We need to stop pretending that this issue is so difficult. It is obvious even to a young child.

[Challenger]

Palestinians lived in the southern Arabian Peninsula until they got pushed out. This is well known.

Do tell...enlighten us with corroborating evidence.

 

[rylah]

Palestinians lived in the southern Arabian Peninsula until they got pushed out. This is well known.

Do tell...enlighten us with corroborating evidence.

Do You really need evidence that Arab tribes trace their roots to Arabia, Hejaz, Yemen?
Who inhabits Sur Bahir & Umm Tuba, Abu Dis, Beit Iksa, Ash....Tammun?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Palestinians lived in the southern Arabian Peninsula until they got pushed out. This is well known.

Do tell...enlighten us with corroborating evidence.

Do You really need evidence that Arab tribes trace their roots to Arabia, Hejaz, Yemen?
Who inhabits Sur Bahir & Umm Tuba, Abu Dis, Beit Iksa, Ash....Tammun?

And besides that, what difference does it make?

 

[rylah]

Palestinians lived in the southern Arabian Peninsula until they got pushed out. This is well known.

Do tell...enlighten us with corroborating evidence.

Do You really need evidence that Arab tribes trace their roots to Arabia, Hejaz, Yemen?
Who inhabits Sur Bahir & Umm Tuba, Abu Dis, Beit Iksa, Ash....Tammun?

And besides that, what difference does it make?

You want to deny Jews their rights, while call the land a "Homeland " of Arab tribes.
Pan Arabism at it's best. And again Jews, Yazidis and the Kurds disagree.

 

[P F Tinmore]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

 

[rylah]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

 

[Indeependent]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

 

[P F Tinmore]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

 

[Indeependent]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

They do if people are trying to kill them.

 

[louie888]

This whole argument is so stupid.

Susan Abulhawa says that she can trace her family in Palestine back 900 years.

Ali Abunimah says his family came to Palestine in 1492 when they were expelled from Spain.

Now, that's awkward.

 

[Indeependent]

This whole argument is so stupid.

Susan Abulhawa says that she can trace her family in Palestine back 900 years.

Ali Abunimah says his family came to Palestine in 1492 when they were expelled from Spain.

The farm village of Najd had 300 people at the beginning of the Ottoman Empire. It is said, but I don't know if anybody knows for sure, that the village was formed in the 7th century. Now, were these people immigrants or were they from elsewhere in Palestine looking for fertile fields? Who knows?

Now, how can anyone say that Palestine is not their homeland?

Y'all have been ducking this question.

They don't say!

 

[rylah]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

 

[montelatici]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Palestine is the homeland of the native people who were living there before the European colonists arrived. Not the homeland of colonists (and their descendants) from elsewhere. Starting from that fact, maybe there can be a way to compromise. Starting from a claim that God gave the land to European colonists is a non-starter.

 

[Indeependent]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Palestine is the homeland of the native people who were living there before the European colonists arrived. Not the homeland of colonists (and their descendants) from elsewhere. Starting from that fact, maybe there can be a way to compromise. Starting from a claim that God gave the land to European colonists is a non-starter.

Let us know when you become an atheist.

 

[Hollie]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Palestine is the homeland of the native people who were living there before the European colonists arrived. Not the homeland of colonists (and their descendants) from elsewhere. Starting from that fact, maybe there can be a way to compromise. Starting from a claim that God gave the land to European colonists is a non-starter.

That's odd. You are claiming that the native people in the "country of Pal'istan" you have invented were invading / colonizing Turks, European Christian Crusaders and absentee landlords in Egypt, Syria and Lebanon.

Let's have you identify when the European Christian Crusaders magically become the "native people".

 

[P F Tinmore]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

 

[Indeependent]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

 

[P F Tinmore]

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

 

[Indeependent]

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?