Meriweather
Not all who wander are lost
- Oct 21, 2014
- 20,335
- 4,370
- 165
Read on...For in Christ all will be brought to life.If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable. 1 Corinthians 15:19
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Read on...For in Christ all will be brought to life.If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable. 1 Corinthians 15:19
Apparently I have to be dumb enough to believe in a magical afterlife or Christianity will not yield its full benefit.
Christianity is not just a kick ass philosophical system with strong similarities with stoicism but Christianity is full blown psychological therapy as well. I get it but that doesn’t mean God exists. It just means resigning your mind feels good. That explains why so many people fall for it hook, line, and sinker. I could but I worry it would hinder the ambitious side of my existence.
Perfect! You have found eternal life, a life of serving God and others. This life begins here and extends into the afterlife. What more are you looking for? (This is a serious question.)I can do that whether He exists or not. I could follow the Bible 99% of the way and live a good life that benefits others but that comes with a guarantee.
Christianity is not just a kick ass philosophical system with strong similarities with stoicism but Christianity is full blown psychological therapy as well. I get it but that doesn’t mean God exists. It just means resigning your mind feels good. That explains why so many people fall for it hook, line, and sinker. I could but I worry it would hinder the ambitious side of my existence.
If you recognize Christianity works, what is it about God's existence that bothers you so much?
Setting aside the invisible God for a moment, let's take the other issues. First, Jesus did not have magical blood. Go back and re-read the New Testament. Jesus' battle with the religious leaders of his day was over the forgiveness of sins. He started proclaiming, Sins are forgiven! and ran into those who sincerely believed he had no right to make this proclamation. This was no covenant with God, because covenants were sealed with blood. Jesus gave his own very human blood to mark the sign of this New Testament (Covenant). It was a sign he had God's authority to voice this truth: Sins ARE forgiven. Note Jesus did not say or suggest that sins would be forgiven after his death. He was telling people right then, right there, "You sins are forgiven."Nothing really. I have a poor time in these message forums illustrating my full appreciation for Christian both as a philosophy, and as a religion but reject it as a tool of psychotherapy. Mind control is not my thing but I understand its usefulness. I’m not going to “believe” anything that is stupid. I’m not going to believe in an invisible God. I’m not going to believe in magic blood from a man that died 2,000 years ago. I’m not going to believe Jonah lived inside a whale. I’m not going to believe that donkeys or snakes talk. I’m not going to believe in heaven or hell. That’s just taking things too far. I will not accept any man or any gods mandate that I am required to be stupid. If a man or god wants to prove me that these fantastic things are real then I would not be believing them out of blind stupidity anymore. It’s not really that I dislike Christianity at all. It is that I have a strong objection to voluntarily believing things that are untrue.
Let us acknowledge that some believers to make themselves vulnerable to other outlandish claims. Should those who are not vulnerable to other outlandish claims be forbidden to explore their faith and spiritual existence?If a person agrees to believe outlandish claims that are either true or untrue then they make themselves vulnerable to believe other outlandish claims that are backed by a sinister agenda.
I’m not sure why you do not find this system so vulnerable to abuse.
You should follow God on faith. He is invisible and if you are bad He will not talk to you. Just trust me. I know what God wants. Listen to me and you will be Holy in the eyes of God.
Is there any cult leader in the entire world that has never read the Bible? The Bible is hella powerful. If you have the desire to control people in any capacity the Bible is the best resource in existence.
“You can’t see God or hear God but I can. Obey me.” Do you honestly think that passes the smell test of being on the up and up?
The whole concept of God is very important for organizing societies. I get that but haven’t we grown out of that and found a more honest method ?
Let us acknowledge that some believers to make themselves vulnerable to other outlandish claims. Should those who are not vulnerable to other outlandish claims be forbidden to explore their faith and spiritual existence?If a person agrees to believe outlandish claims that are either true or untrue then they make themselves vulnerable to believe other outlandish claims that are backed by a sinister agenda.
You think critically. Pretty sure that beats buying into Spaghettis Monster dogma any day in terms of mental health maintenance. I've witnessed devout Christians still desperately.. agonizingly.. proselytizing to any and all in their death throws. Not a pretty sight. Faith is a nasty Ponzi scheme.
It has been my experience that most people give up studying the Bible and their faith even before they are teenagers. Perhaps it taking too much to heart that a childlike faith is best. Bible studies should include the history, cultures, and languages of Biblical times, which means decades after one leaves Sunday school. The idea that people can read and know the Bible on their own is deplorable. (Too many people believing in talking snakes, donkeys, and the flooding of an entire planet--not to mention Rapture and a six thousand year-old Earth.)Yes and the reason I say that is because others will follow your lead. They may not have the wisdom to differentiate between believing stupid stuff about God and believer stupid stuff about God.
