Appalachia: Are there solutions?

I think you know exactly what this thread is about. Warrantless stereotypes of southerners by those on the left. Things like "they cling to their guns and religion" sort of stuff, "Redneck Racists", "Christian Taliban" to name a few more. Try not to feign ignorance. I live in North Georgia, thus I know quite a few people from that area. Hopefully you genuinely disagree with those stereotypes.

[MENTION=43268]TemplarKormac[/MENTION]
Why do you have to be a dick?

Why do you care? You'd much rather just jump on the bandwagon and stereotype all of us, wouldn't you?

I defended Appalachia in my post. I think it's a great culture. Screw you!

Ever heard of a Dulcimer? Have you ever gone looking for snipes in the woods?

Get off your fucking high horse TK. You're as BLATANTLY partisan as anyone I've ever met; right and wrong be damned. You saw my post and decided to be a dick. Right?
 
Reading through the first few pages of the President's 2015 budget I just got an idea. It is a really bad idea but maybe it will spur something else that is a good idea. First a little background. Like I mentioned I grew up the the far backwoods of the Ozarks. We had a neighbor who was an alcholic. Took his government check and bought all the Old Milwakee it would buy. My brothers and I were over at his place, we were like early teens. He was kicking back cans when he took his pen knife and jammed it into his leg. Needless to say I flinched. I soon realized it was OK because his leg was wooden. We knew him for a while and I have never noticed. He lost it in Korea. First car I bought was a '63 Bel Air for $400. I was fascinated how the previous owner would open the door with his metal hand. I think he left it in Vietnam somewhere. Several people were out in the woods just to breath. We have all these vets coming back from the wars. They get checks anyway, they need clinics, and some space just to breath would do them good, maybe just for a weekend every couple of months. It is an idea anyway.
 
[MENTION=43268]TemplarKormac[/MENTION]
Why do you have to be a dick?

Why do you care? You'd much rather just jump on the bandwagon and stereotype all of us, wouldn't you?

I defended Appalachia in my post. I think it's a great culture. Screw you!

Ever heard of a Dulcimer? Have you ever gone looking for snipes in the woods?

Get off your fucking high horse TK. You're as BLATANTLY partisan as anyone I've ever met; right and wrong be damned. You saw my post and decided to be a dick. Right?


simple plays the hand he was given.....
 
From Rep. Ryan's "War on Poverty", 2014
ARC has established four priority goals for the region: 1) increase job opportunities and per
capita income; 2) strengthen the capacity of the people to compete in the global environment;
3) develop and improve infrastructure; and 4) build the Appalachian Development Highway
System to reduce isolation.629 In order to achieve these goals, the commission seeks to
coordinate all available federal funding to provide leverage for local government and private
investment. Grants are awarded for priority regional activities such as reforestation, green
energy, food-system development, and community-based philanthropy.

Interesting question in the OP. I live smack dab in Appalachia, foot hills of WV mtns. I know the attitudes of this area and the problems though personally I am the anti-thesis of this area having been educated (philosophy and sociology), traveled within the US broadly, excessively long hair, and am an avid cyclist (who has no children). Everyone else who lives here is haggard by 24, everyone has a kid (or 3) they cannot support without Christian grandparents. They also are heavy smokers and drug use has shot up since I was became aware in 05 despite oxy prices being almost twice that of major areas. Oddly enough this is the only narrative I share with my fellow community members: disillusionment in being able to get ahead in life (though this wasn't necessarily true for me, it was a combination of lack of desire to make it big and having having a hard time selling my self for money under contract). Most of us, including myself, ended up addicted to drugs.

Whenever I leave this area looking for work or just traveling, it is a huge burden lifted. No doubt this area is a national travesty and a large part is due to our self-sufficient attitudes of mountain folk. We are definitely an ingenious bunch jerry-rigging and the like but when it comes to understanding politics, we don't. We are too hard up to stand for a social issue. Yes we need jobs but everyone oughtta know by now manufacturing jobs that my Dad could get are gone now. They will never come back unless we work for Malaysian labor prices.

