Zone1 When Is A Baby Considered Alive?

[ChristisKing]

I've been saying when they get a heartbeat for years but this guy makes a valid point. Plants are alive and they don't have heartbeats. They're alive because they're growing. So I guess a fetus can be alive in that sense.

 

[skews13]

I've been saying when they get a heartbeat for years but this guy makes a valid point. Plants are alive and they don't have heartbeats. They're alive because they're growing. So I guess a fetus can be alive in that sense.

When it's born.

According to the bible, and medical science.

 

[ChristisKing]

When it's born.

According to the bible, and medical science.

Wrong on all accounts. How can a baby kick, cry, and suck his or her thumb if they aren't alive?

 

[Mortis]

Don't you have any kids? You would know this, if you did.

I think Life starts with a heartbeat.

Yes, I know what the guy is saying. But I am sure it is a rare case for a few that don't have a heartbeat and still alive.

Most cases, when a baby starts forming a heartbeat, she/he is usually "officially" alive.

I wonder if those babies who don't have a heartbeat, and still alive, actually go on living a normal life? I a sure they would need some medical device to keep the "heart" pumping somehow.

 

[Arlette]

I've been saying when they get a heartbeat for years but this guy makes a valid point. Plants are alive and they don't have heartbeats. They're alive because they're growing. So I guess a fetus can be alive in that sense.

First dirty diaper.

 

[ChristisKing]

Don't you have any kids? You would know this, if you did.

Not yet. I hope to someday though.

Yes, I know what the guy is saying. But I am sure it is a rare case for a few that don't have a heartbeat and still alive.

No, all babies are alive before a heartbeat in the sense that they're growing inside the womb.

I wonder if those babies who don't have a heartbeat, and still alive, actually go on living a normal life? I a sure they would need some medical device to keep the "heart" pumping somehow.

Huh? What do you mean?

First dirty diaper.

So when a baby is kicking in the womb and at the moment of birth they're not considered alive to you?

 

[JoeMoma]

How is it possible for the zygote to grow to develop a heart beat if it is not alive?

 

[Mortis]

Huh? What do you mean?

I don't know what the medical devices are called.I am not a doctor. But the medical devices that keeps the heart beating.

 

[Arlette]

Not yet. I hope to someday though.


No, all babies are alive before a heartbeat in the sense that they're growing inside the womb.



Huh? What do you mean?




So when a baby is kicking in the womb and at the moment of birth they're not considered alive to you?

I can consider Lima beans to be a desert or a lace curtain to be a blanket. It's all irrelevant.

 

[SassyIrishLass]

Conception. /Thread

 

[ChristisKing]

I don't know what the medical devices are called.I am not a doctor. But the medical devices that keeps the heart beating.

So you're obviously talking about critically ill babies because all regular and healthy human beings have heartbeats.

I can consider Lima beans to be a desert or a lace curtain to be a blanket. It's all irrelevant.

What in the world are you babbling about now?

 

[Oddball]

 

[Mortis]

So you're obviously talking about critically ill babies because all regular and healthy human beings have heartbeats.

Maybe...

I am not a doctor, as I just mentioned. I don't know the terms they use.

 

[ChristisKing]

Maybe...

I am not a doctor, as I just mentioned. I don't know the terms they use.

Mortis you're scaring me if you don't know the fact that all living human beings have heartbeats.

 

[Arlette]

So you're obviously talking about critically ill babies because all regular and healthy human beings have heartbeats.





What in the world are you babbling about now?

I consider you to be an idiot, meaning that's my opinion. Nothing more. It's just another one of your garbage threads.

 

[Mortis]

Mortis you're scaring me if you don't know the fact that all living human beings have heartbeats.

Maybe the guy in the video is scaring you. You made the post.

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

I've been saying when they get a heartbeat for years but this guy makes a valid point. Plants are alive and they don't have heartbeats. They're alive because they're growing. So I guess a fetus can be alive in that sense.

.

But technically, a plant NEVER has a heartbeat. Otherwise there might be a good point here.

I'm Catholic and most of us believe that life starts at the moment of conception.

I'd bet that you'll get a different answer, depending on who you're talking to. Some pro-abort would tell you life starts at birth, until they decided they want to have a child.

For now, I'll stick with the moment of conception, and as someone who has worked for a doctor who performed abortions, the guilt I carry around due to my participation of flushing something obviously human down the lab sink, I only pray that God has forgiven me.

As someone who has converted to Catholicism only a year ago, I know that technically God has forgiven me that sin, but the guilt still lingers.


.

 

[JoeMoma]

Mortis you're scaring me if you don't know the fact that all living human beings have heartbeats.

I disagree. Some living human beings don't have heartbeats..........yet.

 

[shockedcanadian]

Find me the right woman and I will put in the work to try and find out

 

[fncceo]

In Catholicism, a fetus becomes a human being at the moment of conception.

In Protestantism, a fetus becomes a human being at birth.

In Judaism, a fetus becomes a human being the day it graduates medical school.