Shrug. It is not about picking and choosing. It is about research and a lot of it. Those who take every word in the Bible literally are those who haven't spent the time researching. Further, it is about living what is being learned. In science, students perform their own experiments, they just don't take the text's word for it. This is even more true for scripture. When do you not let your left hand know what your right is doing; when don't you hide the light under a bushel basket.Pick and choose.. Pick and choose.. No phony Christian here like those people. They like to dip a toe in. Nope. You have to fully commit. All in. Or die tryin'!
I see myself as immersed and in no game. You see, I have a unique set of skills..I peg you for a referee--one who delights not only in watching the game but in pointing out what the players are doing wrong.![]()
You think critically. Pretty sure that beats buying into Spaghettis Monster dogma any day in terms of mental health maintenance. I've witnessed devout Christians still desperately.. agonizingly.. proselytizing to any and all in their death throws. Not a pretty sight. Faith is a nasty Ponzi scheme.
Actually it is. If you created something I could use it as evidence. Anything tangible can be used as evidence, dum dum.None of what you said is empirical proof. So you still have nothing but a fantasy.The just because is because virtue is logical, taz. As for your failure to investigate the only evidence you will ever have until you enter into a relationship with the Creator, that's on you.But no one knows who, how or why the universe was created. I'd accept real, tangible empirical evidence. And you don't have that. For you, it's "my magical invisible friend exists because the universe exists. And my invisible friend cares how we live our live, well... just because."Untrue. The existence of God can be known through the light of human reason by examining what He created. What you mean to say is that you reject all evidence for God. There is no evidence you will accept as proof of God's existence. And then there is Jesus Christ.Because you've shown no empirical proof for your invisible magician.How do you know?You're worshipping a fantasy. If that brings you peace, I'm not against that.Like I said before... You keep worshiping yourself and I'll keep worshiping the creator of existence and we'll see who leads the the more harmonious and peaceful life.So basically, you’re living in a dreamworld.We both know better what you meant, Taz. You dismiss and ridicule what you don't understand.I'm just going by what YOU said.Are you expecting magic again, Taz?So nobody has recorded this voice. Got it. Then you all must simply imagine it.The question is what would that actually look like, right?So someone has recorded this?All the time, through the Holy Spirit who speaks in a very quiet voice.Has God ever spoken to a human?Only those who pray.Has anyone ever spoken to God?![]()
"the Holy Spirit who speaks in a very quiet voice"
So either god is speaking for real, or you're imagining it. Which is it?
From my own personal experiences I have had revelations that when they popped into my head I instantly recognized that they were true. Mind you I am not describing religious revelations, but ordinary everyday kind of things about my ordinary everyday issues that I am confronted with. Usually they happen in the morning when I am in that halfway state of being asleep and being awake. There is only one time when we are not conscious of self and that is when we are asleep. So it makes perfect sense to me that that is the time I am most receptive to the spirit which binds us but is not a part of the material world. This is how I believe revelations work.
You keep worshiping yourself and I'll keep worshiping the creator of existence and we'll see who leads the the more harmonious and peaceful life.
And then there is Jesus Christ.
How do you know?But you made it up.I had no problem.Nobody has any idea where to send me, or go themselves.Then go and find it. No one is stopping you but you.Because people like you say that god kingdom is so fantastic, I want to see it for myself. But so far, nothing but goose eggs.Why should convincing you be important exactly?What would it take to assure you that God is real and God cares about you?
The same way you would prove you are real. I would want Him to stand right in front me me and say, “hi”. That would convince me.
Why? You aren't interested in it. You are here to amuse yourself. Besides, I don't believe you are willing or capable to do what is required. But on the off chance I have you pegged all wrong, it's simple. Die to self. Of course, simple does not necessarily mean easy.Then go and find it. No one is stopping you but you.Because people like you say that god kingdom is so fantastic, I want to see it for myself. But so far, nothing but goose eggs.Why should convincing you be important exactly?What would it take to assure you that God is real and God cares about you?
The same way you would prove you are real. I would want Him to stand right in front me me and say, “hi”. That would convince me.
Just tell us how you found God so that we can use the same method. It turns out this is quite a complicated process for some reason.
Have you ever considered that God hates some people and loves others? (Like the Bible says). If God hates me then He probably doesn’t want me to find Him.
John Calvin is considered the greatest theologian of all times. John Calvin taught that God chooses some and ignores others. His theology actually makes sense and is consistent with the observation of myself and many atheists.
You seem to be an amateur theologian with a theology that makes no sense whatsoever. Are you sure that you and Calvin knew the same god?
Your theology is lacking an explanation for why God reveals Himself to you but refuses to reveal Himself to me. Calvinism explains it plainly and clearly.