So how do you get jobs Ryan? Magically invent them (the government can do that and the CCC of FDR's day did a great many projects in this area)? Or is this a ploy to give subsidies and tax breaks to corporations to come in a decimate what's left of our pristine mountains and hills? Natural gas has caused 11 Earth quakes recently in Ohio and more plans exist to drill Environmentalists Call For Ban on Fracking in Ohio After Earthquakes

Mountain top removal, coal processing happens near schools in WV that are causing 1/4 of students to miss school due to strange illnesses. I can't help think that when Ryan talks of jobs, it's more jobs like this than jobs that actually benefit citizens instead of making them ill. However, there is a lot of grass roots movements been taking place for the last decade with increasing support and perhaps cancer of unknown origins is becoming too common a diagnosis that it's getting opposition. Maybe Ryan can bring in much need green jobs that re-enforce and preserve our beautiful parks, wildlife and nature. But knowing Ryan, he believes this spells the demise of jobs and so is anti-American (a totally false premise).

And indeed this is confirmed when we see Ryan mention "compete on a global market." To do so is to compete with other parts of the world. What does that mean? other parts of the world are being exploited amazingly fast. There are tons of ways to further exploit our large land resources and render them commercial or hazardous. I don't think there will be support for this but Ryan doesn't need support, he needs tacit idleness. And we red neck folk sure know how to bend over and take it and then beg for our children. We are not known for organizing or serious community action. I've been wowed by the fact Occupy was in a couple nearby towns in my area (Huntington WV and Portsmouth OH).

yeah so the highways are kinda shitty but we don't need better highways. We need mass transit. It wasn't until 5 years ago buses existed in my town and for the first 2 years maybe a total of 100 people road it. It was absurd. Now there's a terminal but given no incentive to ride a bus, people are stuck in the mindset of "must own car" and in a sense, if one wishes to really be able to live around here, you need to drive 60-120 miles a day to get to work and a friend's house! That's why I said I'm the anti-thesis since I bike 60 miles to get around these long gaps of civilization. So bettering the highway means funds are being spent on a collapsing infrastructure that should be abolished. That's right, I'm saying cars should be a thing of the past as we move into light rail and integrated communities who are not fearful of riding with their neighbor. What's terribly sad is this area in particular is madly in love with guns and conceal carry permits so I don't see this happening.

My conclusion for residents if Ryan's plan succeeds: leave the area.

If Ryan's plans doesn't succeed: still leave the area! It's a wasteland! Almost any establishment agenda on this area will lead to great exploitation and alienation. We are alienated enough!

Personally I cannot wait to leave and hopefully by next year I will, again, for the 4th time. 28,500/yr was the median annual income of residents in my county in '11. It shows. There are literally 90% empty store fronts in my "downtown" even though in the 50s this was a booming area. For us to maintain its beauty and return it to acceptable living standards we would need solutions from outside the capitalist system and drop our need for commercialization. I would love to see this region maintain its beauty will becoming a global inspiration by creating a visionary and revolutionary solution empowering workers instead of the same old exploitation.
 
Last edited:
[MENTION=43268]TemplarKormac[/MENTION]
Why do you have to be a dick?

Why do you care? You'd much rather just jump on the bandwagon and stereotype all of us, wouldn't you?

I defended Appalachia in my post. I think it's a great culture. Screw you!

Ever heard of a Dulcimer?yes, limited at playing one but yes a bit

Have you ever gone looking for snipes in the woods? no, i am not stupid

Get off your fucking high horse TK. You're as BLATANTLY partisan as anyone I've ever met; right and wrong be damned. You saw my post and decided to be a dick. Right?

a dick and a liar....dont forget that...the liar part
 
lack of...where does one begin...here the roads are an issue....we still have roads that 18 wheelers cannot navigate ...property is cheap but if a large plant comes in...they have to really reach out to get workers...baxters off the mountain hires w/i a 100 miles radius and supplies buses to bring workers in....we are still a very underpopulated area depending on tourism....

i see no problem with ashe country workers getting out and helping people sign up for programs need....that mountain pride should not mean kids go hungry or people nearly freeze in the winter...it has been several hard winters now...people need help....if you fully understood the programs....one will come in and help insulate a house...new windows etc....

and this not being a culturally diverse area...it may be hard to talk upper level plant types to come to the area....



