KT McFarland outraged by Dempsey s Ramadi remarks On Air Videos Fox News
Why can't we win a war when we have a Democrat led government? People should go to jail for screwing up what our troops fought and died for. We should all be disgusted with Obama and his weak ass followers including this phony General.
I would prefer a commander of the Joint Chiefs that had actually seen combat in a combat arms capacity. Since when do we promote generals to make such crucial decisions on the lives of troops when the generals haven't seen combat?
Where did Dempsey earn the bronze star with the V? Nobody seems to know
Iraq...then your boy lost it.
Iraq hasn't been lost. The thread is bull crap.
Oh? So why is Iraq in turmoil? What has happened in Ramadi? Again, you're just trying to defend the indefensible, Obama blew the victory
Your deflections and back peddling only work with the members of you circle jerk. The comment was made that Iraq was lost and another was made that Democrats don't win wars. Iraq has not been lost and a ghost town in Iraq being given up does not constitute the lose of Iraq, no matter how much you try to spin it. On the subject of Democrats not winning wars, you and the rest of the circle jerkers are just blank. You were asked which Republican won a war in the last 100 years. Silence.
I pulled up the latest map I could find. They control more than a ghost town.Whoopsies! Meant to give you these links:
Right up to date reporting here. Great website.
Iraq Situation Report: April 16-17, 2015
This is the article I lifted the map from.
Here s all of the area that ISIS controls - Business Insider
And even though they have been losing some territory they still hold Mosul and Raqqa.
The map is garbage. A normal map that we would have used in the military would have labeled much more territory as enemy controlled than simply where they had a physical presence. They wouldn't dare do the same to the Iraqi Security Forces. Essentially, they just followed the main road to the cities along it where ISIS controlled the area. What of the huge blank space in-between those roads? MOSTLY NOTHING IS THERE BUT DESERT!!! (The roads follow the waterways for obvious reasons) That map is garbage
Holy toledo there Publius. I'm not military. I don't pretend to be. And the Business Insider article is a reprint from an article from the Institute for the Study of War.
The woman who is President of this think tank appears to have excellent credentials considering she served as part of General McCrystal's assessment team in Kabul. What I've read about the think tank certainly confirms that they are professionals.
The map is obviously strictly designed for individuals like myself to try to wrap my brain around how ISIS is moving about, what they are capturing and what they are losing.
In other words whoever designed the map put in crayon for me. And I appreciate that.
The article itself clearly points out that ISIS's game plan is to control the roadways and urban regions.
Do you take issue with ISW? If so could you at least point out why they can't be trusted to be a credible source of information?
"ISW President Kagan has conducted eight battlefield circulations of Iraq since starting ISW for the MNF-I Commanding General, three of which were in
Afghanistan for CENTCOM
United States Central Command and ISAF
International Security Assistance Force.
She participated formally on the Joint Campaign Plan Assessment Team for Multi-National Force – Iraq U.S. Mission – Iraq in October 2008, and as part of the Civilian Advisory Team for the CENTCOM strategic review in January 2009.
Kagan served in Kabul as a member of General
Stanley McChrystal's strategic assessment team, composed of civilian experts, during his strategic review in June and July 2009.
She returned to Afghanistan in the summer of 2010 to assist General
David Petraeus with key transition tasks following his assumption of command in Afghanistan.
Kagan also serves on the Academic Advisory Board at the Afghanistan-
Pakistan Center of Excellence at CENTCOM."
Institute for the Study of War - Wikipedia the free encyclopedia