My question to Trump about the Mexicans paying the Wall

[nat4900]

Maybe you should email your question to Trump, I doubt he reads this forum.

Well, I rather address Trump supporters.....The Donald is way BEYOND hope.

 

[Soggy in NOLA]

Well, our "beloved" Donald has conjured up a somewhat extortionist scheme to have Mexico pay for the building of the "beautiful" border wall.

The scheme involves the stopping of the $25 B that Mexicans in the US send back to their home country as money transference better known as "remittances"....

Trump vows that the ban on these remittances would be lifted if Mexico pays up front $10 B to build the wall.

Sounds good, doesn't it????

But, a couple of snags emerge in Trump-land rationale....

The first snag is actually minor and it involves Mexico paying for a wall that would keep out not only Mexicans from the US, but the millions of Central and South Americans who also cross the border...Maybe a per capita fee will be worked out by Trump's accountants.....

BUT, the second snag is a bit more thorny.......

Trump has also NOT relented on his "promise" to deport 11 million (or so) illegals (without really stating where these illegals would be deported to since not all are Mexicans.)

NOW, if you were the Mexican government......and you expected that high Mexican percentage of the 11 million illegals to be shipped back, the "threat" of the remittances becomes moot, doesn't it?
If all those illegal Mexicans are shipped back across the border, there are no remittances to also be shipped back to Mexico....

Soooooooo, unless we think of Mexicans as complete idiots, WHY should they pay for the Wall???????

Why would they pay a wall?

 

[Soggy in NOLA]

Nobody pays walls. That's just silly.

 

[nat4900]

Why would they pay a wall?

As soon as I can get my hands on my Moron-to-English dictionary, I promise to decipher the above.

 

[Correll]

Bottom line is this: Trump's extortionist tactics about denying the Mexicans their remittances, could ONLY work (well, just for argument sake) IF and only IF Trump does not deport all those illegals....

Conversely, if Trump deports all those illegals (its funny just to type this bullshit) what exactly is the INCENTIVE for Mexico to "pay for the wall".....

(Unless Trump threatens to fill the Mexican TV airwaves with reruns of The Apprentice.....now, that may loosen Mexico's purse-strings.)

Wow. Just wow..


1, Not all remittances are sent by illegals. THere are million and millions of LEGAL Mexican immigrants in this nation that are not going to be sent back and many of them are the ones sending money. So, that flow of money will not be reduced.

2. It will take years to deport 11 million people. Even the money of 1 or 2 years is a sizable amount, even if it is a steadily declining source.

 

[OKTexas]

Maybe you should email your question to Trump, I doubt he reads this forum.

Well, I rather address Trump supporters.....The Donald is way BEYOND hope.

Your title should have been written to reflect that. For a self proclaimed former speech writer you're not very articulate.

 

[nat4900]

Nobody pays walls. That's just silly.

 

[nat4900]

Your title should have been written to reflect that. For a self proclaimed former speech writer you're not very articulate.

Yet, you should have gotten the gist, don't you think?

 

[Soggy in NOLA]

Why would they pay a wall?

As soon as I can get my hands on my Moron-to-English dictionary, I promise to decipher the above.

Dude, it is a simple question about your thread title.

 

[Maryland Patriot]

Well, our "beloved" Donald has conjured up a somewhat extortionist scheme to have Mexico pay for the building of the "beautiful" border wall.

The scheme involves the stopping of the $25 B that Mexicans in the US send back to their home country as money transference better known as "remittances"....

Trump vows that the ban on these remittances would be lifted if Mexico pays up front $10 B to build the wall.

Sounds good, doesn't it????

But, a couple of snags emerge in Trump-land rationale....

The first snag is actually minor and it involves Mexico paying for a wall that would keep out not only Mexicans from the US, but the millions of Central and South Americans who also cross the border...Maybe a per capita fee will be worked out by Trump's accountants.....

BUT, the second snag is a bit more thorny.......

Trump has also NOT relented on his "promise" to deport 11 million (or so) illegals (without really stating where these illegals would be deported to since not all are Mexicans.)

NOW, if you were the Mexican government......and you expected that high Mexican percentage of the 11 million illegals to be shipped back, the "threat" of the remittances becomes moot, doesn't it?
If all those illegal Mexicans are shipped back across the border, there are no remittances to also be shipped back to Mexico....

Soooooooo, unless we think of Mexicans as complete idiots, WHY should they pay for the Wall???????

unless we are complete idiots, why should we keep paying for their 11 million illegals.
Ship the disease carrying scum back and don't waste another moment worrying about them.

 

[Soggy in NOLA]

Maybe you should email your question to Trump, I doubt he reads this forum.

Well, I rather address Trump supporters.....The Donald is way BEYOND hope.

Your title should have been written to reflect that. For a self proclaimed former speech writer you're not very articulate.

No shit huh? What an inarticulate loon. It is always these lefties shouting from the rooftops how educated and smart they are; then they can't manage to pen a cogent thought.

 

[nat4900]

1, Not all remittances are sent by illegals. THere are million and millions of LEGAL Mexican immigrants in this nation that are not going to be sent back and many of them are the ones sending money. So, that flow of money will not be reduced.

Well, then, TWO problems arise....

