We need to stop pretending that this issue is so difficult. It is obvious even to a young child.

[Indeependent]

Do Palestinian Arabs in Jordan know their rights ARE exclusive and have been since the beginning?
Then why do Palestinian Arabs keep demanding Judenrhein Palestine today?

How are You recognizing Jewish rights when all Your solutions are based on the elimination of their national home?

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?

You got your Link 1,000 times already.

 

[Indeependent]

Challenger...
Got no response?
Click a smiley.

 

[Challenger]

Jubbet adh Dhib Village Profile

Location and Physical Characteristics
Jubbet adh Dhib is a Palestinian village in Bethlehem Governorate located at 6.5km (horizontal distance) south-east of Bethlehem City. Jubbet adh Dhib is bordered by Za’tara village to the east, Bit Ta’mir to the north, Beit Ta’mir and Al Furdeis villages to the west, and several Israeli settlements to the south (See map 1).

Families
The inhabitants of Jubbet adh Dhib are predominantly from one main family; Al Wahsh.

History
The word Jubb means well, thus the name of the village Jubbet adh Dhib means the well of the wolf. The locality of Jubbet adh Dhib was established in 1929. Before that time, some nomadic Arab Bedouin were living in the territory. The origin of Jubbet adh Dhib residents goes back to the Arabian Peninsula (Cayman) and the tribe of Bani Harb.

http://vprofile.arij.org/bethlehem/pdfs/VP/Jubbet_Adh_Dhib_vp_en.pdf

OK, so are you arguing that because 33 people, allegedly from the Bani Harb tribe of Saudi Arabia, settled in this location in 1929, then all Palestinians did the same?

 

[rylah]

Jubbet adh Dhib Village Profile

Location and Physical Characteristics
Jubbet adh Dhib is a Palestinian village in Bethlehem Governorate located at 6.5km (horizontal distance) south-east of Bethlehem City. Jubbet adh Dhib is bordered by Za’tara village to the east, Bit Ta’mir to the north, Beit Ta’mir and Al Furdeis villages to the west, and several Israeli settlements to the south (See map 1).

Families
The inhabitants of Jubbet adh Dhib are predominantly from one main family; Al Wahsh.

History
The word Jubb means well, thus the name of the village Jubbet adh Dhib means the well of the wolf. The locality of Jubbet adh Dhib was established in 1929. Before that time, some nomadic Arab Bedouin were living in the territory. The origin of Jubbet adh Dhib residents goes back to the Arabian Peninsula (Cayman) and the tribe of Bani Harb.

http://vprofile.arij.org/bethlehem/pdfs/VP/Jubbet_Adh_Dhib_vp_en.pdf

OK, so are you arguing that because 33 people, allegedly from the Bani Harb tribe of Saudi Arabia, settled in this location in 1929, then all Palestinians did the same?

Not 33 people. The same goes for all towns and villages I've mentioned.
Palestinian Arabs don't hide their Yemeni, Arabian or even Bosnian origins.

 

[rylah]

Sur Bahir & Umm Tuba Town Profile

History

An ancient story claims that Omar Ben al Khattab held a secret meeting in the area with his army leaders before he entered Jerusalem, and the town was therefore originally named ‘As Sir al Bahir’ (‘the impressive secret’), which later became Sur Bahir (Sur Bahir Mayor, 2012).

The town was established over 1000 years ago, and its original residents were from the Arabian Peninsula and Yemen (Sur Bahir Mayor, 2012)

http://vprofile.arij.org/jerusalem/pdfs/vprofile/surbaherumtuba.pdf

 

[rylah]

Beit Imrin Village Profile

Location and physical characteristics
Beit Imrin is a Palestinian village in the Nablus Governorate located 9.06km north of Nablus city. It is bordered by Yasid and ‘Asira ash Shamaliya to the east, Jaba' to the north, Burqa to the west, Nisf Jubeil and ‘Asira ash Shamaliya to the south. (ARIJ-GIS, 2014) (See Map 1).

History
Beit Imrin village’s was named after Imrin, an honorable man who lived in the village’s hill. The word ‘Imrin’ is believed to be converted from the Syriac word ‘Imrin’ which means “Alsheikh” or prince. Over time the village’s name was converted into Beit Imrin, meaning “House of Princes” (Beit Imrin Village Council, 2013).
The village was established during the Canaanite era. However the ancestors of its residents originally came from Iraq, Yemen, Jordan, and Egypt (Beit Imrin Village Council, 2013).

http://vprofile.arij.org/nablus/pdfs/vprofile/Beit Imrin_vp_en.pdf

 

[rylah]

Salim Village Profile

Location and physical characteristics
Salim is a Palestinian village in Nablus Governorate, located 6.63 km East of Nablus City. It is bordered by Beit Dajan to the East, Deir al Hatab to the North and West, Beit Dajan and Beit Furik to the South (ARIJ-GIS, 2014) (see map 1).

History
The name of Salim village derives from the Syriac word (Salme) which means “idol”. It is said that idols existed in the village and were worshiped as part of the Canaanites customs at that time. During the Roman Period it was called “Sanim” and “Salim” (Al-Dabbagh, 1991) The village was established more than 600 years ago with its residents originating from Yemen and Saudi Arabia. (Salim Village Council, 2013).

http://vprofile.arij.org/nablus/pdfs/vprofile/Salim_vp_en.pdf

 

[rylah]

Where's Montelatici to tell us how all these Arabs from Yemen and al-Hejaz were the original Jews that converted to Christianity

 

[montelatici]

Where's Montelatici to tell us how all these Arabs from Yemen and al-Hejaz were the original Jews that converted to Christianity

Making things up again? Everyone knows that the Palestinians are, for the most part, the descendants of the ancient people of Palestine that converted to Christianity in the centuries following the birth of Christ. Conversion of the Jews, Samaritans, Pagans etc. accelerated after Christianity became the state religion of Rome.

