[
What difference does it make though if somebody worships idols or sheep or dwarfs so long as nothing is required of you either materially or physically? The topic of this thread is tolerance. Tolerance is allowing others to believe or think or do whatever they want that does not violate the rights of anybody else; that requires no contribution of any kind from anybody else.
There is little of wisdom in the bible thanks to it's corruption over time but this bit is wise.
Proverbs 3:12
For whom the LORD loveth he correcteth; even as a father the son in whom he delighteth.
We would still be in the trees if none of us corrected foolish thinking.
It is our duty to our fellow man and reciprocity is a moral tenet of almost all religions.
Do you like to be wrong in your thinking?
Do you not like being corrected when wrong?
Regards
DL
But the thread isn't about correct thinking. It is about religious intolerance that seeks to marginalize or punish or disallow the thoughts, beliefs, and practices of others that do not require anything of us in any way.
Jesus amended some Old Testament teachings, however, by suggesting that we should not be so concerned about those who break the rules, but to rather lead by our own example. I am fairly certain that there is a tiny, tiny minority of people who have ever been persuaded to seek heaven because they were told they were going to hell. And I wonder how many people have not accepted Christ because of the self righteous or hateful way that He was introduced to them? However well intended one might have been, I don't think God approves of that kind of missionary effort.
But so far as the topic goes, in my opinion, those who want to be tolerated are hypocrites if they are not equally tolerant of the beliefs, customs, and practices of others so long as that requires nothing of the non believer. Tolerance is not the same things as acceptance or approval. It is simply the ability to not interfere, to live and let live.
Nicely stated.
In connection with your comment: “
I am fairly certain that there is a tiny, tiny minority of people who have ever been persuaded to seek heaven because they were told they were going to hell” , I would have to disagree.
So here you hit the nail on the head as to one of the various dynamics that motivates religious beliefs: FEAR, fear of being condemned to hell for not believing, the deep seated fear of dying, fear of the unknown and a desire to experience our lives. Perhaps not everyone shares those feeling, perhaps not everyone can. The best way to ameliorate the idea of such injustice and to improving the world is to actively be involved in making this world the kind of world it should be. The onus is on us, not a father figure who will vent his anger and punish us for eternity for not "believing".
If you are comforted by your religious beliefs then there is nothing more to say except that your belief being unsupported and lacking in demonstration may mean you’re living an illusion. I’ve always maintained, I could be wrong, there could be a god, (there’s no reason to assume the Christian conception of god is THE god), or many gods. But the answer is exactly the same. Actively be a participant in making this the kind of world that minimizes human suffering. Saying, "it’s impossible" or "man can never achieve that" is clearly surrendering before you even begin. Would it be easy to do? No. Is it possible? Yeah. Of course it is.
Hope for the best, prepare for the worst. The answer
again is the same -- let's say you spend your entire life making it as good a world as you can -- is your life somehow
wasted if there is no god? Does it count against you? No, it doesn't.
You, all of us, can contribute to making the world better. Do you really need the carrot of an eternal reward to invest a few decades to the human condition? Does it all "matter in the end"? No, but it does matter while you're here. And that's good enough.
In connection with your comment: “
Tolerance is not the same things as acceptance or approval. It is simply the ability to not interfere, to live and let live”, again, nicely stated.
I think that religions can be polarizing in that they are designed to create divisions.
Believing in a particular god(s) makes people feel like they are "on the right team" (else why believe that way??), and while many Christians may try to be humble in terms of their asserted salvation, the fact is, people don’t accept Christianity in an attempt to
not have salvation. That was the point of the faith and the promise of Jesus in the first place!
The belief that “I have the “correct” religion” is the engine that drives intolerance because obviously, if someone has chosen differently, they are wrong, deluded, “in denial” or otherwise purposely rejecting the “correct” message. And my overwhelming experience is that believers find it
very easy to believe because the dynamic of the belief system makes you feel good about choosing "correctly" and it addresses your concerns about mortality. It just doesn't back them up with any authority.