Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order Reaches the Supreme Court

[Auld Phart]

She you can scream into the belly of a girl/woman to ask the zygote or fetus.

You just don’t get to decide. It’s not your body.

you're right, it's NOT mine.

it's the babys.

it's the mother's, but only as long as it's in her body.

and it's the baby body as long as it can survive.
(something you seem to be against)

You give the mother a choice, why not the baby?

 

[Correll]

Umm simple - she and her Coyote friends are subject to arrest by US authorities…unlike ambassadors for example.

No, they aren't. We don't even know that they are there. That is the point.

 

[otto105]

you're right, it's NOT mine.

it's the babys.

it's the mother's, but only as long as it's in her body.

and it's the baby body as long as it can survive.
(something you seem to be against)

You give the mother a choice, why not the baby?

For obvious reasons that you deny.

 

[AntonToo]

No, they aren't. We don't even know that they are there. That is the point.

Knowing or not knowing has nothing to with anything. It is entirely a legal matter and yes of course they are subject to laws and enforcement in United States.

 

[Correll]

Knowing or not knowing has nothing to with anything. It is entirely a legal matter and yes of course they are subject to laws and enforcement in United States.

HOW, are they subject to our laws, when they are ignoring our laws and every single law enforcement officer and court official in the nation, does not know that they are there?

 

[ThisIsMe]

Because one was born in US and the others were not.

What’s not to get?

If you are going to make tbe child a citizen why not just make the whole family a citizen.

If the child is a citizen then they run into the problem of the parents being reportable but the child isn't.

What do you do in that dilemma?

 

[AntonToo]

HOW, are they subject to our laws, when they are ignoring our laws and every single law enforcement officer and court official in the nation, does not know that they are there?

If you are going to make tbe child a citizen why not just make the whole family a citizen.

If the child is a citizen then they run into the problem of the parents being reportable but the child isn't.

What do you do in that dilemma?

Thats for parents to decide.

Child is not deportable but they can still take the child back with them.

 

[ThisIsMe]

Thats for parents to decide.

Child is not deportable but they can still take the child back with them.

So, they had the choice to leave without the child or taken the child with them? Right?

 

[AntonToo]

So, they had the choice to leave without the child or taken the child with them? Right?

Yea. I don't know who is going to leave their child but thats the choice.

 

[AntonToo]

HOW, are they subject to our laws, when they are ignoring our laws

Being subject to law is a separate question from you breaking or not breaking the law.

I am subject to my state's tax laws for example, whether or not I evade them.

 

[Correll]

Being subject to law is a separate question from you breaking or not breaking the law.

I am subject to my state's tax laws for example, whether or not I evade them.

You're a citizen. They know you exist. You don't pay, they notice, and can take actions.

The illegals, no one knows where they are, or who they are.

 

[AsherN]

And that means that every visitor is free to commit crimes in the US and can't be prosecuted as they would no lon

The court could rule that "diplomats" represents all non-US citizens, i.e citizens under other jurisdictions or citizens of other countries.

ger be subject to the jurisdiction of the US. Be careful what you wish for.

 

[ThisIsMe]

Yea. I don't know who is going to leave their child but thats the choice.

You don't think they would have thought that to be an immoral choice to thrust upon them? Leave your child behind or take them with you? Obviously they would take the child with them. So then you have to wonder, did they intend for a citizen to leave the country for...18...20 years, and then return to claim their citizenship?

Also, what of the child? Depending on the country they came from, they'd be stuck. If that country doesn't allow dual citizenship, and America doesn't allow parents to renounce the citizenship of their child. The child becomes an illegal immigrants in their own country?

 

[Mac-7]

Hopefully Roberts and Barrett show up at court with their heads out of their asses that day. We know all the crooked Democrats will vote against Trump.

They are closet lib contrarians

I expect very little from those two

 

[WEATHER53]

So, they had the choice to leave without the child or taken the child with them? Right?

Yes they have a choice
Fortunate for them that they do

 

[WEATHER53]

My house is vacant. A man and woman break in and she has a baby . Does all the silliness of rights but no responsibility confer to them and is imposed upon me ?

 

[AntonToo]

You don't think they would have thought that to be an immoral choice to thrust upon them?

They broke laws and face the consequences.

Do we "thurst immoral choices" on other parents that break the laws? Should we not send crime commiting people to jail because they have a child?