Non US citizens have a say! Why?

[Coyote]

Now non US citizens will be counted for apportioning congressional representatives. Amazing. Am I reading this correctly and how does no one have issues with this?

Executive Order on Ensuring a Lawful and Accurate Enumeration and Apportionment Pursuant to the Decennial Census | The White House

By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, it is hereby ordered: Section 1. Background. We have long guaranteed all of the Nation’s inhabitants representation in the House of Representatives. This tradition is foundational to...

www.whitehouse.gov

They always have been.

 

[Coyote]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

 

[Rambunctious]

Trump won in a landslide the dems know it and its freaked them out...they are hunting for new dems everywhere.....

 

[georgephillip]

So we should count illegals too? They are inhabitants.

For the purpose of an accurate census...yes.
Isn't that what the Constitution calls for?

 

[Leo123]

Now non US citizens will be counted for apportioning congressional representatives. Amazing. Am I reading this correctly and how does no one have issues with this?

Executive Order on Ensuring a Lawful and Accurate Enumeration and Apportionment Pursuant to the Decennial Census | The White House

By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, it is hereby ordered: Section 1. Background. We have long guaranteed all of the Nation’s inhabitants representation in the House of Representatives. This tradition is foundational to...

www.whitehouse.gov

Wrong.

Documented immigrants don’t have a ‘say.’

Lawful Permanent Resident Aliens (‘green card’ holders) consume local resources – they drive on roads, conduct business in state and local offices, and receive services at hospitals and clinics.

It’s perfectly appropriate and warranted for them the be counted in the census to allow for the distribution of Federal funding to offset the use of local resources.

Indeed, it would be financially reckless and irresponsible to not count LPRAs in the census.

“At no point since our Nation’s Founding has a person’s immigration status alone served as a basis for excluding that person from the total population count used in apportionment.” ibid

Bullshit, any alien coming here to enjoy the benefits of the U.S. paid for by its CITIZENS should not be counted and still (IMO) should have to pay extra until they become citizens and swear to assimilate. Others can just keep paying or go the fuck back to their shit hole country.

 

[lantern2814]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

 

[Coyote]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

So...do I take it you are on record as claiming they’ve been doing it wrong since 1790?

 

[Asclepias]

Trump won in a landslide the dems know it and its freaked them out...they are hunting for new dems everywhere.....

Still in denial eh?

 

[Asclepias]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

Who told you that? Show us in the constitution where it says this.

 

[Oz and the Orchestra]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

What difference does it make? - You guys don't seem to know how to count anyway...ha ha ha.

 

[lantern2814]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

So...do I take it you are on record as claiming they’ve been doing it wrong since 1790?

Don’t you ever think you can speak for me asshole. Your bullshit comparison means nothing to real Americans. Illegals are not citizens and have no say. Period. You are on record as a dumbass and a liar.

 

[georgephillip]

Everyone on US soil is under US jurisdiction. The laws of France or Mexico or Timbuktu do not apply in the US.. I swear, if brains were gunpowder Trump couldn't blow his nose.

Trump's blend of ignorance and arrogance is unprecedented, but I wonder if he isn't channeling Stephen Miller on this subject?

10 quotes from Stephen Miller, Trump's other true believer

 

[HenryBHough]

Naturally this extends worldwide. Everybody everywhere, especially in China, MUST have a vote in any national election in America. Even (especially?) if they aren't allowed to vote where they live.

Do I have that right, Nancy?

 

[lantern2814]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

Who told you that? Show us in the constitution where it says this.

Show us where illegals are citizens.

 

[lantern2814]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

What difference does it make? - You guys don't seem to know how to count anyway...ha ha ha.

Oh we can count. And we know when numbers don’t match.

 

[Coyote]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

So...do I take it you are on record as claiming they’ve been doing it wrong since 1790?

Don’t you ever think you can speak for me asshole. Your bullshit comparison means nothing to real Americans. Illegals are not citizens and have no say. Period. You are on record as a dumbass and a liar.

Just trying to figure out what your thesis is here, maestro...clearly not in the realm of history and likely not reality either.

 

[AzogtheDefiler]

So we should count illegals too? They are inhabitants.

For the purpose of an accurate census...yes.
Isn't that what the Constitution calls for?

Tourists are inhabitants too. Do we count them?

 

[HappyJoy]

Maybe the wingnuts will stop molesting the Constitution now.

 

[Coyote]

[

So we should count illegals too? They are inhabitants.

For the purpose of an accurate census...yes.
Isn't that what the Constitution calls for?

Tourists are inhabitants too. Do we count them?

Tourists, by definition, are not.

 

[Jim H - VA USA]

The census is supposed to aid in determining representation in Congress based on number of CITIZENS. Illegals are not citizens and thus legally should not be counted. There’s no gray area here. More bullshit from Xiden. Well on his way to Obozo and Carter depths of incompetence.

Where did you pull that out of? Are you you trying to claim they’ve been doing it all wrong since 1790?

Like I care what a proven lying asshole like you thinks. Representation is based on citizens. Illegals get ZERO say and not counted. Of course a dumbfuck like you has no problem with stuffing illegals into everything.

Who told you that? Show us in the constitution where it says this.

I don't think the COTUS says it, but it makes sense. Since the census determines the apportionment of Representatives who will be voted on, and only American citizens can vote in federal elections (as far as I know), it makes sense.