Immigrants pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits from the US government

Immigrants, both legal and illegal but not US citizens, pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits from the US government.
A study by the Cato Institute, a right leaning Libertarian think tank, provides data on immigrants in the USA.
Please read the study for accurate assessment of immigrants in the USA. That is not to say that there arebad ones that should be deported bu that is a minority.


View attachment 1215294

LOL todays' broadbrushing of LEGAL and ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS. You guys never stop with the bull crap. I just call it out.
 
Not everything is as simple as a cost/benefit comparison though. I mean illegal drugs probably add a lot to economic velocity, but we shouldn't just turn a blind eye to it.
Correct. This ios one metric to look at in the big picture on determining what to do.

With all metric we want the most accurate information possible.

There is a lot of incorrect information and information based on emotion.
 
LOL todays' broadbrushing of LEGAL and ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS. You guys never stop with the bull crap. I just call it out.
The study was done by the Cato Institute. Do you know who the Cato Institute is. Do you know those "guys ... with 'bull crap".

The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank. The mission of the Cato Institute is to originate, disseminate, and increase understanding of public policies based on the principles of individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.

MAGA is a bunch of fake conservatives who follow Trump's bullshit and not true conservative, libertarian philosophy.
FAKE REPUBLICANS.
 
The study was done by the Cato Institute. Do you know who the Cato Institute is. Do you know those "guys ... with 'bull crap".

The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank. The mission of the Cato Institute is to originate, disseminate, and increase understanding of public policies based on the principles of individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.

MAGA is a bunch of fake conservatives who follow Trump's bullshit and not true conservative, libertarian philosophy.
FAKE REPUBLICANS.
When I read "think tank" I see "stink tank". They don't impress me at all. And you like all other Trump/MAGA haters rely on broad brushing to convince yourselves that everyone who doesn't share your political beliefs is a redneck moron who lives in a trailer. That is just absurd.
 
Correct. This ios one metric to look at in the big picture on determining what to do.

With all metric we want the most accurate information possible.

There is a lot of incorrect information and information based on emotion.
Logical goals can flow from emotions though. I mean that has been my journey on the issue. When I was a little one, we used to have regular inflows and outflows of migrant workers mainly related to tobacco prior to the ending of the allotment system. I thought Mexicans were weird and a bit scary I suppose, and maybe that is what drives some people's views today. I, however, as an adult have read many stories over the years where illegal migrant workers have really been victimized by catastrophic work-related injuries and such. The logical position I now take is very much driven by those stories really pissing me off. I think we need to do whatever we need to do to get immigrants in legally to service the industries they work in in the numbers we need them. We should also get rid of the illegals just as a matter of health and safety alone.
 
When I read "think tank" I see "stink tank". They don't impress me at all. And you like all other Trump/MAGA haters rely on broad brushing to convince yourselves that everyone who doesn't share your political beliefs is a redneck moron who lives in a trailer. That is just absurd.
The words of a stupid person. Think, is something you don't do.
Smart people learn as much as they can. They then decide what they believe by knowing all sides of an issue. That requires thinking and reading and learning. Something stupid people are too lazy to do.
 
They cannot possibly pay more taxes than the services they use.https://www.frontpagemag.com/migrants-cost-3x-times-as-much-as-they-pay-in-taxes/

Their children alone use more in services than the miniscule taxes they pay.
 
Immigrants, both legal and illegal but not US citizens, pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits from the US government.
A study by the Cato Institute, a right leaning Libertarian think tank, provides data on immigrants in the USA.
Please read the study for accurate assessment of immigrants in the USA. That is not to say that there arebad ones that should be deported bu that is a minority.


View attachment 1215294

Bullshit
 
No it is not misleading.

You grouped people here legally with illegal aliens. You knew that illegals are drain so you did that to mask to the truth. Stop gaslighting, ElmerPudd.
 
You grouped people here legally with illegal aliens. You knew that illegals are drain so you did that to mask to the truth. Stop gaslighting, ElmerPudd.
The study was done by the Cato Institute. Do you know who the Cato Institute is. Do you know those "guys ... with 'bull crap".

The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank. The mission of the Cato Institute is to originate, disseminate, and increase understanding of public policies based on the principles of individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.

MAGA is a bunch of fake conservatives who follow Trump's bullshit and not true conservative, libertarian philosophy.
FAKE REPUBLICANS.
 
