Grandma,
I'll straight shoot this. I am having issues with your arguments. A ton of your posts seem to keep reverting back to FA's reads. You keep referencing him over and over, almost as if that is the only argument you have. Perhaps since I have been reading from my phone I have missed something. But it seems as if you are leaning on his reads as being the "be all end all" and you are not making other logical arguments. I think you have referenced and linked to that FA's reads several times and have gone back to the "king" thing too several times.
I don't know why, but this is strange to me.
I thought Aye may be usurper because her voting pattern.
How about an argument for Aye, without using FA? Scum are scum, and since you think he may have been trying to fool us by saying "King" and it could have been 'Queen" why lean on FAs count so much?
Cafe, you had FA in your neighborhood Game 3. He was Scum with me in Game 4. You and I know how he plays.
There is no way in hell he would dare risk the Ruler by reading the Ruler as Scum. FA would read the Ruler as Null or Town.
His Scum/Leaning Scum reads: Scarlet, Mertex, Wolf, Ika.
His Null/Town reads: Aye, Shaitra, Cafe (The Old School), Arden, Avi, Josh, Grandma (TSO), Mathblade
From Wall Post 1766: FA defends Josh and calls Math Scum. He's very much after Wolf. He reads me (tso) and Scarlet as Scum. Defends Avi. Wants to PL Ika.
Later he and Shaitra wagon Avi.
So Scarlet, Mertex, Wolf, Ika, Avi, Math, Avi, and I = not Ruler, not likely Guard.
That leaves Aye, Shaitra, Cafe (The Old School), Arden, Josh.
Well, Shaitra turned out to be a Guard, didn't she?
So Aye, Cafe, Arden, Josh are left.
Shaitra read Aye as Town. I don't have the link for her full reads list, I got that bit of news from Avi.
SHAITRA AND FA BOTH LIST AYE AS TOWN.
That very much shortens the suspect list for me.
