"...I'm sure you are...wrong."
Having observed first-hand (
as a staffer of a national-scale charitable feeding agency and a social-services agency - both with a disaster-relief component to their missions) a great many folks coming to the scene of disasters such as Hurricanes Andrew and Katrina with car-loads or truck-loads of donated foodstuffs and clothing and blankets and bottled water and the like...
And seeing multiple relief agencies accept these donations of questionable quality and value just to get the donors out of their hair without offending them, and then dumping the donated goods in dumpsters or at the landfill due to safety and sanitation and health concerns, soon after the donors were out of sight, because they had more than enough to go around from their new-commodities inventories and warehouses and event-driven purchasing... and seeing various corporate executives and politicians pimp themselves out for photo-ops and sound and video bytes designed to portray them in a favorable light, and watching the warm smiles turn back to cold, steely-eyed arrogance the minute the cameras were turned back off again...
I have some modest basis in fact and previous experience, for making the observations that I did...
You are welcome to share with the class whatever experiences that you have in a similar vein, that you believe might trump such experience or render it obsolete or unserviceable...
Perhaps you know something that I don't about such matters...
ETA...
Oh, and BTW...
I don't know Beck from Adam... I listen to a handful of both Conservative and Liberal radio commentators from time to time, and have probably heard Beck from time to time, while flipping the channels, but I'm neither a listener nor a fan
nor a detractor...
I am coming at this from the generic angle of the cynicism I have acquired in observing minor celebrities and politicians imposing themselves upon disaster sites more to be seen and portrayed favorably than as a matter of providing humanitarian relief (
which is being done quite well by others, anyway)...
I don't give a rat's ass whether it's Rachel Madcow or Lush Limpbow or whatever... I don't care... I'm just sayin' that most of these jokers feed on such opportunities to enhance their reps... nuthin' against talk-radio demigod A or B or C... hope that helps.