Justice Roberts second guesses policy making decision on census, violates separation of powers

[Faun]

Skewing the results defeats the purpose of the census. It's just another example of republicans targeting democracy itself because they think it is against them.

It defeats the goals of your evil party.

The purpose of the census is to determine representation. Illegals are not citizens and have no representation outside of the consulate of their governments.

Loon, adding the question if one is a citizen or not does not determine the legal status of non-U.S. citizens.

Try harder next time.

 

[Care4all]

The ACS is not binding on redrawing districts, is not sent to everyone and is used as a test-bed for questions and methods. Who gives a shit? The actual census is key to the balance of power in this country and republicans are ******* with it and telling a bullshit story about why.

So, it was constitutional for Obama to ask the question but now it's not constitutional? Seems to me the Second Section of the 14th Amendment requires a distinction to be made between citizens and non-citizens.

JWK


The Democrat Party Leadership has been angry, stupid and obnoxious ever since the Republican Party Leadership freed democrat owned slaves. ___ Author unknown

So why doesn't president Trump get the information he wants from the ACS???

A correct census helps in many ways and an incorrect census harms in many ways and does not take much logic to understand this

The GDP scores will be faulty with incorrect counts

Health research and studies with patterns and the learning would be incorrect

Should be a world law that only citizens should be counted once and travelers could be counted many times

Justice Roberts has a severe problem of not wanting a nation and world to have prosperity

The question on the census will give you an inaccurate count..

Why do you want an inaccurate census count????

Tell us.

 

[Faun]

The removal of the citizenship question amounts to election tampering more than any gerrymandering or Russian meddling ever did. Not only that, but the flood of illegals and phony refugees that it encourages is destroying our country. And the only reason we're allowing it is because Democrats are getting a big electoral advantage from this invasion. There's nothing compassionate or fair about it and it will certainly destroy our economy if it continues. If you want to talk about fairness, lets talk about citizens of this country who are having their votes unfairly negated by illegal alien voters. Lets talk about the depressed wages and higher taxes that result from illegals. If a state wants to allow slave labor, they shouldn't be rewarded with a higher rate of representation. And as a taxpayer, I sure as hell don't want to subsidize illegal aliens or any state that promotes them in any way. We have our own poor people who should be our first priority.

The democrat Party WANTS to destroy America, that's why they NEED Illegals and their sex trafficked children

I wonder if Billy boy Clinton will get swept up in the Epstein sex charges. He had 30 something documented trips to Epstein's pedophile island and anyone with half a brain knew what that was about.

Why lie? Clinton has zero documented trips to pedophile isle.

 

[Faun]

The ACS is not binding on redrawing districts, is not sent to everyone and is used as a test-bed for questions and methods. Who gives a shit? The actual census is key to the balance of power in this country and republicans are ******* with it and telling a bullshit story about why.

So, it was constitutional for Obama to ask the question but now it's not constitutional? Seems to me the Second Section of the 14th Amendment requires a distinction to be made between citizens and non-citizens.

JWK


The Democrat Party Leadership has been angry, stupid and obnoxious ever since the Republican Party Leadership freed democrat owned slaves. ___ Author unknown

The distinction in section two is based on voter suppression. Adding the citizen question does not count disenfranchised voters.

 

[johnwk]

So why doesn't president Trump get the information he wants from the ACS???

You do not comprehend the 14th amendment, at all!!!!

It is a very, very small sampling.


The bottom line question is, why was it constitutional for Obama's Census Bureau to ask "Is this person a citizen of the United States", and un-constitutional for today's Census Bureau to ask the very same question? Keep in mind that Section 2 of the 14th Amendment requires the distinction between citizens and non-citizens to be made with reference to apportionment.


It appears Justice Roberts believes he is vested with a power to strike down laws and policy making decisions that do not meet his personal sense of fairness, reasonableness and justice, which in fact is second guessing our Constitution which actually requires, by Section 2 of the 14th Amendment to make a distinction between citizens and non-citizens with reference to apportionment.


Justice Roberts, who also embraced our federal government entering the states and meddling with the people's unalienable right to make their own medical choices and decisions, needs to be held accountable for his acts of sedition and personal war against our Constitution.


JWK

"The public welfare demands that constitutional cases must be decided according to the terms of the Constitution itself, and not according to judges' views of fairness, reasonableness, or justice." -- Justice Hugo L. Black ( U.S. Supreme Court Justice, 1886 - 1971) Source: Lecture, Columbia University, 1968

 

[GreenAndBlue]

The ACS is not binding on redrawing districts, is not sent to everyone and is used as a test-bed for questions and methods. Who gives a shit? The actual census is key to the balance of power in this country and republicans are ******* with it and telling a bullshit story about why.

So, it was constitutional for Obama to ask the question but now it's not constitutional? Seems to me the Second Section of the 14th Amendment requires a distinction to be made between citizens and non-citizens.

