How do we Know Human are Causing Climate Change?

[ReinyDays]

The temperature traces in post #1038 and #1040 are different ...

Can't you remember which side of your mouth you're lying out of ...

"Fourth root" ... HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW ...

 

[abu afak]

The temperature traces in post #1038 and #1040 are different ...

Can't you remember which side of your mouth you're lying out of ...

"Fourth root" ... HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW HAW ...

No they're not goofy.
the short term ones the same, the longer different time and scale of course.
And you are 1000% wrong about your claim of cooling
Not that on any given short period it could cool.
It's not going to up every year or even every ten.
Just that it will indeed be going up and be warmer than it was going to e due to the increasingly thick CO2/GHG Blanket

Go away 80 IQ boy.
`

`

 

[ReinyDays]

No they're not goofy.
the short term ones the same, the longer different time and scale of course.
And you are 1000% wrong about your claim of cooling
Not that on any given short period it could cool.
It's not going to up every year or even every ten.
Just that it will indeed be going up and be warmer than it was going to e due to the increasingly thick CO2/GHG Blanket

Go away 80 IQ boy.
`

`

NOAA's data ...

You'll never be able to admit 1941 was 0.3ºC warmer than 1976 ... in spite CO2 levels having increased through that whole time interval ... sad ... God forbid you inflict that much harm to your own ego ... she bruises so easily ... dT/dt < 0 ha ha ha ha ha ha ...

I do agree with you that these 40 year time intervals are too short ... I'm just pointing out this 40 year time interval is also too short for any claims of global warming ...

 

[abu afak]

NOAA's data ...

You'll never be able to admit 1941 was 0.3ºC warmer than 1976 ... in spite CO2 levels having increased through that whole time interval ... sad ... God forbid you inflict that much harm to your own ego ... she bruises so easily ... dT/dt < 0 ha ha ha ha ha ha ...

I do agree with you that these 40 year time intervals are too short ... I'm just pointing out this 40 year time interval is also too short for any claims of global warming ...

You are an IDIOT
I'd be glad to admit any given year was warmer than one with more CO2/GHGs 35 yrs later.
WTF!
That's an anomaly, perhaps a year of high/peak solar activity, etc.
WTF!
It might even get colder for a number of years during a general uptrend. (solar minimum in app 2017) The sun has 11 yr cycles... and longer ones too.

All things remaining the same WE are warming the earth.

The GHG Blanket gets thicker (PPM) every year so whatever happens in the way of other cycles/anomalies, it was warmer than it would have been without the CO2.
The more CO2, the bigger the warming difference.
So you are seeing the general uptrend expected, over 150 years, over 500,000 years.

Can YOU Admit that OUR huge CO2/CH4 emissions is making it warmer. AGW.
Yes or No.

`

 

[CrusaderFrank]

Why Yes, I do have evidence. Strong Evidence.
(Science does not deal in 'proof,' really only math does/can.)
(Science deals in theories affirmed over time)
You were in this thread and could NOT dent it.

The OP and many individual posts of mine and others throughout.
Much more extensive than your goofy Thwaites ANECDOTAL argument.

You faux-participated in it but it was way over your head, and you would rather keep your politics than learn the Truth.

`

Strong evidence = ignore any and all questions

"The truth does not mind being questioned. A lie does not like being challenged”

“A reliable way to make people believe in falsehoods is frequent repetition, because familiarity is not easily distinguished from truth." -- Daniel Kahneman Sounds like he's talking about all the "science" behind Manmade Global Climate Warming Change

 

[CrusaderFrank]

You are an IDIOT
I'd be glad to admit any given year was warmer than one with more CO2/GHGs 35 yrs later.
WTF!
That's an anomaly, perhaps a year of high/peak solar activity, etc.
WTF!
It might even get colder for a number of years during a general uptrend. (solar minimum in app 2017) The sun has 11 yr cycles... and longer ones too.

All things remaining the same WE are warming the earth.

The GHG Blanket gets thicker (PPM) every year so whatever happens in the way of other cycles/anomalies, it was warmer than it would have been without the CO2.
The more CO2, the bigger the warming difference.
So you are seeing the general uptrend expected, over 150 years, over 500,000 years.

Can YOU Admit that OUR huge CO2/CH4 emissions is making it warmer. AGW.
Yes or No.

