Welfare is superior to charity in that it allows the recipient to retain some dignity.
We are entitled to welfare because we have paid our taxes. It is there for all of us and is a right.
1. The argument is that people like those committing crimes that get them stuck in prison at 50K a year (and then can't work but end up on welfare after that) are costing taxpayers who are working and paying in.
Tommy Tainant if we who pay taxes are getting the welfare we are entitled to, then why are people in prison getting their health care and housing paid for by taxes, while people who don't commit crimes are fined for not paying ADDITIONAL money for insurance?
Why isn't our health care already paid for if we are paying 50K a year for each person in prison?
Are you sure these people are paying for what they are getting?
2. what allows DIGNITY is free choice and CONSENT.
so
Tommy Tainant if you CONSENT to pay for welfare through govt, then you see this as dignified. If someone consents to receive welfare this way, they may see it as dignified.
Can you speak for yourself and not assume you speak for others who DON'T consent to keep paying for others while not getting their benefits paid for?
one of my friends, a lifelong Democrat who votes straight D tickets without exception, HATES having to go through the county hospital system and beg for appts at the mercy of govt.
he would LOVE I mean LOVE to have the benefits that people in govt have that is paid for by taxpayers.
His question is why are we paying for officials to have top health care, while they don't give us jack and we are expected to pay higher rates or else be fined?
Where is the dignity in taxation without representation?
Clearly
Tommy Tainant if you believe this represents you and give you a sense of dignity and security, GREAT!
But what about other people?
I have felt like a SLAVE trying to pay the costs of govt, not just the damage done to my neighborhood by govt abuses that nonprofit volunteers had to repair ourselves, but to add the health care insurance mandates ON TOP of what I am already covering was the straw that broke the camel's back.
If you consent to this, that is your choice,
What makes you think you have the right to dictate that for someone else?