frazzledgear
Senior Member
- Mar 17, 2008
- 1,479
- 544
- 48
I listed the prophesies.
Please explain how jesus
- brought all the jews to israel
- Kept them all there
- Created world peace
- Rebuilt the temple in jerusalem which would stand forever
The Torah is thousands of pages, and G-d went into great detail, even giving the exact measurements that the temple should be constructed.
Yet all this father, son, and all the other christian creations are never mentioned in it.
In fact, G-D said to only trust him, and him alone. He also said to not add or subtract from the Torah.
Look, it's really simply, you either what G-D said in the Torah or your don't. If you do, you can not worship jesus, or treat him as any divine being in any way.
Another fabrication. I quoted the passages where exactly does it say anything about a second coming?
You certaintly can. It's called idol worship. But you are right you certainly have a legal right to worship whatever or whomever you wish.
Everything predicted in the OT regarding the punishment of the Jews for rejecting the Messiah have come true.
More christian creations.
I am not aware of anywhere in the Torah, where jews are punished for rejecting the messiah. Jews are punished for rejecting G-D.
In any case it's very simple.
G-D gave the messianic prophesies. The true messiah will fulfill them. I really you have to do creative dancing and create multiple comings because it's clear that jesus didn't fulfill any of them.
Jews have no choice but to reject false messiahs and false gods.
The messiah will never claim to be divine. That within itself ascertains that jesus could never be the messiah in the Torah.
He can certainly be the christian messiah, but he certainly has nothing to do with judaism, other than a person who challenged G-D's authority.
People have gotten WAY off track on the initial topic of this thread. Christians know the drill when it comes to Jewish beliefs regarding Jesus. The one I always found the oddest was the claim that Jesus challenged God's authority when in fact He did no such thing -not EVER. The ONLY authority He ever challenged was that of MAN -specifically that of a few Jews who deliberately positioned themselves to exploit and take advantage of their position in the Jewish community and hierarchy for THEIR benefit -and not for that of God.
The primary reason Jews rejected Jesus is because He failed, in their eyes, to do what they expected their Messiah to dodestroy evil and all their enemies, rebuild the temple and establish an eternal kingdom with Israel as the preeminent nation in the world.
The prophecies in Isaiah and Psalms describe a suffering Messiah who would be persecuted and killed, but Jews chose to focus instead on those prophecies that discussed His glorious victories, not His crucifixion. They reject two comings of the Messiah in spite of prophesy in Isaiah that clearly indicates there are two -one that will occur in the year of the Lord's favor and the other at the end of the world. Considering the fact Jewish prophesy clearly indicates the Messiah will be mocked, beaten, spat upon, crucified and die -Jews ignore ALL of these prophesies and think the only ones that count are those regarding the end of the world and His ultimate victories. All I can think is that even though the Messiah is predicted to be REJECTED by His own people, beaten, mocked, spat upon, crucified and then DIE apparently they expected ALL prophesy regarding the Messiah to be all fulfilled at one "sitting". The only prophesy even remotely suggesting how many appearances there will be indicates TWO, not one. And that there is prophesy regarding how the Messiah will be rejected by His own people, maltreated and killed as well as prophesy where He is rejoiced by His own people, leading His own people and rebuilds the temple, defeats Israel's enemies and establishes the supremacy of Israel as God's kingdom on earth -also supports two separate appearances.
So the expectation that the Messiah will do all these things AT ONCE is a man made expectation and one MAN has placed upon the Messiah to perform as Jews expect. This MAN MADE expectation about only fulfilling prophesy in accordance with how Jews have decided to interpret it is something Jews consider to be far more important than the actual prophesies themselves. That makes it man's error and Jesus had no problem pointing out the errors of MAN. Just like at all times it was MAN and MAN'S authority that Jesus challenged. NEVER that of God.
To claim that Jesus fulfilled none of the prophesies is just deceitful. Even today AS AT THE TIME, there are rabbis and scholars of the Talmud who admit that Jesus did indeed fulfill many, MANY of them while quibbling about how they believe other prophesies can only be interpreted as they have decided and no other way. Yet that insistence that it may only be interpreted no other way is done for the specific purpose of "proving" how Jesus did not fulfill prophesies. Even while admitting that another interpretation would mean Jesus did fulfill it after all. They just refuse to agree those can be interpreted that way and insist only the interpretation they insist upon is acceptable -again, man made restrictions on how God must perform. HOW these prophesies must be interpreted is decided by MAN, not by God and God is not restricted to fulfill them exactly the way Jews expect and even demand must be fulfilled ONLY this way.
Again, for the first 400 years the followers of Jesus were almost entirely no one but JEWS. It was JEWS who thought Jesus had indeed fulfilled prophesy and this was a sect that only grew larger and larger and it was considered to be a Jewish sect for hundreds of years until gentile converts outnumbered those who were Jewish. It just wasn't most Jews who believed Jesus was the Messiah -but it is a fact that it was ONLY Jews who believed this for many, many years. It was JEWS who believed Jesus was the Messiah, Jews who went out into the world and preached His message first, JEWS who converted gentiles to believe in Jesus. And this is why Christianity was considered to be part of the JEWISH religion for centuries before being accepted as a separate religion. Jesus never renounced His own Jewish faith. He was not here for the purpose of creating a new religion. He preached among JEWS and what He preached was about THEIR shared religion and THEIR religious beliefs. Not the beliefs of pagan gentiles.
When it is predicted that Israel will reject the Messiah and this is accepted and understood by Christians -then trying to justify why Jews rejected the Messiah AS PREDICTED seems a rather useless exercise to me. Christians are very unlikely to convince you that they are right and I understand that. But you aren't going to convince Christians that this is one the Jews got right, sorry.