Is America Ruled By A Socialist?

I think obama is a marxist collectivist. He is also clearly an america-hater, why else would he be so determined to destroy our economy? His latest being his war on coal-------the most stupid thing he has done yet, it will raise unemployment, spark inflation, raise prices of energy, and help our economic enemies, plus it will do absolutely nothing to reduce world wide pollution.
 
I think obama is a marxist collectivist. He is also clearly an america-hater, why else would he be so determined to destroy our economy? His latest being his war on coal-------the most stupid thing he has done yet, it will raise unemployment, spark inflation, raise prices of energy, and help our economic enemies, plus it will do absolutely nothing to reduce world wide pollution.

And how is any of that Marxist though.

We need to remember that term refers to how the means of production is owned.

Please, show ONE SINGLE ACT that has moved the means one inch to the ‘people.’

Essentially, he is NOT Marxist or Socialist. He moves the means of production to an ever decreasing pool of mega corporations that have special legal protections and ties/responsibilities to the government. That is not socialism, it is statist.
 
Socialist ideals help the middle class prosper.


" Marxism rested on the assumption that the condition of the working classes would grow ever worse under capitalism, that there would be but two classes: one small and rich, the other vast and increasingly impoverished, and revolution would be the anodyne that would result in the “common good.”

But by the early 20th century, it was clear that this assumption was completely wrong! Under capitalism, the standard of living of all was improving: prices falling, incomes rising, health and sanitation improving, lengthening of life spans, diets becoming more varied, the new jobs created in industry paid more than most could make in agriculture, housing improved, and middle class industrialists and business owners displaced nobility and gentry as heroes."
From a speech by Rev. Robert A. Sirico, President, Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty.
Delivered at Hillsdale College, October 27, 2006

Bwaaahh Hah Hah! Oh, this is great. Are you talking about the timeframe when the Great Depression occurred or the timeframe afterwards when the socialistic programs of FDR made the middle class thrive? I hope you aren't a history major.
 
Amusing, and a bit puzzling, that at this late stage, and long after the hallmark "...you didn't build that....," almost daily some apologist writes that Obama certainly isn't a socialist.

It's hard to believe there are still people in the world who think that Karl Marx invented wealth redistribution. ...must have been home-schooled or something :rolleyes:

"legislators cannot invent too many devices for subdividing property, only taking care to let their subdivisions go hand in hand with the natural affections of the human mind. The descent of property of every kind therefore to all the children, or to all the brothers and sisters, or other relations in equal degree is a politic measure, and a practicable one. Another means of silently lessening the inequality of property is to exempt all from taxation below a certain point, and to tax the higher portions of property in geometrical progression as they rise."
-- Thomas Jefferson; Letter to James Madison, (Oct. 28, 1785)
 
I think obama is a marxist collectivist. He is also clearly an america-hater, why else would he be so determined to destroy our economy? His latest being his war on coal-------the most stupid thing he has done yet, it will raise unemployment, spark inflation, raise prices of energy, and help our economic enemies, plus it will do absolutely nothing to reduce world wide pollution.

And how is any of that Marxist though.

We need to remember that term refers to how the means of production is owned.

Please, show ONE SINGLE ACT that has moved the means one inch to the ‘people.’

Essentially, he is NOT Marxist or Socialist. He moves the means of production to an ever decreasing pool of mega corporations that have special legal protections and ties/responsibilities to the government. That is not socialism, it is statist.

"from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs" Marx

"I want to redistribute the wealth" "you didn't build that" Obama

so maybe marxist collectivist statist is more accurate.
 
Amusing, and a bit puzzling, that at this late stage, and long after the hallmark "...you didn't build that....," almost daily some apologist writes that Obama certainly isn't a socialist.

It's hard to believe there are still people in the world who think that Karl Marx invented wealth redistribution. ...must have been home-schooled or something :rolleyes:

"legislators cannot invent too many devices for subdividing property, only taking care to let their subdivisions go hand in hand with the natural affections of the human mind. The descent of property of every kind therefore to all the children, or to all the brothers and sisters, or other relations in equal degree is a politic measure, and a practicable one. Another means of silently lessening the inequality of property is to exempt all from taxation below a certain point, and to tax the higher portions of property in geometrical progression as they rise."
-- Thomas Jefferson; Letter to James Madison, (Oct. 28, 1785)

no one said that Marx invented it, only that he believed in it. progressive income taxation is certainly redistributive.
 
