Who Are The Palestinians? Part 2

[Shusha]

P F Tinmore, et al,

Here you go again with incitement.

until the Jewish State of Israel concedes to Arab Palestinian Demands?

Like the demand to decolonize Palestine?

(COMMENT)

The Jewish State of Israel is NOT a COLONIAL POWER. The "demand to decolonize Palestine" is just another way of demanding Israel surrender.

Worse, its the demand to remove people from a territory based on ethnicity, aka ethnic cleansing.

 

[P F Tinmore]

P F Tinmore, et al,

Here you go again with incitement.

until the Jewish State of Israel concedes to Arab Palestinian Demands?

Like the demand to decolonize Palestine?

(COMMENT)

The Jewish State of Israel is NOT a COLONIAL POWER. The "demand to decolonize Palestine" is just another way of demanding Israel surrender.

Worse, its the demand to remove people from a territory based on ethnicity, aka ethnic cleansing.

If you check out BDS, not one person calls for the removal of Jews.

 

[rylah]

Who were the Palestinians

Palestinian Jews of 'Kerem Avraham', Jerusalem 1855 :

 

[montelatici]

Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, the British counsel in Jerusalem, nothing ever changes.

 

[Hollie]

Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, the British counsel in Jerusalem, nothing ever changes.

Of course things change. Earlier, xtian Crusaders bought xtianity to the area.

 

[rylah]

Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, the British counsel in Jerusalem, nothing ever changes.

It's 1855, 30 years before the 1st Zionist immigration.
This are the people who were expelled from Safed and Hebron and flee to Jerusalem.

 

[Shusha]

If you check out BDS, not one person calls for the removal of Jews.

*newsflash* YOU called for ethnic cleansing with your demand that "Palestine" be decolonized of Jews. Don't misdirect to BDS. Own your shit.

 

[RoccoR]

P F Tinmore, et al,

This is misdirection.

If you check out BDS, not one person calls for the removal of Jews.

(COMMENT)

The BSD Movement is just one aspect of Arab Palestinian incitement. Many of the members of the BSD are also member of activists and those that provide material supporters for Jihadism, Deadly Fedayeen Action, Hostile Insurgency Operations, Radicalized Islamic Behaviors, and Asymmetric Violence.

Which one of these novel Palestinian groups is dedicated to the settlement of disputes by peaceful means.

Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO)
Palestinian Authority (PA)
The Palestine Islamic Jihad (PIJ)
Palestine Liberation Front (PLF)
Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP)
Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command (PFLP-GC)
Al-Aqsa Brigade
Tanzim-Fatah
​

Most Respectfully,
R

 

[montelatici]

Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, the British counsel in Jerusalem, nothing ever changes.

It's 1855, 30 years before the 1st Zionist immigration.
This are the people who were expelled from Safed and Hebron and flee to Jerusalem.

They are Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, a Christian Zionist ahead of his time. Again, nothing ever changes.

 

[rylah]

Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, the British counsel in Jerusalem, nothing ever changes.

It's 1855, 30 years before the 1st Zionist immigration.
This are the people who were expelled from Safed and Hebron and flee to Jerusalem.

They are Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, a Christian Zionist ahead of his time. Again, nothing ever changes.

There were Palestinian Jews before 1839, before England opened its' first council in Palestine.
Otherwise to whom would Napoleon propose establish a Jewish homeland there?

 

[montelatici]

Napoleon's letter proclaimed that since "his young army" conquered Palestine he was invited Jews around the to go to Palestine under a French colonial protectorate. Not too much different than what the British proposed later. Still, Napoleon was promoting the replacement of the native people of Palestine with Jews from elsewhere.

"In 1799, the French armies under Napoleon were camped outside of Acre. Napoleon issued a letter offering Palestine as a homeland to the Jews under French protection. The project was stillborn because Napoleon was defeated and was forced to withdraw from the Near East. The letter is remarkable because it marks the coming of age of enlightenment philosophy, making it respectable at last to integrate Jews as equal citizens in Europe and because it marked the beginning of nineteenth century projects for Jewish autonomy in Palestine under a colonial protectorate."

Napoleon's Proclamation of a Jewish State - 1799

 

[rylah]

Of course he emancipated the Jews in Europe, however since we're discussing the time around the Acre siege it was directed towards Jews who lived allover the Galilee area.