One......Will western union, post offices, etc. be asked to check a "residency card" from whoever wants to send money to Mexico?

Two, will Trump enact a SPECIAL law banning legal citizens from sending remittances?

 

[nat4900]

unless we are complete idiots, why should we keep paying for their 11 million illegals.
Ship the disease carrying scum back and don't waste another moment worrying about them.

Swallow back some of your spittle, there, moron...

You should (probably not) know that not ALL illegals here are from Mexico..

 

[nat4900]

No shit huh? What an inarticulate loon. It is always these lefties shouting from the rooftops how educated and smart they are; then they can't manage to pen a cogent thought.

REALLY????
REALLY???? the above from a moron who writes: "Nobody pays walls. That's just silly."???? LOL

 

[OKTexas]

Your title should have been written to reflect that. For a self proclaimed former speech writer you're not very articulate.

Yet, you should have gotten the gist, don't you think?

I don't do gist or regressive BS, you seem to be full of both.

 

[nat4900]

I don't do gist or regressive BS, you seem to be full of both.

LOL.....Never mind.......I guess you "don't do" logic either......

 

[Maryland Patriot]

unless we are complete idiots, why should we keep paying for their 11 million illegals.
Ship the disease carrying scum back and don't waste another moment worrying about them.

Swallow back some of your spittle, there, moron...

You should (probably not) know that not ALL illegals here are from Mexico..

again with the left starting the ignorant dialogue. What is it with you people that causes you to be so uncouth and uncivilized.
Does that not indicate some sort of mental illness to you? maybe one that could have you thinking about voting for the wrong person?
I'm glad I don't have to live that way.

 

[easyt65]

Well, our "beloved" Donald has conjured up a somewhat extortionist scheme to have Mexico pay for the building of the "beautiful" border wall.

The scheme involves the stopping of the $25 B that Mexicans in the US send back to their home country as money transference better known as "remittances"....

Trump vows that the ban on these remittances would be lifted if Mexico pays up front $10 B to build the wall.

Sounds good, doesn't it????

But, a couple of snags emerge in Trump-land rationale....

The first snag is actually minor and it involves Mexico paying for a wall that would keep out not only Mexicans from the US, but the millions of Central and South Americans who also cross the border...Maybe a per capita fee will be worked out by Trump's accountants.....

BUT, the second snag is a bit more thorny.......

Trump has also NOT relented on his "promise" to deport 11 million (or so) illegals (without really stating where these illegals would be deported to since not all are Mexicans.)

NOW, if you were the Mexican government......and you expected that high Mexican percentage of the 11 million illegals to be shipped back, the "threat" of the remittances becomes moot, doesn't it?
If all those illegal Mexicans are shipped back across the border, there are no remittances to also be shipped back to Mexico....

Soooooooo, unless we think of Mexicans as complete idiots, WHY should they pay for the Wall???????

Yu libs have a hard time thinking things through, so let me help you by giving one or two examples of how Trump could accomplish these:

Mexico Pays For The Wall:
1. Suspend the annual 'Foreign Aid' payment to Mexico - use it to build the wall, hire more ICE / BPAs, and secure the border.

2. Freeze all Mexican funds in the US and use it to pay for all of that...AS WELL AS reimbursement for expenses of having to care for their citizens here illegally and to pay money to all the US victims and their families of illegal crimes / murder.

11 Million Illegals Gone:
- Deport all criminal illegals. No catch-and-release policy like Barry's. Break the law - you're gone.
- ENFORCE THE LAW: It is illegal to give an illegal a job - 'E-Verify'. No jobs, no reason to be here and they will leave on their own.
- Cut Off all American Tax payer-funded benefit to illegals: No drivers' licenses, no Welfare, no Unemployment, no Food Stamps, no Obamaphone, no Social Security - No NOTHING.
- End - cut off at the knees - all sanctuary cities. Until all sanctuary cites are eliminated not only are the cities cut off from govt funding, cut the states off too. The Governors will quickly crack down on their cities' criminal activity.

If Illegals have no jobs, no access to tax payer-funded social programs/services, THEY WILL LEAVE ON THEIR OWN. Need money HELPING them get back home? SEIZE MONEY MEXICO HAS IN THE US TO HELP PAY FOR THEIR EXODUS...AND BE GENEROUS WITH THE MONEY - IT WON'T BE OURS.

These are a couple ways...but if Libs are honest (which they hardly ever are) they will admit that THEIR politicians will have a HUGE part in deciding if Trump can keep his promises...because they know there is no way in hell Democrats in Congress are going to let Trump successfully do ANYTHING to close and secure the border or to deport this huge new eventual voting block they have spent years creating!

 

[OKTexas]

I don't do gist or regressive BS, you seem to be full of both.

LOL.....Never mind.......I guess you "don't do" logic either......

Hey dipshit, I'm not the one addressing a question to one person and expecting others to answer it. If that sounds logical to you then you really need professional help.

 

[Soggy in NOLA]

No shit huh? What an inarticulate loon. It is always these lefties shouting from the rooftops how educated and smart they are; then they can't manage to pen a cogent thought.

REALLY????
REALLY???? the above from a moron who writes: "Nobody pays walls. That's just silly."???? LOL

Hey, snatch breath, this is YOUR thread title:

My question to Trump about the Mexicans paying the Wall