Holy cow, Bones. I live in Ashe too. Been here for nearly six years and haven't lived in a more pleasant and resilient place. We may be from OFF but we have acclimated well with our neighbors and friends. We see great strength, kindness and determination to survive. Mountain Pride is alive and well, even under financial duress.
 
well hello i live in avery.....i go to pottertown a lot...dont hold that against me...but i love ashe...we go to the murals and the cheese factory...which was a lot more fun when the guy used his arm ...his hairy ass arm to stir the cheese as it was setting up...

ashe has become a 'bedroom community' for asu...yall got one damn good road over there....i still take old 194 for the hell of it....
 
Here in southern Indiana, we are not a part of the Appalachian mountains of course, however the culture of self sufficiency and resiliency is as much a part of life here as there.
What the OP misses out on, and many in this thread, is many do not want or need anyone to "solve their problem". This reminds me of when the Europeans came to America and saw how Indians lived, and felt like it was their duty to "civilize" them. Didn't work out too good for those poor helpless Indians did it?
Same here, not having money does not necessarily make you poor. If you know how to grow your own vegetables, hunt and fish...and barter for other necessities - who is to say that they are not richer than you? - who spends 8-10 hours a day working somewhere you don't want to be, doing something you don't want to do - and stressing everyday because of it.
A newer car, an over-sized house, 5 widescreen TV's etc. etc. etc. - just may not be something they want.
 
Last edited:
Here in southern Indiana, we are not a part of the Appalachian mountains of course, however the culture of self sufficiency and resiliency is as much a part of life here as there.
What the OP misses out on, and many in this thread, is many do not want or need anyone to "solve their problem". This reminds me of when the Europeans came to America and saw how Indians lived, and felt like it was their duty to "civilize" them. Didn't work out too good for those poor helpless Indians did it?
Same here, not having money does not necessarily make you poor. If you know how to grow your own vegetables, hunt and fish...and barter for other necessities - who is to say that they are not richer than you? - who spends 8-10 hours a day working somewhere you don't want to be, doing something you don't want to do - and stressing everyday because of it.
A newer car, an over-sized house, 5 widescreen TV's etc. etc. etc. - just may not be something they want.

No, I fully agree with you about the "solve their problem" implication. I did not like the title to begin with and I like it much less as the posts come in. As the post a couple back said, they really don't want a factory or the environmental destruction. The thread about national parks had some good posts. I think that is something everyone would be happy with. I definitely thing Republican's agendas are destructive to the environment but also reading the President's 2015 budget they are clueless about areas like these. That is the main reason I started the thread. I think a national committee should sit down with some park rangers, extension agents, small business owners, and other locals and talk about what would really make sense. Bottom up, not top down. A little respect would go a long way.

I say "what they want" but I guess it would be OK to say 'we'. When one grows up in the sticks it is always there. I drive by and looks at a tree line and wonder how far back the woods go but know that it is probably a few hundred yards, at best.
 
No, I fully agree with you about the "solve their problem" implication. I did not like the title to begin with and I like it much less as the posts come in. As the post a couple back said, they really don't want a factory or the environmental destruction. The thread about national parks had some good posts. I think that is something everyone would be happy with. I definitely thing Republican's agendas are destructive to the environment but also reading the President's 2015 budget they are clueless about areas like these. That is the main reason I started the thread. I think a national committee should sit down with some park rangers, extension agents, small business owners, and other locals and talk about what would really make sense. Bottom up, not top down. A little respect would go a long way.