`

CO2 is making it "warmer" but has stage fright whenever we ask it to show the temperature increase in a laboratory

 

[abu afak]

CO2 is making it "warmer" but has stage fright whenever we ask it to show the temperature increase in a laboratory

You can do it/prove it at home goofy.

How Exactly Does Carbon Dioxide Cause Global Warming?​

https://news.climate.columbia.edu › 2021/02/25 › carbo...
Feb 25, 2021 — A better experiment would be to have 3 large containers – one containing earth's atmosphere with no CO2, one with atmosphere of 0.025% CO2 and ...

The Carbon Dioxide Greenhouse Effect - American Institute of ...​

https://history.aip.org › climate › co2
Arrhenius brought up the possibility of future warming in an impressive scientific ... The early experiments that sent radiation through gases in a tube, ...
‎The Theory Restored (1950... · ‎Carbon Dioxide: Key to... · ‎Evidence from the Ice

Global warming and climate change – an experimental ...​

http://www.carboeurope.org › CS_Materials › Ber...

Experiment 3. Radiation determines temperature (3). Aim: to demonstrate how CO2 gas absorbs heat rays more than normal "air": CO2- gas is "thermally darker" ...
24 pages

Climate Change Inquiry Labs: CO2 and Air Temperature​

https://gpm.nasa.gov › files › lesson_plan_files

NOTE: The plastic wrap is representing carbon dioxide in the model used for the experiment. Greenhouse gases don't hold in heat exactly the same way as the ...
2 pages

Demos & Experiments | NOAA Climate.gov​

http://www.climate.gov › teaching › demos-experiments
Results 1 - 10 of 88 — Summary: This is a short experiment to demonstrate the concept of ... an analogy to thermal expansion of oceans due to global warming.

Millennium time-scale experiments on climate-carbon cycle ...​

https://progearthplanetsci.springeropen.com › articles
by T Hajima · 2020 · Cited by 1 — Thus, in the BGC2 × CO2 experiment, there was no global warming induced by CO2 concentration increase, and direct stimulation of CO2 ...

Global Warming Experiment thermal propeties carbon dioxide ...​

https://www.picotech.com › library › global-warming
Experiment setup · Prepare plastic pop bottles by removing the labels and drilling holes in the tops big enough to allow the temperature probes to go through.

The Greenhouse Effect Experiment and Lesson for Kids​

https://www.steampoweredfamily.com › activities › the-gr...
In this experiment we are trapping the carbon dioxide gas in the jar. When heat is applied, the carbon dioxide traps more heat in the jar ...


Basically you are all STUPID.
You can't even use google, which is why you have wrong opinions and a 95% Info deficit.

 

[CrusaderFrank]

You can do it/prove it at home goofy.

How Exactly Does Carbon Dioxide Cause Global Warming?​

https://news.climate.columbia.edu › 2021/02/25 › carbo...
Feb 25, 2021 — A better experiment would be to have 3 large containers – one containing earth's atmosphere with no CO2, one with atmosphere of 0.025% CO2 and ...

The Carbon Dioxide Greenhouse Effect - American Institute of ...​

https://history.aip.org › climate › co2
Arrhenius brought up the possibility of future warming in an impressive scientific ... The early experiments that sent radiation through gases in a tube, ...
‎The Theory Restored (1950... · ‎Carbon Dioxide: Key to... · ‎Evidence from the Ice

Global warming and climate change – an experimental ...​

http://www.carboeurope.org › CS_Materials › Ber...

Experiment 3. Radiation determines temperature (3). Aim: to demonstrate how CO2 gas absorbs heat rays more than normal "air": CO2- gas is "thermally darker" ...
24 pages

Climate Change Inquiry Labs: CO2 and Air Temperature​

https://gpm.nasa.gov › files › lesson_plan_files

NOTE: The plastic wrap is representing carbon dioxide in the model used for the experiment. Greenhouse gases don't hold in heat exactly the same way as the ...
2 pages

Demos & Experiments | NOAA Climate.gov​

http://www.climate.gov › teaching › demos-experiments
Results 1 - 10 of 88 — Summary: This is a short experiment to demonstrate the concept of ... an analogy to thermal expansion of oceans due to global warming.

Millennium time-scale experiments on climate-carbon cycle ...​

https://progearthplanetsci.springeropen.com › articles
by T Hajima · 2020 · Cited by 1 — Thus, in the BGC2 × CO2 experiment, there was no global warming induced by CO2 concentration increase, and direct stimulation of CO2 ...

