I personally believe in voluntarism and not compulsory mandates when it comes to achieving a common goal. I understand the reasoning behind the stay at home orders and the mandates that governments across the country are doing but I don't think making it as compulsory, especially in such seemingly harsh ways in certain parts of the country, is the most dependable and reliable method. The virus has been so politicized by people that even how to stay at home during the stay at home order is looked at as being a left or right version of that act.
The arguments made by people in power and by experts was to stay at home in order to relieve the burden on hospitals and flatten the curve, not necessarily to wait till we had a vaccine or for the infection rate to go down to near or at zero. The goal posts for ending the orders have been moved over the past weeks and mandates continue in most of the country which is only causing more of a divide in my opinion and a lack of trust in their leadership on all levels. It seemed that every two weeks the goal got extended another two weeks, but what was the extension supposed to accomplish in most areas of the country that wasn't already accomplished based on the initial goal? Now their is bitterness, protests, snitching, politicization, economic depression, confusion, anger, fear, paranoia, and uncertainty all because of strict, seemingly never ending or unnecessary, and in some cases draconian, mandates in my opinion.
I personally believe that if you asked most Americans to voluntarily self quarantine and for businesses to voluntarily temporarily halt operations for a specific amount of time and then be able to reopen at the end of that short and reasonable timeframe to see if it could help ease the burden on hospitals then most would probably have done it without government mandates and police presence to ensure that compulsion. Being able to voluntarily quarantine and then reactivate on their own timeframe based on their circumstances you'd have a more reliable buy in and you would have trust maintained for a longer period of time than being forced to sacrifice. Forced sacrifice never has the same level of achievement in my opinion as voluntary sacrifice does.