Originally posted by CMike
How do you feel about the settlements in Washington, D.C.?
This is not the right forum to debate the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, Mike, but since you insist...
These are the laws of humanity that have been regulating land conflicts since the dawn of our species, CMike:
YOU FORFEIT YOUR RIGHT TO LIVE IN A TERRITORY YOU LOST IN BATTLE THE MOMENT YOU STOP FIGHTING FOR IT, THE MOMENT YOU LOSE THE WILL TO FIGHT FOR YOUR LOST LAND.
We need some tacit, unspoken rules to regulate, to discipline land conflicts because without them the human species would be mired in a hellstorm of land conflicts dating back to
HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF YEARS.
So these are the rules:
AS LONG AS YOU KEEP FIGHTING FOR YOUR LAND YOU STILL HAVE THE RIGHT TO LIVE IN IT. NO PEOPLE IN THE WORLD CAN RESUME THE FIGHT FOR THEIR LAND AFTER STOPPING THE FIGHT FOR CENTURIES AND ACCEPTING THE INVADERS' VICTORY.
Let's apply this rule to 3 concrete cases, Mike:
1 -
Jews under Roman rule
2 -
19th century Mexico
3 -
Palestinians post 1948
1 - Jews lost their right to their land THE MOMENT THEY LOST THE WILL TO FIGHT THE ROMANS AND ACCEPTED EXILE ALL OVER THE WORLD.
2 - Mexicans lost their right to live in their former northern provinces THE MOMENT THEY LOST THEIR COLLECTIVE WILL TO FIGHT FOR THEM.
The moment the last Mexican gave up armed or at least political resistance to the US occupation of Mexico's northern provinces CALIFORNIA, NEW MEXICO, ARIZONA, TEXAS WENT BYE BYE.
NO MEXICAN CAN PRESENT ANY LEGIMATE CLAIM TO LIVE IN AMERICA IN THE 21TH CENTURY BECAUSE THE MEXICAN SOCIETY CAME TO TERMS WITH ITS TERRITORIAL LOSSES AND ACCEPTED AMERICA'S POSESSION OF THAT REGION ALMOST TWO HUNDRED YEARS AGO.
3 - Palestinians have an absolutely valid, legitimate right to live in Western Palestine because the palestinian people never stopped fighting for this right.
If Jews ever get Palestinians to do what Mexicans did 200 years ago, if they get them to abdicate their right to live in Western Palestine or even in the entire region THE LAND WILL LEGITEMATELY BELONG TO THEM, HOWEVER MUCH THEY CAN GRAB.
But as long as Palestinians continue to fight for their land, IT'S UP FOR GRABS.
All the peoples in the world who have lost their land and have never conceded defeat have the sacred right to say to the invaders what Palestinians say to Israelis:
"
Share the land you stole from us or be attacked with deadly force for as long as we see fit."
These are the costumary laws that have been regulating human conflicts for thousands of years:
The moment the natives stop fighting the land belongs to the invader
AND NOT EVEN A SECOND EARLIER.