 

[Indeependent]

Where's Montelatici to tell us how all these Arabs from Yemen and al-Hejaz were the original Jews that converted to Christianity

Making things up again? Everyone knows that the Palestinians are, for the most part, the descendants of the ancient people of Palestine that converted to Christianity in the centuries following the birth of Christ. Conversion of the Jews, Samaritans, Pagans etc. accelerated after Christianity became the state religion of Rome.

Because...everybody knows.

 

[montelatici]

Where's Montelatici to tell us how all these Arabs from Yemen and al-Hejaz were the original Jews that converted to Christianity

Making things up again? Everyone knows that the Palestinians are, for the most part, the descendants of the ancient people of Palestine that converted to Christianity in the centuries following the birth of Christ. Conversion of the Jews, Samaritans, Pagans etc. accelerated after Christianity became the state religion of Rome.

Because...everybody knows.

I should have qualified it, serious historians know.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Are you saying that the the Jews have the right to violate the rights of the Palestinians?

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?

You got your Link 1,000 times already.

Typical duck.

 

[rylah]

Farkha Village Profile

Location and Physical Characteristics
Farkha is a Palestinian village in Salfit Governorate located 3.2 km west of Salfit City. It is bordered by Salfit city to the east and north, Qarawat Bani Zaid and Bani Zaid ash Sharqiya (in Ramallah Governorate) to the south, and Bruqin village to the west (ARIJ-GIS, 2013) (See Map 1).

History
Farkha village was named after leading Arab scientist „Abdul Rahman bin Abdullah al Farkhawi‟, while “Al Farkh” literally means a chick or spear blade of wide teeth. The village was established 250 years ago (Farkha Village Council, 2012). Its residents however are descended from the Hijazi tribes (Ad Dabbagh, 1991).

http://vprofile.arij.org/salfit/pdfs/vprofile/Farkha_vp_en.pdf

 

[louie888]

Farkha Village Profile

Location and Physical Characteristics
Farkha is a Palestinian village in Salfit Governorate located 3.2 km west of Salfit City. It is bordered by Salfit city to the east and north, Qarawat Bani Zaid and Bani Zaid ash Sharqiya (in Ramallah Governorate) to the south, and Bruqin village to the west (ARIJ-GIS, 2013) (See Map 1).

History
Farkha village was named after leading Arab scientist „Abdul Rahman bin Abdullah al Farkhawi‟, while “Al Farkh” literally means a chick or spear blade of wide teeth. The village was established 250 years ago (Farkha Village Council, 2012). Its residents however are descended from the Hijazi tribes (Ad Dabbagh, 1991).

http://vprofile.arij.org/salfit/pdfs/vprofile/Farkha_vp_en.pdf

 

[montelatici]

"For we who were Occidentals have now become Orientals. He who was a Roman or a Frank has in this land been made into a Galilean or a Palestinian...."

Fulcher of Chartres 11th Century.

The Crusaders arrived and found Palestinians, and they were Eastern Christians.

 

[louie888]

"For we who were Occidentals have now become Orientals. He who was a Roman or a Frank has in this land been made into a Galilean or a Palestinian...."

Fulcher of Chartres 11th Century.

The Crusaders arrived and found Palestinians, and they were Eastern Christians.

Now, that is AWKWARD.

 

[rylah]

"For we who were Occidentals have now become Orientals. He who was a Roman or a Frank has in this land been made into a Galilean or a Palestinian...."

Fulcher of Chartres 11th Century.

The Crusaders arrived and found Palestinians, and they were Eastern Christians.

Read the quote once again.
Are You claiming now that Palestinian Arabs are Romans and Franks?


Wow thank You.

 

[Indeependent]

"For we who were Occidentals have now become Orientals. He who was a Roman or a Frank has in this land been made into a Galilean or a Palestinian...."

Fulcher of Chartres 11th Century.

The Crusaders arrived and found Palestinians, and they were Eastern Christians.

And I'm sure Charlie was telling the truth as he was slaughtering anyone who disagreed with his Catholicsm.
Now THAT'S awkward.

 

[Indeependent]

They left for Jordan.
They got to Jordan.
Jordan locked them in to where they are.
Your inability to absorb facts is your problem.

The reason people left is irrelevant to the right to return.

Incorrect.

Link?

You got your Link 1,000 times already.

Typical duck.

1948 war, Mr, Duck, duck, goose.

 

[montelatici]

No, I am claiming that the Latin rulers became like the indigenous Christians in language, customs etc. Exactly what Fulcher stated.

"This piece of writing, multi-valent, elusive, in some respects contentious, conveys something of the complexities of Frankish identity in the East, the social and economic imperatives underlying immigration, as well as the aspirations of a particularly thoughtful and articulate member of the ‘new’ Frankish community in the East. It also, I think, serves as a warning to historians attempting the task I have been set for today: to offer an overview of the encounter between Franks and the indigenous peoples of the eastern Mediterranean in the context of the Crusades."

Thanks for leaving me the opening.