JWK


The Democrat Party Leadership has been angry, stupid and obnoxious ever since the Republican Party Leadership freed democrat owned slaves. ___ Author unknown

So why doesn't president Trump get the information he wants from the ACS???

A correct census helps in many ways and an incorrect census harms in many ways and does not take much logic to understand this

The GDP scores will be faulty with incorrect counts

Health research and studies with patterns and the learning would be incorrect

Should be a world law that only citizens should be counted once and travelers could be counted many times

Justice Roberts has a severe problem of not wanting a nation and world to have prosperity

The question on the census will give you an inaccurate count..

Why do you want an inaccurate census count????

Tell us.

Wrong dead wrong

A citizen count means a lot and helps a lot in understanding and progress in many ways

It's outrageous how this cannot be understood or simply dishonest people

Which is it??

This weakens the progress of the nation ... Was Roberts bought off to weaken America ??

His financies and his families financies should be investigated

 

[Faun]

The ACS is not binding on redrawing districts, is not sent to everyone and is used as a test-bed for questions and methods. Who gives a shit? The actual census is key to the balance of power in this country and republicans are ******* with it and telling a bullshit story about why.

So, it was constitutional for Obama to ask the question but now it's not constitutional? Seems to me the Second Section of the 14th Amendment requires a distinction to be made between citizens and non-citizens.

JWK


The Democrat Party Leadership has been angry, stupid and obnoxious ever since the Republican Party Leadership freed democrat owned slaves. ___ Author unknown

So why doesn't president Trump get the information he wants from the ACS???

A correct census helps in many ways and an incorrect census harms in many ways and does not take much logic to understand this

The GDP scores will be faulty with incorrect counts

Health research and studies with patterns and the learning would be incorrect

Should be a world law that only citizens should be counted once and travelers could be counted many times

Justice Roberts has a severe problem of not wanting a nation and world to have prosperity

The question on the census will give you an inaccurate count..

Why do you want an inaccurate census count????

Tell us.

Wrong dead wrong

A citizen count means a lot and helps a lot in understanding and progress in many ways

It's outrageous how this cannot be understood or simply dishonest people

Which is it??

This weakens the progress of the nation ... Was Roberts bought off to weaken America ??

His financies and his families financies should be investigated

How does that question help in terms of apportioning representation?

 

[CrusaderFrank]

You almost have to wonder if filing the latest charges against Epstein is Trump's way of telling Roberts, "yes, we know too. Time for you to go"

 

[GreenAndBlue]

With trump gaining the majority of the men and the white men in a landslide

And the majority of the military

That means they have judged opposite of Roberts and the lefties on the court

A 5 to 4 victory by the Supreme Court that barely passes should not be allowed to go against the majority of the men of the nation and especially the white men

That Supreme Court is just asking for the majority of the men to stop this whole system !!

Really foolish people

 

[Faun]

With trump gaining the majority of the men and the white men in a landslide

And the majority of the military

That means they have judged opposite of Roberts and the lefties on the court

A 5 to 4 victory by the Supreme Court that barely passes should not be allowed to go against the majority of the men of the nation and especially the white men

That Supreme Court is just asking for the majority of the men to stop this whole system !!

Really foolish people

 

[The Original Tree]

The census question is legal and has been on the Census before..

It will be on there again.

 

[GreenAndBlue]

With trump gaining the majority of the men and the white men in a landslide

And the majority of the military

That means they have judged opposite of Roberts and the lefties on the court

A 5 to 4 victory by the Supreme Court that barely passes should not be allowed to go against the majority of the men of the nation and especially the white men

That Supreme Court is just asking for the majority of the men to stop this whole system !!

Really foolish people

What does it mean when a majority of the men of a nation goes against a few leaders?

 

[Faun]

With trump gaining the majority of the men and the white men in a landslide

And the majority of the military

That means they have judged opposite of Roberts and the lefties on the court

A 5 to 4 victory by the Supreme Court that barely passes should not be allowed to go against the majority of the men of the nation and especially the white men

That Supreme Court is just asking for the majority of the men to stop this whole system !!

Really foolish people

What does it mean when a majority of the men of a nation goes against a few leaders?

Loon, I'm still waiting for you answer my question.... How does adding a citizenship question help in terms of apportioning representation?

 

[GreenAndBlue]

With trump gaining the majority of the men and the white men in a landslide

And the majority of the military

That means they have judged opposite of Roberts and the lefties on the court

A 5 to 4 victory by the Supreme Court that barely passes should not be allowed to go against the majority of the men of the nation and especially the white men

That Supreme Court is just asking for the majority of the men to stop this whole system !!

Really foolish people

What does it mean when a majority of the men of a nation goes against a few leaders?

Loon, I'm still waiting for you answer my question.... How does adding a citizenship question help in terms of apportioning representation?

Wise people have woke up to this type of corruption by the left

What is this type of corruption ??

They simply lie


How do they simply lie??