 

[montelatici]

No, the letter was directed to the Jewish Nation, as he called it. Not the handful of Jews that may or may not have been in Palestine at the time.

 

[rylah]

No, the letter was directed to the Jewish Nation, as he called it. Not the handful of Jews that may or may not have been in Palestine at the time.

If You're trying to deny the existence of Jews in Palestine You're in big trouble.

Haim Farkhi, the de facto ruler of Acre was in Napoleon's mind. He was a Jew and he was a Palestinian along with thousands of other Jews who lived in Tiberias, Safed, Hebron and Jerusalem.

 

[montelatici]

There were a handful of Jews in Palestine at the time, not "thousands".

The original French text of the letter makes it clear who Napoleon was writing to.

"Alors, debout dans la joie, vous les exilés! (Then stand in joy, you the exiles!). Par une guerre sans exemple dans les annales de l’histoire, guerre engagée pour son auto-défense par une nation dont les territoires héréditaires étaient considérés par l’ennemi comme un butin à partager arbitrairement.........."

PROCLAMATION DE BONAPARTE SUR LA PALESTINE

 

[Phoenall]

P F Tinmore, et al,

Here you go again with incitement.

(COMMENT)

The Jewish State of Israel is NOT a COLONIAL POWER. The "demand to decolonize Palestine" is just another way of demanding Israel surrender.

If you look at the table of Non-Self Governing Territories by Committee 24 (Special Committee on Decolonization), you will not find Israel listed by the International activity exclusively devoted to the issue of decolonization. You will find World Powers like the US, UK, FR, NZ listed; but NOT Israel.

So, you can put that horse in the barn.

Most Respectfully,
R

The Empire Files: How Palestine Became Colonized

meaningless maps as there was never a nation of palestine, just a land area and a mandate

Another unsubstantiated Israeli talking point.

WRONG AGAIN as it is a proven fact. Shown to you many times and still you ignore it

See, there is your proof right there.

So you admit these maps are meaningless, and that there was never a nation of palestine. And all your claims are centered on the mandate's existence

 

[Phoenall]

P F Tinmore, et al,

Here you go again with incitement.

until the Jewish State of Israel concedes to Arab Palestinian Demands?

Like the demand to decolonize Palestine?

(COMMENT)

The Jewish State of Israel is NOT a COLONIAL POWER. The "demand to decolonize Palestine" is just another way of demanding Israel surrender.

Worse, its the demand to remove people from a territory based on ethnicity, aka ethnic cleansing.

If you check out BDS, not one person calls for the removal of Jews.

Try again as it is an underlying principle, and you have been shown this many times

 

[Phoenall]

Russian Jews brought to Palestine by an Englishman, the British counsel in Jerusalem, nothing ever changes.

Actually invited by the Ottomans because the arab muslims refused to do any work

 

[rylah]

There were a handful of Jews in Palestine at the time, not "thousands".

The original French text of the letter makes it clear who Napoleon was writing to.

"Alors, debout dans la joie, vous les exilés! (Then stand in joy, you the exiles!). Par une guerre sans exemple dans les annales de l’histoire, guerre engagée pour son auto-défense par une nation dont les territoires héréditaires étaient considérés par l’ennemi comme un butin à partager arbitrairement.........."

PROCLAMATION DE BONAPARTE SUR LA PALESTINE

Maybe You overlook the simple fact that when Napoleon wrote it he was in Palestine with his army.
In addition any basic research according to either McCarthy, Scholch or the Ottoman Consensus shows Jews to be 2%-6% of the population in the area Jerusalem, Nablus and Acre Sanjaks.
In The Ottoman Census of 1878 there're 15000 Jews with additional 5000-10000 more foreign citizens estimated by different studies.

Indeed THOUSANDS of Palestinian Jews.

 

[P F Tinmore]

P F Tinmore, et al,

Here you go again with incitement.

until the Jewish State of Israel concedes to Arab Palestinian Demands?

Like the demand to decolonize Palestine?

(COMMENT)

The Jewish State of Israel is NOT a COLONIAL POWER. The "demand to decolonize Palestine" is just another way of demanding Israel surrender.

Worse, its the demand to remove people from a territory based on ethnicity, aka ethnic cleansing.

If you check out BDS, not one person calls for the removal of Jews.

Try again as it is an underlying principle, and you have been shown this many times

And saying it a thousand times more still won't make it true.