If we ever find out what socialism really is, then we can name the first real American socialist president.
I have a feeling it will be Washington, I mean the guy put tariffs on parts of our imports to help business. Is that socialism or what? If it wasn't Washington, how about Jefferson, I mean borrowing money to buy all that land and making the country twice as big. If not Jefferson, there is no end to the socialist presidents, how about Jackson, Teddy Roosevelt, even Harding. I mean Harding gave Standard oil some oil that belonged to the navy, sounds like socialism to me. And who did Marx write congratulation letters to, Lincoln that's who. FDR is always good for being called a socialist, I mean Social Security and all that stuff. What of IKE and his road building socialism, or Obama and Obama-care? Maybe when we know what socialism really is, we should see what American president was not a socialist?
 
Amusing, and a bit puzzling, that at this late stage, and long after the hallmark "...you didn't build that....," almost daily some apologist writes that Obama certainly isn't a socialist.

It's hard to believe there are still people in the world who think that Karl Marx invented wealth redistribution. ...must have been home-schooled or something :rolleyes:

"legislators cannot invent too many devices for subdividing property, only taking care to let their subdivisions go hand in hand with the natural affections of the human mind. The descent of property of every kind therefore to all the children, or to all the brothers and sisters, or other relations in equal degree is a politic measure, and a practicable one. Another means of silently lessening the inequality of property is to exempt all from taxation below a certain point, and to tax the higher portions of property in geometrical progression as they rise."
-- Thomas Jefferson; Letter to James Madison, (Oct. 28, 1785)

no one said that Marx invented it, only that he believed in it. progressive income taxation is certainly redistributive.

Fair enough. Maybe we don't need to call everyone who believes in redistribution "Marxist" though.
 
I think obama is a marxist collectivist. He is also clearly an america-hater, why else would he be so determined to destroy our economy? His latest being his war on coal-------the most stupid thing he has done yet, it will raise unemployment, spark inflation, raise prices of energy, and help our economic enemies, plus it will do absolutely nothing to reduce world wide pollution.

And how is any of that Marxist though.

We need to remember that term refers to how the means of production is owned.

Please, show ONE SINGLE ACT that has moved the means one inch to the ‘people.’

Essentially, he is NOT Marxist or Socialist. He moves the means of production to an ever decreasing pool of mega corporations that have special legal protections and ties/responsibilities to the government. That is not socialism, it is statist.

"from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs" Marx

"I want to redistribute the wealth" "you didn't build that" Obama

so maybe marxist collectivist statist is more accurate.

I think Trojan Horse would be most accurate. In words, Obama proposes programs that would help the middle class thrive. In deeds, not so much.
 
Last edited:
And how is any of that Marxist though.

We need to remember that term refers to how the means of production is owned.

Please, show ONE SINGLE ACT that has moved the means one inch to the ‘people.’

Essentially, he is NOT Marxist or Socialist. He moves the means of production to an ever decreasing pool of mega corporations that have special legal protections and ties/responsibilities to the government. That is not socialism, it is statist.

"from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs" Marx

"I want to redistribute the wealth" "you didn't build that" Obama

so maybe marxist collectivist statist is more accurate.

I think Trojan Horse would be most accurate. In words, Obama proposes programs that would help the middle class thrive. In deeds, not so much.

really??? high unemployment helps the middle class? high taxes help the middle class? high fuel prices help the middle class? highest ever poverty rates help the middle class? highest ever numbers on food stamps help the middle class? a divided country helps the middle class? the war on coal helps the middle class? shipping jobs to china and mexico helps the middle class? open borders and amnesty helps the middle class?

damn, seems to me everything obama has done has hurt the middle class and helped his rich buddies.
 
"from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs" Marx

"I want to redistribute the wealth" "you didn't build that" Obama

so maybe marxist collectivist statist is more accurate.

I think Trojan Horse would be most accurate. In words, Obama proposes programs that would help the middle class thrive. In deeds, not so much.

really??? high unemployment helps the middle class? high taxes help the middle class? high fuel prices help the middle class? highest ever poverty rates help the middle class? highest ever numbers on food stamps help the middle class? a divided country helps the middle class? the war on coal helps the middle class? shipping jobs to china and mexico helps the middle class? open borders and amnesty helps the middle class?

damn, seems to me everything obama has done has hurt the middle class and helped his rich buddies.

These are the byproducts of corporatism. You just reinforced my point.
 
I think obama is a marxist collectivist. He is also clearly an america-hater, why else would he be so determined to destroy our economy? His latest being his war on coal-------the most stupid thing he has done yet, it will raise unemployment, spark inflation, raise prices of energy, and help our economic enemies, plus it will do absolutely nothing to reduce world wide pollution.


Ding! Ding! Ding ! Ding!

We have a winner!!

