Is the best QB in this NFL Draft Spencer Rattler of the Chickens?

[Couchpotato]

LOL!!!

Arch Manning does not have a Peyton/Eli caliber arm, not even close.

Dude you think Rattler was the best QB in last year's draft...

 

[EMH]

Dude you think Rattler was the best QB in last year's draft...

Rattler has a great arm.

Arch Manning doesn't.

Sarkesian is not a stat parroting moron.

 

[Couchpotato]

Rattler has a great arm.

Arch Manning doesn't.

Sarkesian is not a stat parroting moron.

Ok. Ewers will enter the portal and play somewhere else next year and won’t be a legit nfl prospect. Manning will play one year at Texas (maybe 2) and go in the 1st round. As the kids say “you don’t know ball”

 

[Failzero]

My guess is 3 of the Top 5 QB Prospects in this years Draft will go in rounds 3-4

 

[Couchpotato]

My guess is 3 of the Top 5 QB Prospects in this years Draft will go in rounds 3-4

Who are the top 5 in your opinion? I don’t disagree this year is terrible for QBs.

 

[EMH]

Ok. Ewers will enter the portal and play somewhere else next year and won’t be a legit nfl prospect. Manning will play one year at Texas (maybe 2) and go in the 1st round. As the kids say “you don’t know ball”

Ewers just declared for the Draft. Ewers has accuracy but not arm strength. If the Horns had a really top QB this year, they'd be in the finals. They don't.

Arch Manning does not have a great arm, not even close.

Arch Manning looks like a "bum steer" in the Texas Spring Game

Have a look Suckin... Agreed it is early, but it is a Spring Game, should have had some deep throws etc... Arch looks like he is running for his life - hey, it is a Spring Game... Does Arch have what it takes to end the Horns' disasterous record against Vandy?

www.usmessageboard.com

Still not impressed by Arch Manning

Here are Arch's TDs against UTSA. One is a dump, a quality dump, about 8 yards in the air. The best throw is the last one, the "arched" loop to the corner of the endzone. Isaiah Bond has to break off his route and go back to catch weak armed Arch's poor throw. The other is a flutterball...

www.usmessageboard.com

and the first game against UGA Arch had a chance to make a 40 yard Peyton Manning laser for a TD, and the ball hit the ground before the WRs feet....

 

[sealybobo]

I cannot say that he isn't.

Rattler's supporting cast with South Carolina faded this year. That's not his fault. He had his moments but too often was running for his life.

Rattler's performances the year before against Tenn and Clemson were top 5.

Prediction - Rattler ends up going Top 5

Bo Nix. Broncos. He’s playing pretty good for a rookie in a playoff game against the Bills

 

[leftwinger]

Who dat? It ain't the Ratt. I'll tell you that. Though me the money is in. Who dey say Ratt gonna play?

 

[Couchpotato]

Who dat? It ain't the Ratt. I'll tell you that. Though me the money is in. Who dey say Ratt gonna play?

Right now Drake Maye is the leading contender. Dude is an MVP candidate.

 

[leftwinger]

Right now Drake Maye is the leading contender. Dude is an MVP candidate.

Dammmeettt auto correct killed me! Should say...as a rhyme


Who dat? It ain't the Ratt. I'll tell you that. SHOUGH me the money is in. Who dey say Ratt gonna play?

 

[leftwinger]

EMH I think Couchpotato won the thread. Ratt is caged. SHOUGH me da'money is probably doing "better" overall? But with less quickness and escapability, running ability?

 

[Couchpotato]

EMH I think Couchpotato won the thread. Ratt is caged. SHOUGH me da'money is probably doing "better" overall? But with less quickness and escapability, running ability?

The thread wasn’t whether Ratt or Shough was better even. It was whether Ratt was tne best qb in his draft class which is a ridiculous contention. The franchise qb for the Saints isn’t currently on their roster as I’ve said repeatedly in the thread.

 

[leftwinger]

The thread wasn’t whether Ratt or Shough was better even. It was whether Ratt was tne best qb in his draft class which is a ridiculous contention. The franchise qb for the Saints isn’t currently on their roster as I’ve said repeatedly in the thread.

Got it. I understood. The point is RATT lost even that local job, let alone compete with some others.


Who dey'? I'll tell who dey is. Not many right now are on the Ratt. Maybe he gets another shot someday?

 

[Couchpotato]

Got it. I understood. The point is RATT lost even that local job, let alone compete with some others.


Who dey'? I'll tell who dey is. Not many right now are on the Ratt. Maybe he gets another shot someday?

Rattler isn’t a terrible QB. He’s just not a starter in this league. Unless he played for a team that’s loaded with talent and had an offensive genius HC or OC. He will likely be a career back up. Not a bad gig really.

EMH is hiding. Rattler is benched and his team Vandy got run by Arxh Mannibg this weekdn

 

[EMH]

Rattler isn’t a terrible QB. He’s just not a starter in this league. Unless he played for a team that’s loaded with talent and had an offensive genius HC or OC. He will likely be a career back up. Not a bad gig really.

EMH is hiding. Rattler is benched and his team Vandy got run by Arxh Mannibg this weekdn

It wasn't a fun weekend.

 

[Couchpotato]

It wasn't a fun weekend.

When I turned on that Texas v Vandy game in the second half I chuckled a bit Im not going to lie but I did feel bad for ya.

 

[EMH]

When I turned on that Texas v Vandy game in the second half I chuckled a bit Im not going to lie but I did feel bad for ya.

Vandy's D just did not tackle in the first half, especially the first quarter. That really was the difference. Very frustrating...


But well, you and I lived to see Vandy ranked in the AP top 10...

 

[leftwinger]

Vandy's D just did not tackle in the first half, especially the first quarter. That really was the difference. Very frustrating...


But well, you and I lived to see Vandy ranked in the AP top 10...

6-0 first play. Vandy did make a respectable charge to the end.

 

[EMH]

Saints dumped Trevor Penning, their starting OLG, at the end for next to nothing.

Looking at their depth chart, they have Radunz replacing Penning.

I would suggest putting Asim Richards in at OLT and moving Kelvin Banks to OLG, but that's just me.

 

[EMH]

Well, Bo Nix is 8-2 as a starting QB this year.

To me, the Denver D is winning games, and Bo Nix doesn't look anything like a "First Round QB" on the field. Bo Nix is a weak armed system QB, and Denver will never get far in January because of that, same as the Lions with Jared Goff.


Put Bo Nix behind center in NO and the Saints are winless this year...