I say "what they want" but I guess it would be OK to say 'we'. When one grows up in the sticks it is always there. I drive by and looks at a tree line and wonder how far back the woods go but know that it is probably a few hundred yards, at best.

Sounds like you are suggesting creating something like an Indian Reservation for these folks as a way of addressing the issue. Maybe build a casino or bingo hall in the foothills and use the proceeds to fund economic reform for the mountain people?
 
No, I fully agree with you about the "solve their problem" implication. I did not like the title to begin with and I like it much less as the posts come in. As the post a couple back said, they really don't want a factory or the environmental destruction. The thread about national parks had some good posts. I think that is something everyone would be happy with. I definitely thing Republican's agendas are destructive to the environment but also reading the President's 2015 budget they are clueless about areas like these. That is the main reason I started the thread. I think a national committee should sit down with some park rangers, extension agents, small business owners, and other locals and talk about what would really make sense. Bottom up, not top down. A little respect would go a long way.

I say "what they want" but I guess it would be OK to say 'we'. When one grows up in the sticks it is always there. I drive by and looks at a tree line and wonder how far back the woods go but know that it is probably a few hundred yards, at best.

Sounds like you are suggesting creating something like an Indian Reservation for these folks as a way of addressing the issue. Maybe build a casino or bingo hall in the foothills and use the proceeds to fund economic reform for the mountain people?

What did I say that gave you that impression?
 
No, I fully agree with you about the "solve their problem" implication. I did not like the title to begin with and I like it much less as the posts come in. As the post a couple back said, they really don't want a factory or the environmental destruction. The thread about national parks had some good posts. I think that is something everyone would be happy with. I definitely thing Republican's agendas are destructive to the environment but also reading the President's 2015 budget they are clueless about areas like these. That is the main reason I started the thread. I think a national committee should sit down with some park rangers, extension agents, small business owners, and other locals and talk about what would really make sense. Bottom up, not top down. A little respect would go a long way.

I say "what they want" but I guess it would be OK to say 'we'. When one grows up in the sticks it is always there. I drive by and looks at a tree line and wonder how far back the woods go but know that it is probably a few hundred yards, at best.

Sounds like you are suggesting creating something like an Indian Reservation for these folks as a way of addressing the issue. Maybe build a casino or bingo hall in the foothills and use the proceeds to fund economic reform for the mountain people?

What did I say that gave you that impression?
The thread about national parks had some good posts...I think a national committee should sit down with some park rangers...


I have no problem admitting I jumped to that conclusion and I should have tried to find the National Park thread instead of assuming one solution you are suggestion is to turn these areas into National Parks to inspire tourism.
 
Sounds like you are suggesting creating something like an Indian Reservation for these folks as a way of addressing the issue. Maybe build a casino or bingo hall in the foothills and use the proceeds to fund economic reform for the mountain people?

What did I say that gave you that impression?
The thread about national parks had some good posts...I think a national committee should sit down with some park rangers...


I have no problem admitting I jumped to that conclusion and I should have tried to find the National Park thread instead of assuming one solution you are suggestion is to turn these areas into National Parks to inspire tourism.

My question way you thought so was to see how I might be stating something in a way which leads to inaccurate conclusions. Your reply gives also gives me the opportunity to better explain what an extension agent does, an opportunity I hope to take soon. If anyone else has an experience with extension agents I welcome the input.
 
Hmm...I haven't seen any comments like that. Its been a circle jerk of similar thought, but no warrant less attacks on Southerners or mountain people (I'm sorta surprised).

But lets be honest, there is poverty in the mountains because these people have no education and they make no attempt to better their community.

It's a lifestyle, no? There is nothing the matter with this...there is nothing the matter with wanting to live off the land and be one with the mountains. The thing is, if you want this lifestyle, if you want to remain isolated, if you want to be 'left alone' - don't make American's pay for your welfare!

