National origin quotas - immoral or not?

Joined
Jun 13, 2026
Messages
4
Reaction score
3
Points
1
I think not. Immigration is not a basic right of anyone, so the argument it's unfair does not hold. US (nor any country) doesn't owes anybody a right to immigrate. And since there are large differences in how well immigrants from some countries do compared to others, it's irresponsible to citizens to not filter out bad origin countries. Even non nationalists like Tomas Sowell agrees with this.
 
I think not. Immigration is not a basic right of anyone, so the argument it's unfair does not hold. US (nor any country) doesn't owes anybody a right to immigrate. And since there are large differences in how well immigrants from some countries do compared to others, it's irresponsible to citizens to not filter out bad origin countries. Even non nationalists like Tomas Sowell agrees with this.
White Americans are all descendants of immigrants. You guys really have no moral right toset limit n other. Furthermore, our foreign policy creates problems that make people leave their countries. So again, whites have no right to set limits.
 
White Americans are all descendants of immigrants. You guys really have no moral right toset limit n other. Furthermore, our foreign policy creates problems that make people leave their countries. So again, whites have no right to set limits.
Legal immigrants. We have moral obligation to keep third world trash out of our country
 
White Americans are all descendants of immigrants. You guys really have no moral right toset limit n other. Furthermore, our foreign policy creates problems that make people leave their countries. So again, whites have no right to set limits.
Most countries in the world were created by ethnic groups who once immigrated somewhere. By your logic, North Africa, and Central Africa do not have a right to their own immigration policies because they are descendants who immigrated there and took land from some other people. Taiwan does not have a right to deny anyone because it's Chinese came there only in 16th century and took the island from natives. More anti White double standards .

No, US foreign policy is not the primary reason. Immigrants from poor countries come because they have failed to built prosperity due to their own incompetence.
 
Legal immigrants. We have moral obligation to keep third world trash out of our country
Third world countries happen because white corporations take their resources and get rich while paying the people there pittances. So again, whites have no moral right to set limits on a land that they immigrated to.
 
Third world countries happen because white corporations take their resources and get rich while paying the people there pittances. So again, whites have no moral right to set limits on a land that they immigrated to.
Ridiculous. How come South Korea developed so rapidly embracing capitalism and opening themselves to those "evil corporations". How come China and Vietnam did despite officially being communist but in practice they still decided to open themselves to capitalist economic policies when their socialism wasn't working. How about India? It used to be 3x poorer than Black Africa and is now considerably richer? The most rational explanation is that some countries have what it takes, while others don't.
 
Back
Top Bottom