Could someone who is calling to "Free Palestine" explain what that realistically looks like?

[rosends]

I show you the boots on the ground. The truth that is there has contributed to those maps.
The settlers move in and commit violence. The Palestinians stand up for themselves, the IDF rolls in under the guise of insurrection and terrorism, and helps clear the land.
Hand in glove.

you showed lies with maps. Nothing new about that. I showed you what the maps really mean and say. You responded by posting all sorts of other things. Same approach loads of others have taken. It is no more persuasive than it ever was.

 

[Gabe Lackmann]

you showed lies with maps. Nothing new about that. I showed you what the maps really mean and say. You responded by posting all sorts of other things. Same approach loads of others have taken. It is no more persuasive than it ever was.

I provided a 10,000 view. You contested it, so I showed you the boots on the ground.
Israeli settlers at their despicable best, aided and protected by the Waffen IDF.
Do you want some more? I can go on for days because you Jews have gone on for nearly a century.

 

[AnOrangeCat]

"Free Palestine" is merely "Destroy Israel" under another name. Question, why have the surrounding Arab nations refused to assist the Palestinians in any meaningful way? Notice that the border with Egypt is wide open and Palestinians are welcomed with open arms and resettled in peace.

No, that's not the case. The border with Egypt is sealed shut and Palestinians are not allowed to move across it.

What's interesting is that when India and Pakistan were partitioned at the same time, there was displacement of about 15 million people. India took in the displaced Hindus living in Pakistan, and Pakistan took in the displaced Muslims living in India. Both made them citizens.

Israel took in the 900,000 Jews from MENA countries and made them citizens.

Only the Arab nations refused to bring in the Arabs displaced by the 1948 War for Independence.

So how come Pakistan, India, and Israel can take in their refugees and make them citizens, but the Arab countries couldn't?

 

[hadit]

What's interesting is that when India and Pakistan were partitioned at the same time, there was displacement of about 15 million people. India took in the displaced Hindus living in Pakistan, and Pakistan took in the displaced Muslims living in India. Both made them citizens of Pakistan.

Israel took in the 900,000 Jews from MENA countries and made them citizens.

Only the Arab nations refused to bring in the Arabs displaced by the 1948 War for Independence.

So how come Pakistan, India, and Israel can take in their refugees and make them citizens, but the Arab countries couldn't?

No pro-Palestinian advocate wants to touch that one.

 

[1srelluc]

"From the River INTO the Sea" works for me.

If the world woke up tomorrow and every "Pali" had up and disappeared the world would go.

 

[rosends]

I provided a 10,000 view.

don't know what that means

You contested it, so I showed you the boots on the ground.

instead of defending the lies you posted. Exactly. Pivot.

Israeli settlers at their despicable best, aided and protected by the Waffen IDF.
Do you want some more? I can go on for days because you Jews have gone on for nearly a century.

And I could go on for days showing you the violence perpetrated against Israel. So? There's a reason I'm trying to stay focused. You posted lies and I showed that. Posting anything else is a distraction.

 

[task0778]

What's interesting is that when India and Pakistan were partitioned at the same time, there was displacement of about 15 million people. India took in the displaced Hindus living in Pakistan, and Pakistan took in the displaced Muslims living in India. Both made them citizens of Pakistan.

Israel took in the 900,000 Jews from MENA countries and made them citizens.

Only the Arab nations refused to bring in the Arabs displaced by the 1948 War for Independence.

So how come Pakistan, India, and Israel can take in their refugees and make them citizens, but the Arab countries couldn't?

My guess, and that's all it is, is that the rift between the Shiites and the Sunnis may have something to do with it, or maybe those other Arab countries do not want to be conflicted with Israel. And they would be IMHO, cuz the terrorist attacks on Israel are not going to stop and none of those countries want another war with Israel.

PS: sorry for calling you an idiot. Sometimes I get a little crotchety.

