PratchettFan
Gold Member
- Jun 20, 2012
- 7,238
- 746
- 190
Your believing that doesn't make it true.That is your belief, the religious belief of not understanding what you have repeatedly been told.No, that you are a believer has been established. Your willingness to concede there is a 1% chance your belief is wrong does not make it any less a belief. What we are arguing over is this unquestioned adherence to a definition and the insistence that the definition creates reality. This is the essence of dogma and dogma is one of the attributes of religion.
The definition given is that Atheists lack beliefs in gods. You clearly don't lack beliefs but you go back and forth on admitting this because it conflicts with the definition. Dogma.
It is said Atheists don't evangelize. You have admitted you do exactly that, but you deny it is evangelizing (though you agree you are doing exactly what evangelists do) because you are an Atheist and Atheists don't evangelize. Dogma.
Atheism as the belief there is no God (and you can only arrive at that conclusion via belief) is not religion. It's just a belief and as valid as any other belief. It is this dogmatic approach that an Atheist's beliefs aren't beliefs because Atheists lack beliefs that takes what is just a belief and transforms it into religion. Now you are setting up standards that "this is what an Atheist is" and "they are doing Atheism wrong", and that is nothing but dogma.
The existence and non-existence of a god are not equally probable outcomes. The majority of things we can possibly imagine do not exist. Thus, belief is not as valid a position as skepticism when dealing with unsupported or unfalsifiable claims. Agnostic atheism is the most rational position.
That is a belief. You have no evidence to support the claim, just the claim itself.
No. That is a statement of fact. He is making a claim without support of any kind. That is a belief. And I do understand, I just am not buying the dogma. If you want to claim a position that is not belief, then show me the evidence. Don't give me bumper stickers quips, unsupported definitions or claims I am to accept on faith. Show me hard evidence. Until you do that, you're just another believer claiming to know the TRUTH.
And no evidence. What a surprise.