They all have the same narrative to use against the truth they simply lie

When asked for data or evidence they give something that has no relation to the issue or far less valuable to know the issue

now the wise have caught up with their system of lies to try to influence against truth

They cover up their more serious errors and crookedness by saying look they are also making errors but the wise catches them when seeing the liberal errors are much worse than the conservatives

So these foolish liars should be very worried when the highest logic gender the men catches them and disagrees

Anger of the wise is rising because of these foolish liars and looking thru history they always lose to the more wise

Roberts seeing how the men is opposite his rulings should be shaking in his boots

 

[Faun]

With trump gaining the majority of the men and the white men in a landslide

And the majority of the military

That means they have judged opposite of Roberts and the lefties on the court

A 5 to 4 victory by the Supreme Court that barely passes should not be allowed to go against the majority of the men of the nation and especially the white men

That Supreme Court is just asking for the majority of the men to stop this whole system !!

Really foolish people

What does it mean when a majority of the men of a nation goes against a few leaders?

Loon, I'm still waiting for you answer my question.... How does adding a citizenship question help in terms of apportioning representation?

Wise people have woke up to this type of corruption by the left

What is this type of corruption ??

They simply lie


How do they simply lie??


They all have the same narrative to use against the truth they simply lie

When asked for data or evidence they give something that has no relation to the issue or far less valuable to know the issue

now the wise have caught up with their system of lies to try to influence against truth

They cover up their more serious errors and crookedness by saying look they are also making errors but the wise catches them when seeing the liberal errors are much worse than the conservatives

So these foolish liars should be very worried when the highest logic gender the men catches them and disagrees

Anger of the wise is rising because of these foolish liars and looking thru history they always lose to the more wise

Roberts seeing how the men is opposite his rulings should be shaking in his boots

And still no answer to the question, how does adding a citizenship question help in terms of apportioning representation?

 

[wamose]

We should never count illegal aliens when apportioning aid, determining # of representatives or any other type of federal aid. Counting illegals then becomes the same type of destructive incentive that we give to welfare moms for having more kids they can't afford

 

[johnwk]

And still no answer to the question, how does adding a citizenship question help in terms of apportioning representation?

It distinguishes citizens from non-citizens as required by the Second Section of the 14th Amendment.

Why was it constitutional for Obama’s Census Bureau to ask “Is this person a citizen of the United States”, and un-constitutional for today’s Census Bureau to ask the very same question? Keep in mind that Section 2 of the 14th Amendment requires the distinction between citizens and non-citizens to be made with reference to apportionment.

It appears Justice Roberts believes he is vested with a power to strike down laws and policy making decisions that do not meet his personal sense of fairness, reasonableness and justice, which in fact is second guessing our Constitution which actually requires, by Section 2 of the 14th Amendment to make a distinction between citizens and non-citizens with reference to apportionment.

Justice Roberts, who also embraced our federal government entering the states and meddling with the people’s unalienable right to make their own medical choices and decisions, needs to be held accountable for his acts of sedition and personal war against our Constitution.

JWK

"The public welfare demands that constitutional cases must be decided according to the terms of the Constitution itself, and not according to judges’ views of fairness, reasonableness, or justice." – Justice Hugo L. Black ( U.S. Supreme Court Justice, 1886 - 1971) Source: Lecture, Columbia University, 1968

 

[GreenAndBlue]

Men are increasingly getting angry over the lefts lies and cover ups

The left was very stupid to try to win this with lies

The more wise group the men have caught them with their lies and covering up truth which destroys nations progress

The left if any has any logic must run and hide right now because the backlash from their lies is coming

 

[iceberg]

The ACS is not binding on redrawing districts, is not sent to everyone and is used as a test-bed for questions and methods. Who gives a shit? The actual census is key to the balance of power in this country and republicans are ******* with it and telling a bullshit story about why.

So, it was constitutional for Obama to ask the question but now it's not constitutional? Seems to me the Second Section of the 14th Amendment requires a distinction to be made between citizens and non-citizens.

JWK


The Democrat Party Leadership has been angry, stupid and obnoxious ever since the Republican Party Leadership freed democrat owned slaves. ___ Author unknown

So why doesn't president Trump get the information he wants from the ACS???

A correct census helps in many ways and an incorrect census harms in many ways and does not take much logic to understand this

The GDP scores will be faulty with incorrect counts

Health research and studies with patterns and the learning would be incorrect

Should be a world law that only citizens should be counted once and travelers could be counted many times

Justice Roberts has a severe problem of not wanting a nation and world to have prosperity

The question on the census will give you an inaccurate count..

Why do you want an inaccurate census count????

Tell us.

why do you not want to know how many who live here are legal or not?

tell us...wait....

nevermind. just keep on being a pimp for the left but everyone knows your hookers are diseased.

 

[basquebromance]

if you vote for Democrats, they will do what the Robert court does not, which is to protect minorities' voting rights!