Immigrants, both legal and illegal but not US citizens, pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits from the US government.
A study by the Cato Institute, a right leaning Libertarian think tank, provides data on immigrants in the USA.
Please read the study for accurate assessment of immigrants in the USA. That is not to say that there arebad ones that should be deported bu that is a minority.


View attachment 1215294

Attach files
Based on census data that didn't allow the question of citizenship to be asked or verified. Very nice.
 
Immigrants, both legal and illegal but not US citizens, pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits from the US government.
A study by the Cato Institute, a right leaning Libertarian think tank, provides data on immigrants in the USA.
Please read the study for accurate assessment of immigrants in the USA. That is not to say that there arebad ones that should be deported bu that is a minority.


View attachment 1215294

Complete bullshit....

Sooo they think they can just add up the section 8 food stamp and Medicaid s*** and come to a balanced answer? They also need to include the cram on the housing market, subsequent drive up of healthcare costs and the burden on public municipalities.... Added up correctly the entire ratio changes up 300% leaving you with a two to one deficit. So you can take your politically motivated poll SHOVE IT UP YOUR ILLEGAL LOVING ASS..... WHILE YOU'RE AT IT MAKE SURE YOU HAVE A SPARE BEDROOM FILLED PACO, WIFE AND KIDS.
 
Claiming illegals pay more taxes then they cost is like saying cancer is good for you
 
"Legal" immigrants are being deported. Do you know the difference between legal and illegal immigrants?

There may be a mistake here and there, but a legal immigrant being deported is an anomaly. Only those that have committed immigration violations or crimes are being deported. In both of those cases, they are eligible for deportation under immigration law. Some are detained while being investigated.

People here ins his country illegally are the overwhelming majority of those that are being deported.
 
They cannot possibly pay more taxes than the services they use.https://www.frontpagemag.com/migrants-cost-3x-times-as-much-as-they-pay-in-taxes/

Their children alone use more in services than the miniscule taxes they pay.
Of course they do. This is why he didn't grouped
The study was done by the Cato Institute. Do you know who the Cato Institute is. Do you know those "guys ... with 'bull crap".

The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank. The mission of the Cato Institute is to originate, disseminate, and increase understanding of public policies based on the principles of individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.

MAGA is a bunch of fake conservatives who follow Trump's bullshit and not true conservative, libertarian philosophy.
FAKE REPUBLICANS.
Are you admitting that illegal aliens are a net drain, little pud?
 
15th post
Of course they do. This is why he didn't grouped

Are you admitting that illegal aliens are a net drain, little pud?
You cannot handle the truth. There is still an argument for deportation but this study must be considered. MAGA cannot handle complexity. They are simple minded people living in a complex world. As hard as they try, they cannot chaange the truth.
The study was done by the Cato Institute. Do you know who the Cato Institute is. Do you know those "guys ... with 'bull crap".

The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank. The mission of the Cato Institute is to originate, disseminate, and increase understanding of public policies based on the principles of individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.

MAGA is a bunch of fake conservatives who follow Trump's bullshit and not true conservative, libertarian philosophy.
FAKE REPUBLICANS.
 
"Legal" immigrants are being deported.

Aliens don't magically become legal because Biden wished it into being so, stupid. President Trump now has full authority to render all such declarations by that senile Biden null and void.
 
You cannot handle the truth. There is still an argument for deportation but this study must be considered. MAGA cannot handle complexity.
There is no "complexity" you stupid douche. Aliens are here legally or they are here illegally. Illegal aliens and their offspring are a massive drain on the American taxpayers. Deport yourself to Mexico, FAGAt.
 

There is no "complexity" you stupid douche. Aliens are here legally or they are here illegally. Illegal aliens and their offspring are a massive drain on the American taxpayers. Deport yourself to Mexico, FAGAt.
Your grasp of the english language shows who you are. I completely understand why you are a member of Trump's cult. I will send you the truth one more time. I doubt you will ever accept the truth. That requires more intelligence than you have.

You cannot handle the truth. There is still an argument for deportation but this study must be considered. MAGA cannot handle complexity. They are simple minded people living in a complex world. As hard as they try, they cannot chaange the truth.
The study was done by the Cato Institute. Do you know who the Cato Institute is. Do you know those "guys ... with 'bull crap".

The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank. The mission of the Cato Institute is to originate, disseminate, and increase understanding of public policies based on the principles of individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.

MAGA is a bunch of fake conservatives who follow Trump's bullshit and not true conservative, libertarian philosophy.
FAKE REPUBLICANS.
 
Back
Top Bottom