Global Warming Experiment thermal propeties carbon dioxide ...​

https://www.picotech.com › library › global-warming
Experiment setup · Prepare plastic pop bottles by removing the labels and drilling holes in the tops big enough to allow the temperature probes to go through.

The Greenhouse Effect Experiment and Lesson for Kids​

https://www.steampoweredfamily.com › activities › the-gr...
In this experiment we are trapping the carbon dioxide gas in the jar. When heat is applied, the carbon dioxide traps more heat in the jar ...


Basically you are all STUPID.
You can't even use google, which is why you have wrong opinions and a 95% Info deficit.

All that "science" and not one test of varying CO2 from 280 to 400

“A reliable way to make people believe in falsehoods is frequent repetition, because familiarity is not easily distinguished from truth." -- Daniel Kahneman Sounds like he's talking about all the "science" behind Manmade Global Climate Warming Change

 

[CrusaderFrank]

You can do it/prove it at home goofy.

How Exactly Does Carbon Dioxide Cause Global Warming?​

https://news.climate.columbia.edu › 2021/02/25 › carbo...
Feb 25, 2021 — A better experiment would be to have 3 large containers – one containing earth's atmosphere with no CO2, one with atmosphere of 0.025% CO2 and ...

The Carbon Dioxide Greenhouse Effect - American Institute of ...​

https://history.aip.org › climate › co2
Arrhenius brought up the possibility of future warming in an impressive scientific ... The early experiments that sent radiation through gases in a tube, ...
‎The Theory Restored (1950... · ‎Carbon Dioxide: Key to... · ‎Evidence from the Ice

Global warming and climate change – an experimental ...​

http://www.carboeurope.org › CS_Materials › Ber...

Experiment 3. Radiation determines temperature (3). Aim: to demonstrate how CO2 gas absorbs heat rays more than normal "air": CO2- gas is "thermally darker" ...
24 pages

Climate Change Inquiry Labs: CO2 and Air Temperature​

https://gpm.nasa.gov › files › lesson_plan_files

NOTE: The plastic wrap is representing carbon dioxide in the model used for the experiment. Greenhouse gases don't hold in heat exactly the same way as the ...
2 pages

Demos & Experiments | NOAA Climate.gov​

http://www.climate.gov › teaching › demos-experiments
Results 1 - 10 of 88 — Summary: This is a short experiment to demonstrate the concept of ... an analogy to thermal expansion of oceans due to global warming.

Millennium time-scale experiments on climate-carbon cycle ...​

https://progearthplanetsci.springeropen.com › articles
by T Hajima · 2020 · Cited by 1 — Thus, in the BGC2 × CO2 experiment, there was no global warming induced by CO2 concentration increase, and direct stimulation of CO2 ...

Global Warming Experiment thermal propeties carbon dioxide ...​

https://www.picotech.com › library › global-warming
Experiment setup · Prepare plastic pop bottles by removing the labels and drilling holes in the tops big enough to allow the temperature probes to go through.

The Greenhouse Effect Experiment and Lesson for Kids​

https://www.steampoweredfamily.com › activities › the-gr...
In this experiment we are trapping the carbon dioxide gas in the jar. When heat is applied, the carbon dioxide traps more heat in the jar ...


Basically you are all STUPID.
You can't even use google, which is why you have wrong opinions and a 95% Info deficit.

Squid Ink response, just post dozens of off topic links

 

[Oddball]

It might even get colder for a number of years during a general uptrend. (solar minimum in app 2017) The sun has 11 yr cycles... and longer ones too.

All things remaining the same WE are warming the earth.


`

 

[abu afak]

All that "science" and not one test of varying CO2 from 280 to 400

“A reliable way to make people believe in falsehoods is frequent repetition, because familiarity is not easily distinguished from truth." -- Daniel Kahneman Sounds like he's talking about all the "science" behind Manmade Global Climate Warming Change

AGAIN you low IQ Heel-nipper, That's an idiotic DEMAND DETAIL FALLACY that cannot be done due to the myriad of other factors in Gigantic multi-faceted system.

Of course and again we have actual data from Millions of years of earth's history showing the relationship/LOCK STEP CORRELATION of temp and CO2.
And of course (in the shorter term) it would make a big difference whether you were at the beginning of a cycle/gaining CO2, middle/stable, or end/losing CO2 as to what the temperature is relative to a given amount of CO2.

And also again we know from BOTH Lab experiments and RL CO2 traps heat.
The more CO2, the more trapping.