 

[AnOrangeCat]

You mean kinda like the Jews have been doing for the past 80 years?

How come Egypt and Jordan didn't create a Palestine in Gaza and Judea/Samaria/East Jerusalem when they annexed them from 1948-1967?

 

[CrusaderFrank]

Would it be a democracy like Israel? Would it be a constitutional monarchy like they once had in Iran? Or would it be yet another Theocratic Islamist dictatorship like every Arab country in the Middle East?

What kind of nation are you building?

Would be like Palestine in 1945 where Jews, Muslims and Christians lived together in Peace

 

[AnOrangeCat]

And you're sticking your head up your ass thinking it'll all go away soon. Do you not know that over decades, compromises and agreements have been made by Israel and the arabs and subsequently broken by the arabs every.single.time? Meaningful compromise, my ass.

Yup. I think that the 2SS was killed for good on 10/7.

10/7 was about as far removed from a two state solution as you can get.

Palestinians don't even pay lip service to the 2SS anymore.

So if they won't, why should we?

 

[AnOrangeCat]

They have no idea. It's just a slogan to them and way to fill time in their meaningless lives.

I agree. They haven't given it any thought at all. They're just exploiting Palestinians so they can be antisemitic.

 

[AnOrangeCat]

Jews

First of all, "The West Bank" is its colonial name. That is what the British called it. Its indigenous name is Judea and Samaria. So when you call it "The West Bank", you're just perpetuating colonialism. That's how ridiculous you sound.

Secondly, there were 30,000 Jews who lived in Judea, Samaria, and East Jerusalem in 1947, then by 1949 there were zero. Every single Jew was driven out of homes they had been living in for generations. So I'm curious what your thoughts are on that?

Thirdly, the reason Israel turns a blind eye to what's happening in Judea and Samaria is because the Palestinian Authority pays the families of martyrs and murderers. It's the only way the Palestinian Authority has been able to govern...not because of Israel, but because Abbass hasn't governed at all, just enriched himself, and has not held democratic elections in 20 years. What are your thoughts on that?

 

[AnOrangeCat]

The Arabs commit terror acts all the time, and then whine when they are handled appropriately. Hassan, that will never change.

Muslim immigrants commit acts of terrorism more than any other immigrant group and it isn't even close.

 

[AnOrangeCat]

My guess, and that's all it is, is that the rift between the Shiites and the Sunnis may have something to do with it, or maybe those other Arab countries do not want to be conflicted with Israel. And they would be IMHO, cuz the terrorist attacks on Israel are not going to stop and none of those countries want another war with Israel.

PS: sorry for calling you an idiot. Sometimes I get a little crotchety.

You're good!

 

[AnOrangeCat]

Would be like Palestine in 1945 where Jews, Muslims and Christians lived together in Peace

They did not live in peace.

In 1945, Palestinians were Nazi allies.

Also, in 1945 the British controlled the Mandate.

 

[AnOrangeCat]

sraeli settlers at their despicable best, aided and protected by the Waffen IDF.

The Palestinian Authority pays the families of martyrs and terrorists instead of spending that money on schools, hospitals, and other things to improve their lives.

 

[rosends]

Would be like Palestine in 1945 where Jews, Muslims and Christians lived together in Peace

HAHAHA! Do you really believe that?

 

[Dante]

Could someone who is calling to "Free Palestine" explain what that realistically looks like?​

This cannot be taken as a serious asking. And besides, the statement is a premise based on the idea that Palestine is not Free.​

 

[CrusaderFrank]

HAHAHA! Do you really believe that?

You're right, it will probably never happen.

Especially after the latest incident where the IDF kidnapped unarmed aid worker on International waters to be tortured and gang raped.

 

[Gabe Lackmann]

How come Egypt and Jordan didn't create a Palestine in Gaza and Judea/Samaria/East Jerusalem when they annexed them from 1948-1967?

Don't know. Have you tried asking them?