West Point Appointments and High Schools

[Annie]

I know that when one of my son's cross country teamates was admitted, the banquet went nuts with the representative announcing it. That was in the spring of 2001. The high school since has sent 3 more, always having it announced at the awards banquet. Today, the school sends care packages to the former students, for their 'men.'

These are 'highly regarded' alumni:

http://michellemalkin.com/archives/005293.htm

ARMY BANNED IN BOSTON
By Michelle Malkin · May 31, 2006 11:02 AM

***update: the school backs down! Michael Graham reports:

"As I'm about to report exclusively on my show in 20 minutes, King Philip High has backed down under pressure from angry supporters of the US military. They're going to allow representatives of West Point and the ROTC at graduation on Sunday (not tonight's awards event, alas) to make their presentations.

Hooo-ah!"***

Update II: More from the Boston Herald.

Last night, O'Reilly and I briefly discussed San Francisco's campaign to kick the Junior ROTC off of public high school campuses, where 1,600 students are JROTC members.

Now, the madness moves to the Boston area. A high school principal is barring the Army from attending a scholarship banquest featuring two seniors headed to West Point:

Two local high school students have earned scholarships to West Point, but when it comes to awards night at their school the military is not invited.

Some said it's a big disservice to those who are ready to serve their country.

Newscenter Five's Sean Kelly reported that the principal of King Phillip Regional High School in Wrentham, Mass., told the U.S. Army it would not be welcome at a scholarship banquet that will be held to honor two graduates who have received scholarships to West Point Military Academy.

The town has many memorials to military who have made the ultimate sacrifice while serving their country, but some say that kind of patriotism and respect is not reflected at the high school.

"I was disappointed because I thought everyone should really be educated on what West Point is about and how we're going to serve our country," student Jeff Chin said.

"It is a little bit of a disappointment to not have this kind of a special thing for Jeff and I not go on because we've been expecting it," Will Small said.

It is a West Point tradition to have Army officers representing the elite military school award incoming students their scholarships at their own high school banquets. But King Phillip has its own rules that bar such participation.

"I think they are being a little protective. I think they think if they let West Point or Annapolis in, then there will be recruiters that come next and they'll be trying to persuade these kids to join the military," Will's father, Alan, said.
​

More from the Boston Herald:

A Wrentham high school’s refusal to allow West Point officials to congratulate two student appointees at a school banquet has sparked outrage among parents and politicians who are calling the decision "shameful" and "sad."

"I’m upset by it and I’m still puzzled as to why the principal decided to do what she did," said U.S. Rep. James McGovern, D-3rd. "It seems like someone has made a decision and they’re going to stick to it, whether it makes sense or not."

The decision means King Philip High School students Jeffrey Chin of Plainville and William Small of Norfolk will not receive official recognition at tomorrow’s banquet for years of grinding work required to earn acceptance to highly prestigious West Point.

It’s shameful they’re taking this position with a U.S. military academy," said William’s proud father, Alan Small. "I think as educators they have done a good job, but I disagree with this."​

The school has really blown it:

Pam Chin said the most important thing to her at this point is that the awards night not be ruined for the other graduating seniors.

`` I don't want it to become a crazed media event,'' she said. `` This can't effect the other kids.''

She and others said they are confused by the refusal of school officials.

`` The more I hear about it, the less I understand it,'' she said.

Chin said school officials told her only local officials are allowed to present awards and scholarships at the event.

Alan Small, father of Will Small, said he was told that if the school allowed West Point to present, it would have to open the ceremony to all colleges and universities that give scholarships to King Philip students.

Small said his position is that a West Point appointment is different from a college scholarship and school officials should recognize that.

`` I think it's kind of a smoke screen for some anti-military position,'' he said.​

 

[dmp]

West Point = That place is tougher than most of us mere mortals can imagine. For as much Shit as I give 5StringJeff, I honestly respect him to the nth degree for having made it through the program. He faced stresses I may likely never even comprehend in my lifetime.

To the future leaders of The Army.

 

[Annie]

West Point = That place is tougher than most of us mere mortals can imagine. For as much Shit as I give 5StringJeff, I honestly respect him to the nth degree for having made it through the program. He faced stresses I may likely never even comprehend in my lifetime.

To the future leaders of The Army.

Me too! Without reservation!

 

[Hobbit]

I went through some of the toughest of the Naval Academy, and it broke me, both physically and emotionally (if it hadn't been for the physical, I might have stayed). I respect anyone who can finish that place or anyplace similar, though I'll give those at the Colorado Playschool (Air Force) a hard time about their bus driver hats.

 

[5stringJeff]

At our high school awards ceremony, I was presented with a certificate representing my admission into West Point. Apparently, the Army ROTC people had decided to present me with a four-year scholarship also, but didn't bother telling anyone until that morning. So I showed up and got presented both of them!

And, as much as I would like to be humble, it was kind of nice getting a standing ovation from my classmates. It's too bad these new cadets won't be getting one from theirs.

 

[CSM]

West Point = That place is tougher than most of us mere mortals can imagine. For as much Shit as I give 5StringJeff, I honestly respect him to the nth degree for having made it through the program. He faced stresses I may likely never even comprehend in my lifetime.

To the future leaders of The Army.

BAH...just another ring knocker!


Just kidding of course. All of the military academies are tough...they are designed to be that way. Otherwise we would end up having officers who think like a brand spanking new Berkely graduate ::shudder::

 

[William Joyce]

BAH...just another ring knocker!

This was explained to me by a military relative: "ring knockers" or "ring tappers" are what they call West Point grads because they all get a West Point ring, which they habitually tap on the table when demonstrating that they... went to West Point.

 

[5stringJeff]

This was explained to me by a military relative: "ring knockers" or "ring tappers" are what they call West Point grads because they all get a West Point ring, which they habitually tap on the table when demonstrating that they... went to West Point.

Indeed, we do.

 

[pegwinn]

I feel really bad that the new cadets won't get that ovation jeff spoke of. It's pretty sad when a high school is obviously anti military to the detriment of a student.

I heard that the Academies are no longer issuing a regular commission, that it is now a reserve commission same as all the other degreed/ROTC programs. Anyone know if that is true?

 

[5stringJeff]

I feel really bad that the new cadets won't get that ovation jeff spoke of. It's pretty sad when a high school is obviously anti military to the detriment of a student.

I heard that the Academies are no longer issuing a regular commission, that it is now a reserve commission same as all the other degreed/ROTC programs. Anyone know if that is true?

It's been true since the class of 1997. If one stays in 10 years, they have the opportunity to "upgrade" to an RA commission.

 

[pegwinn]

It's been true since the class of 1997. If one stays in 10 years, they have the opportunity to "upgrade" to an RA commission.

Is it a competitive process? Marines with a reserve commission must face an augmentation board (to convert to a regular commission) at the six or eight year mark if memory serves. Many apply, few are chosen.

 

[5stringJeff]

Is it a competitive process? Marines with a reserve commission must face an augmentation board (to convert to a regular commission) at the six or eight year mark if memory serves. Many apply, few are chosen.

I'm really not sure. I got out after five, so I didn't go through the process.