We need to stop pretending that this issue is so difficult. It is obvious even to a young child.

[Indeependent]

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?

1948 war, dick brain.
The know...the one of several wars you have revised versions of.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?

1948 war, dick brain.
The know...the one of several wars you have revised versions of.

No link?

You are just shoveling Israeli shit.

 

[Indeependent]

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?

1948 war, dick brain.
The know...the one of several wars you have revised versions of.

No link?

You are just shoveling Israeli shit.

I will repeat my instructions from earlier this week...
Look up the 1948 war...No Arab or Jewish sites allowed.
You must either be an idiot, a liar or have dementia because you are always in Wash, Rinse, Repeat mode.
I have it down to idiot or liar.

 

[P F Tinmore]

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?

1948 war, dick brain.
The know...the one of several wars you have revised versions of.

No link?

You are just shoveling Israeli shit.

I will repeat my instructions from earlier this week...
Look up the 1948 war...No Arab or Jewish sites allowed.
You must either be an idiot, a liar or have dementia because you are always in Wash, Rinse, Repeat mode.
I have it down to idiot or liar.

The Palestinians were not a part of the 1948 war.

 

[Indeependent]

Incorrect.

Link?

1948 war, dick brain.
The know...the one of several wars you have revised versions of.

No link?

You are just shoveling Israeli shit.

I will repeat my instructions from earlier this week...
Look up the 1948 war...No Arab or Jewish sites allowed.
You must either be an idiot, a liar or have dementia because you are always in Wash, Rinse, Repeat mode.
I have it down to idiot or liar.

The Palestinians were not a part of the 1948 war.

They ran to enemy territory.
Geesh, Mr. Dementia, we went over this bullshit just a few days ago.
Do you ever get embarrassed by your repetitive bullshit?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Link?

1948 war, dick brain.
The know...the one of several wars you have revised versions of.

No link?

You are just shoveling Israeli shit.

I will repeat my instructions from earlier this week...
Look up the 1948 war...No Arab or Jewish sites allowed.
You must either be an idiot, a liar or have dementia because you are always in Wash, Rinse, Repeat mode.
I have it down to idiot or liar.

The Palestinians were not a part of the 1948 war.

They ran to enemy territory.
Geesh, Mr. Dementia, we went over this bullshit just a few days ago.
Do you ever get embarrassed by your repetitive bullshit?

Of course they did. There were six armies fighting inside Palestine.

And one of those armies was attacking Palestinian civilians.

 

[Indeependent]

1948 war, dick brain.
The know...the one of several wars you have revised versions of.

No link?

You are just shoveling Israeli shit.

I will repeat my instructions from earlier this week...
Look up the 1948 war...No Arab or Jewish sites allowed.
You must either be an idiot, a liar or have dementia because you are always in Wash, Rinse, Repeat mode.
I have it down to idiot or liar.

The Palestinians were not a part of the 1948 war.

They ran to enemy territory.
Geesh, Mr. Dementia, we went over this bullshit just a few days ago.
Do you ever get embarrassed by your repetitive bullshit?

Of course they did. There were six armies fighting inside Palestine.

And one of those armies was attacking Palestinian civilians.

And you can Link to a non-Arab site indicating which of those armies was attacking Palestinian civilians?
Of course you can't which is why you haven't provided a Link.
I'm way more intelligent than you, but you're not intelligent enough to realize that fact.

 

[P F Tinmore]

I'm way more intelligent than you,

Now THAT is funny.

And you prove it by asking a stupid question.

 

[Indeependent]

I'm way more intelligent than you,

Now THAT is funny.

And you prove it by asking a stupid question.

I prove it when you can never provide a Link not from a non-Arab site.
And then you try to add a new angle to the situation which I easily derail.

 

[rylah]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Palestine is the homeland of the native people who were living there before the European colonists arrived. Not the homeland of colonists (and their descendants) from elsewhere. Starting from that fact, maybe there can be a way to compromise. Starting from a claim that God gave the land to European colonists is a non-starter.

Using the same logic Susan Abulahawa who's family was evicted from Spain is a European colonialist.
But then again Judea is not the homeland of Arab Muslims they're with the Greeks and Romans occupiers and colonizers.

You see how easy it works both ways. It's just that anything that Arab Muslims built upon in Palestine has 'Jews' written on it all over.

You Americans are sometimes real hypocrites, tell me are you the famous 'Native Americans'?
Neither are Arabian tribes in Levant.

 

[rylah]

You want to deny Jews their rights,

I never said that.

Do Jews have a right to self-determination and self-defense in their homeland?

You'll begin to dance in 3..2..1... or maybe for the 1st time take the opportunity and get over with this key issue.

Sure, but they do not have an exclusive right.

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

Not at all, in almost every such conversation I agree that Arabs have rights in that land.

Those rights come from their longstanding presence, as Arabs all over the ME.
But there's a reason why in the US not every American is called a 'Native American'.
And that's exactly the reason why You as an American who supports Arab colonialism, insist on missing that point.

 

[Uncensored2008]

It seems like every thread devolves into crap as israel's shills only wish for their narrative to be repeated ad nauseum. As this happens, how simple this topic is gets lost, hence these circular threads that become nothing more than israeli mouthpieces lying and then insulting anyone who dares to disagree, as those who support truth and peace are smeared as racists and terrorists, because hasbara's first rule is to accuse their enemy of exactly what the israeli jews are guilty of.

View attachment 139994

The above illustrates clearly how easy it is to understand what is happening in Palestine. It is the bottom line of the israeli narrative.