The primary phrase in your assessment is "america-hater".
 
I think obama is a marxist collectivist. He is also clearly an america-hater, why else would he be so determined to destroy our economy? His latest being his war on coal-------the most stupid thing he has done yet, it will raise unemployment, spark inflation, raise prices of energy, and help our economic enemies, plus it will do absolutely nothing to reduce world wide pollution.


Ding! Ding! Ding ! Ding!

We have a winner!!

The primary phrase in your assessment is "america-hater".

There are plenty of good reasons to limit particulate emissions

Jacobin Reason: Elections and the Valuation of Life
 
We are not ruled by anyone.


I always find it ironic when I have to teach their language to native English-speakers.
But....Noblesse oblige, I suppose.

ruled past participle, past tense of rule (Verb)
Verb
Exercise ultimate power or authority over (an area and its people): "Latin America today is ruled by elected politicians".
(of a feeling) Have a powerful and restricting influence on (a person's life): "her whole life seemed to be ruled by fear".
 
Well when all the definitions, cute phrases and attempts to confuse are done and the smoke clears we find most of the world economies are a mixture of socialism and capitalism, and every nation has a system for the redistribution of wealth. We also find that few of us can define socialism beyond the dictionary definition, and some only use Marx's Scientific Socialism as the definition.


"....we find most of the world economies are a mixture of socialism and capitalism,...."

The issue comes down to where the fulcrum is.

For Obama....that position is clearly marked.


Try to be more astute.
 
so·cial·ism noun \ˈsō-shə-ˌli-zəm\

Definition of SOCIALISM

1
: any of various economic and political theories advocating collective or governmental ownership and administration of the means of production and distribution of goods
2
a : a system of society or group living in which there is no private property
b : a system or condition of society in which the means of production are owned and controlled by the state
3
: a stage of society in Marxist theory transitional between capitalism and communism and distinguished by unequal distribution of goods and pay according to work done
Socialism - Definition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary

OK PC, using the definition of socialism, please gives us precise examples that match up with the definition. And please, no cut and paste right wing talking points.

Thank you.




1. "OK PC, using the definition of socialism, ...."
Yours, of course, is the sophomoric obfuscation used to hide the facts.
Fully expected from the inept.

I'll stick with the well-constructed OP above, which includes the words of the socialist President, himself.




2. "....please gives us precise examples that match up with the definition."

Why is it that the most effete of individuals find it necessary to resort to "us"....when they mean "me"?

Oh...I've answered my own question!

“Life is a mystery, everyone must stand alone.” Madonna.





3. "And please, no cut and paste right wing talking points."

As far as you influencing my style…I am immovable, like General Jackson’s Virginians at First Manassas: a veritable stone wall.
If you only had an acquaintance with history…you’d understand that.

There may come a time when you can dictate how and what I post.....but, when that happens, I'll probably be ice skating in Hell.



Based on the caliber of post, you should concentrate on your full-time job, Garden Gnome.

In other words, you have nothing, so you do what you usually do as demonstrated in your closing comment. Way to go! :clap2:



"In other words,...."

In what bizzarro world would a dunce like you have even the most tortuous claim to articulate a point more accurately than I????


No other words are necessary.....mine are fine.

I say what I mean, and mean what I say.
Get someone brighter than you to explain what you don't understand.
Any grade school will provide said candidates.
 
1. "OK PC, using the definition of socialism, ...."
Yours, of course, is the sophomoric obfuscation used to hide the facts.
Fully expected from the inept.

I'll stick with the well-constructed OP above, which includes the words of the socialist President, himself.




2. "....please gives us precise examples that match up with the definition."

Why is it that the most effete of individuals find it necessary to resort to "us"....when they mean "me"?

Oh...I've answered my own question!

“Life is a mystery, everyone must stand alone.” Madonna.





3. "And please, no cut and paste right wing talking points."

As far as you influencing my style…I am immovable, like General Jackson’s Virginians at First Manassas: a veritable stone wall.
If you only had an acquaintance with history…you’d understand that.

There may come a time when you can dictate how and what I post.....but, when that happens, I'll probably be ice skating in Hell.



Based on the caliber of post, you should concentrate on your full-time job, Garden Gnome.

In other words, you have nothing, so you do what you usually do as demonstrated in your closing comment. Way to go! :clap2:



"In other words,...."

In what bizzarro world would a dunce like you have even the most tortuous claim to articulate a point more accurately than I????


No other words are necessary.....mine are fine.

I say what I mean, and mean what I say.
Get someone brighter than you to explain what you don't understand.
Any grade school will provide said candidates.

He's banned from school yards
 

Forum List

Back
Top