You lost TROLL.

`

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

And also again we know from BOTH Lab experiments and RL CO2 traps heat.
The more CO2, the more trapping.

CO2 levels are up about 50% since the mid 1700s.
Is the atmosphere trapping 50% more?

 

[CrusaderFrank]

AGAIN you low IQ Heel-nipper, That's an idiotic DEMAND DETAIL FALLACY that cannot be done due to the myriad of other factors in Gigantic multi-faceted system.

Of course and again we have actual data from Millions of years of earth's history showing the relationship/LOCK STEP CORRELATION of temp and CO2.
And of course (in the shorter term) it would make a big difference whether you were at the beginning of a cycle/gaining CO2, middle/stable, or end/losing CO2 as to what the temperature is relative to a given amount of CO2.

And also again we know from BOTH Lab experiments and RL CO2 traps heat.
The more CO2, the more trapping.

You lost TROLL.

`

So you basically said that there are too many variables to control for a change in CO2.

You see that, right?

 

[CrusaderFrank]

AGAIN you low IQ Heel-nipper, That's an idiotic DEMAND DETAIL FALLACY that cannot be done due to the myriad of other factors in Gigantic multi-faceted system.

Of course and again we have actual data from Millions of years of earth's history showing the relationship/LOCK STEP CORRELATION of temp and CO2.
And of course (in the shorter term) it would make a big difference whether you were at the beginning of a cycle/gaining CO2, middle/stable, or end/losing CO2 as to what the temperature is relative to a given amount of CO2.

And also again we know from BOTH Lab experiments and RL CO2 traps heat.
The more CO2, the more trapping.

You lost TROLL.

`

The CO2 and temperature dataset to which you refer shows CO2 LAGGING temperature by 800 to 1,000 years.

 

[abu afak]

So you basically said that there are too many variables to control for a change in CO2.

You see that, right?

We have the climate record which is beyond clear, it's Over-******-whelming and and parallel.

Take your pick you stupid Piece of ****.

temperature co2 - Google Search

What does that demonstrate to any sane person?


`

 

[ding]

We have the climate record which is beyond clear, it's Over-******-whelming and and parallel.

Take your pick you stupid Piece of ****.

temperature co2 - Google Search

What does that demonstrate to any sane person?


`

The climate record overwhelmingly shows that CO2 never drove climate change.

 

[ding]

CO2 is making it "warmer" but has stage fright whenever we ask it to show the temperature increase in a laboratory

That's a good one.

 

[ding]

You are just going to have to take their word that if they ever did do an experiment the published report would match their claim perfectly. The actual recorded temperatures, not so much.

 

[abu afak]

Greenhouse gas - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

A greenhouse gas (GHG or GhG) is a gas that absorbs and emits radiant energy within the thermal infrared range, causing the greenhouse effect.[1]
The primary greenhouse gases in Earth's atmosphere are water vapor (H2O), carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), and ozone (O3).

Without greenhouse gases, the average temperature of Earth's surface would be about −18 °C (0 °F),[2] rather than the present average of 15 °C (59 °F).[3][4][5] The atmospheres of Venus, Mars and Titan also contain greenhouse gases.

Human activities since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution (around 1750) have increased the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide by almost 50%, from 280 ppm in 1750 to 419 ppm in 2021.[6]

The last time the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide was this high was over 3 million years ago.[7] This increase has occurred despite the absorption of more than half of the emissions by various natural carbon sinks in the carbon cycle.[8][9]......

`

 

[Oddball]

Greenhouse gas - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

A greenhouse gas (GHG or GhG) is a gas that absorbs and emits radiant energy within the thermal infrared range, causing the greenhouse effect.[1]
The primary greenhouse gases in Earth's atmosphere are water vapor (H2O), carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), and ozone (O3).

Without greenhouse gases, the average temperature of Earth's surface would be about −18 °C (0 °F),[2] rather than the present average of 15 °C (59 °F).[3][4][5] The atmospheres of Venus, Mars and Titan also contain greenhouse gases.

Human activities since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution (around 1750) have increased the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide by almost 50%, from 280 ppm in 1750 to 419 ppm in 2021.[6]

The last time the atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide was this high was over 3 million years ago.[7] This increase has occurred despite the absorption of more than half of the emissions by various natural carbon sinks in the carbon cycle.[8][9]......

`

Nobody here thought that the goalposts were going to move themselves.