grocery store or the hostess at a restaurant have to subsidize accountants, marketing managers, and the GS13 and up crowd?

 

[Rambunctious]

A lot of people have taken loans from government through agencies like the SBA... if student debt is relieved those loans should be too... covid disaster loans should all be forgiven before student loans are....
A rich kid gets his student loan forgiven but some poor roofer has to repay his disaster loan that he used to buy tools and keep his workers paid though the government ordered shut down?....
We all know what's fair and this isn't fair at all....

 

[Lesh]

That’s because $70k is Middle income. Pell grants are for lower-income.

Exactly. And this regards $20k in PELL GRANTS as well as $10 k for all loans.

And of note… only 3 per cent of loans went to students who went to Ivy League schools

This was clearly geared towards middle class folks

 

[Rambunctious]

Exactly. And this regards $20k in PELL GRANTS as well as $10 k for all loans.

And of note… only 3 per cent of loans went to students who went to Ivy League schools

This was clearly geared towards middle class folks

Democrats bailing out the wealthy.... again....

 

[Lesh]

A lot of people have taken loans from government through agencies like the SBA... if student debt is relieved those loans should be too... covid disaster loans should all be forgiven before student loans are....
A rich kid gets his student loan forgiven but some poor roofer has to repay his disaster loan that he used to buy tools and keep his workers paid though the government ordered shut down?....
We all know what's fair and this isn't fair at all....

A shot load of COVID loans WERE forgiven.

Did you forget that MTG had $180k of COVID loans forgiven?

 

[Lesh]

Democrats bailing out the wealthy.... again....

Welcome to backwards world. I just explained that this is NOT the case

 

[Rambunctious]

A shot load of COVID loans WERE forgiven.

Did you forget that MTG had $180k of COVID loans forgiven?

No those were PPE loans that were used to pay employees... disaster loans were different... they got a couple of deferments for covid numbers rising but the loans are not forgiven... they should be... imo...

 

[Rambunctious]

A shot load of COVID loans WERE forgiven.

Did you forget that MTG had $180k of COVID loans forgiven?

MTG used her PPE loan to keep her employees paid while her business was shut down.... did you forget that or are you purposely leaving that fact out?....

 

[Lesh]

MTG used her PPE loan to keep her employees paid while her business was shut down.... did you forget that or are you purposely leaving that fact out?....

Didn’t you just whine that COVID loans should be forgiven first?

They were dumbass