CaféAuLait;8908858 said:
So since I've "lost" it should be no problem for someone to tell me what I'm getting in return for letting this guy run his commercial enterprise on my land for free? I don't want to hike or camp in a pile of cow shit. So the part he is using is not useable to the rest of us. What is this freeloader giving us in return?
Yet, you can hike and camp use ATVs and drive cars polluting the land, you can do this unregulated for free,( as long as you don't mess with the rock art) your horse can crap all over the place and eat the grass. You will probably pee and poo on the land if staying for any amount of time for free.
You can use the land as a virtual hotel for as long as you like and camp and build fires to warm your butt at night, leaving the land scarred from the fire and your horse trampling all over the land. Your car and ATVs can scar the land, your feet can do the same. Your dog and cat can pee and poo all over the land if you choose to bring it.
Guess what ,
you can hunt there, fish there, you can pan for gold there. Gaining a profit for yourself in all of the aforementioned items. You can photograph the area and sell the photos if you are good enough and make money from the area. You can sustain yourself off the land for free as long as you want as there is nothing to regulate how long you stay.
Perhaps he does not appreciate that. But you can do it, cant you? And you don't have to pay him a dime. You can do all of the above for free.
About Gold Butte | Friends of Gold Butte
Gold Butte Region - Area Overview
You can cip, dive, duck, and dodge all you want, but you still haven't addressed the fact that this guy is operating a commercial enterprise on my land. I deserve some compensation for the loss of use due to this. I'll settle for grazing fees and call it even. But this freeloader thinks he has a right to freebies. Screw him.
Freeloader, eh? You point fingers about addressing issues I have addressed and just ignored mine. You and others camp there for free on my land, you run your horses, ATVs and cars all over my land profiting using it as a hotel room, where is the money from all of those profiting from the use of that land? You have yet to answer that question. Where is the money from the pollution caused by the cars killing the plant life and polluting the beautiful rivers? How about your boat waste? How will the government pay for that destruction? of my land by campers, etc?
As far as use, while your camping on your claimed plot I can't use that land either, can I, I can't enjoy the beauty of the area trying to look through your tents. So I've lost use of my land. I can't trod in the horse crap , human pee and crap and dog shit left behind, so I deserve compensation for the loss of use for that as well, don't I?
You claim he is profiting for a business, where is my money for your personal profit using it as a toilet, a hotel, killing the animals on my land for sport or eating them for
your profit. When do I see the money for the gold taken from the rivers?
I've lost the beauty because someone else took it, I can no longer enjoy it because its dead or missing from my river. Why should you be allowed to kill animals
(for free) I enjoyed seeing each morning I wake up, those I watched in the streams and rivers? Why should you be allowed to do all that without paying a plug nickel to gain access?
Looks like its even to me the nearly 6 million people using the lands each year in the manners listed above, while his 500 cows eat a little grass off of 150 acres in small part of that 600,000 acres of the public land. You and others choose how you profit off the land in a different manner than he does IMO.
My question would be why not charge a fee to the 6 million people entering these public lands each year to assure that people are not doing damage?
That is why BLM is charging him a fee, to assure his cows are not damaging the area. People do a lot more damage than animals, but they are allowed to roam free, setting fires, camping, allowing their animals to do whatever without regulation. Hunting and fishing, etc. Seems if you want to regulate one persons actions on the land because of conservation, then they all should be regulated.
The weirdest part about this is BLM was not going to do anything about the lack of fee being paid until they were sued by conservationists.