It is long past the time to get past this. It is time to see how ridiculous this whole line of "reasoning" truly is. No one in their right mind should be able to argue this idiotic aspect of the israeli narrative.

Let the world know that we know and there can be peace.

For any od israel's shills out there who can't understand the simple cartoon above and that still don't get it, look at like this: G-d said I can have your house. Are you good with that?

So what you are saying is "Allahu Akbar," ISIS boi?

 

[P F Tinmore]

Not at all, in almost every such conversation I agree that Arabs have rights in that land.

Cool, then you favor the right to return.

 

[rylah]

Not at all, in almost every such conversation I agree that Arabs have rights in that land.

Cool, then you favor the right to return.

In a sane settled agreement why not? Certain Arab tribes have developed long lasting understandings with both the Israeli gov and the residents of Judea Samaria.
This could've been solved in quiet, but the way that the Arabs put it publicly, as a tool to overthrow Israel makes the issue a refuge of a much bigger politically driven agreement.

But You prefer the PLO/Hamas version. So be it, but it'll be the end of any potential agreement..

 

[rylah]

Not at all, in almost every such conversation I agree that Arabs have rights in that land.

Cool, then you favor the right to return.

In a sane settled agreement why not? Certain Arab tribes have developed long lasting understandings with both the Israeli gov and the residents of Judea Samaria.
This could've been solved in quiet, but the way that the Arabs put it publicly, as a tool to overthrow Israel makes the issue a refuge of a much bigger politically driven agreement.

But You prefer the PLO/Hamas version. So be it, but it'll be the end of any potential agreement..

Then again we should really invest some attention into the Arab notion that Judea should be Judenrhein.
Still in the context of 'right of return'

 

[rylah]

Not at all, in almost every such conversation I agree that Arabs have rights in that land.

Cool, then you favor the right to return.

In a sane settled agreement why not? Certain Arab tribes have developed long lasting understandings with both the Israeli gov and the residents of Judea Samaria.
This could've been solved in quiet, but the way that the Arabs put it publicly, as a tool to overthrow Israel makes the issue a refuge of a much bigger politically driven agreement.

But You prefer the PLO/Hamas version. So be it, but it'll be the end of any potential agreement..

Then again we should really invest some attention into the Arab notion that Judea should be Judenrhein.
Still in the context of 'right of return'

Remind an American about natives and about the meaning of homeland and........ crickets......
I guess they're all gone to protest for Indian right of return.

 

[Challenger]

Palestinians lived in the southern Arabian Peninsula until they got pushed out. This is well known.

Do tell...enlighten us with corroborating evidence.

Do You really need evidence that Arab tribes trace their roots to Arabia, Hejaz, Yemen?
Who inhabits Sur Bahir & Umm Tuba, Abu Dis, Beit Iksa, Ash....Tammun?

I'd like some corrobotating evidence that Palestinians (who according to Zionists, don't exist) were "pushed out" of the southern Arabian Peninsula, as it's apparently, "well known" to Westwall.

By nice try attempting to muddy the waters.

 

[rylah]

Palestinians lived in the southern Arabian Peninsula until they got pushed out. This is well known.

Do tell...enlighten us with corroborating evidence.

Do You really need evidence that Arab tribes trace their roots to Arabia, Hejaz, Yemen?
Who inhabits Sur Bahir & Umm Tuba, Abu Dis, Beit Iksa, Ash....Tammun?

I'd like some corrobotating evidence that Palestinians (who according to Zionists, don't exist) were "pushed out" of the southern Arabian Peninsula, as it's apparently, "well known" to Westwall.

By nice try attempting to muddy the waters.

Tell me who are the inhabitants of those towns and villages? According to Palestinian Arabs themselves.

Any of the towns I've listed along the couple last pages.

 

[rylah]

Jubbet adh Dhib Village Profile

Location and Physical Characteristics
Jubbet adh Dhib is a Palestinian village in Bethlehem Governorate located at 6.5km (horizontal distance) south-east of Bethlehem City. Jubbet adh Dhib is bordered by Za’tara village to the east, Bit Ta’mir to the north, Beit Ta’mir and Al Furdeis villages to the west, and several Israeli settlements to the south (See map 1).

Families
The inhabitants of Jubbet adh Dhib are predominantly from one main family; Al Wahsh.

History
The word Jubb means well, thus the name of the village Jubbet adh Dhib means the well of the wolf. The locality of Jubbet adh Dhib was established in 1929. Before that time, some nomadic Arab Bedouin were living in the territory. The origin of Jubbet adh Dhib residents goes back to the Arabian Peninsula (Cayman) and the tribe of Bani Harb.

http://vprofile.arij.org/bethlehem/pdfs/VP/Jubbet_Adh_Dhib_vp_en.pdf

 

[Challenger]

Palestinians lived in the southern Arabian Peninsula until they got pushed out. This is well known.

Do tell...enlighten us with corroborating evidence.

Do You really need evidence that Arab tribes trace their roots to Arabia, Hejaz, Yemen?
Who inhabits Sur Bahir & Umm Tuba, Abu Dis, Beit Iksa, Ash....Tammun?

I'd like some corrobotating evidence that Palestinians (who according to Zionists, don't exist) were "pushed out" of the southern Arabian Peninsula, as it's apparently, "well known" to Westwall.

By nice try attempting to muddy the waters.

Tell me who are the inhabitants of those towns and villages? According to Palestinian Arabs themselves.

Any of the towns I've listed along the couple last pages.

What's that got to do with Westwall's comment?