There is something the matter with theses people living off the government...generation, after generation, after generation, after generation. There is something the matter with being intolerant to flatlanders, scaring away business, tourism, and growth then sucking up tax dollars because you want a lifestyle.

The solution is simple...no more welfare. Make these people move where there are jobs and where there is opportunity...because they sure as hell aren't creating ANY opportunity for themselves.

There are many people in the region. The people who live and enjoy their life is one group. People who like the cost of live and live like kings in the hills are another. There is another group where real tragedy lives. These are people who live in towns that used to be. Where there was a business and everyone adapted to working at the one big employer. When that employ picked up and left, for whatever reason, the town and its people are left to slowly decline into abject poverty. This is no "get a job" or "start your own business". There is possibly move elsewhere but families are large and close knit. They can't all pack up and move out. The roads fail, there are no teachers for the schools, and no doctors in the clinics. The government can either step in or not. There is no thing for sure, there are no easy answers.
What I am saying is that they do not want the government to help any more than getting their food stamps and welfare checks. They don't want to better themselves, they want to be left alone to wallow in their own misery.

As for moving large families...you would think, if you cared about your family, you would find a way to move out. They already know how to manipulate and abuse welfare...they could do the same in populated cities where there are jobs.

Sorry, this is nothing more than a group of people that are willful victims of the American welfare system.

Troll, you have no idea what living in the old hills is like. I've been there, I've done it, and I'm better educated than you.
 
There are many people in the region. The people who live and enjoy their life is one group. People who like the cost of live and live like kings in the hills are another. There is another group where real tragedy lives. These are people who live in towns that used to be. Where there was a business and everyone adapted to working at the one big employer. When that employ picked up and left, for whatever reason, the town and its people are left to slowly decline into abject poverty. This is no "get a job" or "start your own business". There is possibly move elsewhere but families are large and close knit. They can't all pack up and move out. The roads fail, there are no teachers for the schools, and no doctors in the clinics. The government can either step in or not. There is no thing for sure, there are no easy answers.
What I am saying is that they do not want the government to help any more than getting their food stamps and welfare checks. They don't want to better themselves, they want to be left alone to wallow in their own misery.

As for moving large families...you would think, if you cared about your family, you would find a way to move out. They already know how to manipulate and abuse welfare...they could do the same in populated cities where there are jobs.

Sorry, this is nothing more than a group of people that are willful victims of the American welfare system.

Troll, you have no idea what living in the old hills is like. I've been there, I've done it, and I'm better educated than you.

Why do I have to know what it is like to live in the hills? Moonshine, meth and welfare checks..oh my. One doctor, no dentist and a nearby welfare office...right? And of course, lets not forget about the preacher that will marry you and your cousin for some shine and possum stew.

Again, willful victims of the welfare system. Leeches on society who want big government to fix their problems so they can continue their heritage of isolationism.

Oh, and I doubt you are better educated than me.
 
What I am saying is that they do not want the government to help any more than getting their food stamps and welfare checks. They don't want to better themselves, they want to be left alone to wallow in their own misery.

As for moving large families...you would think, if you cared about your family, you would find a way to move out. They already know how to manipulate and abuse welfare...they could do the same in populated cities where there are jobs.

Sorry, this is nothing more than a group of people that are willful victims of the American welfare system.

Troll, you have no idea what living in the old hills is like. I've been there, I've done it, and I'm better educated than you.

Why do I have to know what it is like to live in the hills? Moonshine, meth and welfare checks..oh my. One doctor, no dentist and a nearby welfare office...right? And of course, lets not forget about the preacher that will marry you and your cousin for some shine and possum stew.

Again, willful victims of the welfare system. Leeches on society who want big government to fix their problems so they can continue their heritage of isolationism.

Oh, and I doubt you are better educated than me.

you really dont have a clue do you? as for the one doctor....boone is now a small medical center for this area...if they cannot deal with it...asheville or winston salem can....no dentist really....welfare office? how quaint ..when you decide to live in this century and discuss issues of this century then you may have a discussion
 

Forum List

Back
Top