The Official Discussion Thread for who is considered indiginous to Palestine?

[Sixties Fan]

Jews were a very small minority in Palestine. See the census of 1870 and they didn't count the Bedouin. The ottomans left them alone. It was sleepy and apolitical with the three groups mostly governing themselves. When the European Zionists arrived most were Socialists and they intended to expell the Arabs whether Christian or Muslim. They looked down on the Arabs. They were very nationalistic like the Nazis had been towards them when they revoked Jewish citizenship.

Take this discussion to the other thread.

This thread is about who is indigenous.

Meet you there.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Jews were a very small minority in Palestine. See the census of 1870 and they didn't count the Bedouin. The ottomans left them alone. It was sleepy and apolitical with the three groups mostly governing themselves. When the European Zionists arrived most were Socialists and they intended to expell the Arabs whether Christian or Muslim. They looked down on the Arabs. They were very nationalistic like the Nazis had been towards them when they revoked Jewish citizenship.

PS : One does not count who is the indigenous people in any place in the world by the number of indigenous people one finds at any time in history.

Indigenous people are indigenous people, ask the indigenous people of the Americas, Australia, NZ, Hawaii, and all other places which have been invaded at any time in history since cities and armies were created.

But the only people not having the right to be the indigenous people on their homeland......drum roll..

The Jews.

Thank you for your constant attempts at making the Jews NOT the indigenous people of the land, and endlessly taking away their right to sovereignty over their own ancient homeland.

 

[surada]

Take this discussion to the other thread.

This thread is about who is indigenous.

Meet you there.

The European Zionists were not indigenous. They ridiculed the people who lived there and despised their culture. Would you want 30 million foreigners to move to the US and take your homes?

 

[surada]

PS : One does not count who is the indigenous people in any place in the world by the number of indigenous people one finds at any time in history.

Indigenous people are indigenous people, ask the indigenous people of the Americas, Australia, NZ, Hawaii, and all other places which have been invaded at any time in history since cities and armies were created.

But the only people not having the right to be the indigenous people on their homeland......drum roll..

The Jews.

Thank you for your constant attempts at making the Jews NOT the indigenous people of the land, and endlessly taking away their right to sovereignty over their own ancient homeland.

Jews were a tiny minority. There's more to the history of the Levant than just Jewish history. Where is your family from? Mine is from the Netherlands... Originally England.

 

[Sixties Fan]

The European Zionists were not indigenous. They ridiculed the people who lived there and despised their culture. Would you want 30 million foreigners to move to the US and take your homes?

Stop telling that lie. It works only for people like yourself.
False comparisons. Always.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Jews were a tiny minority. There's more to the history of the Levant than just Jewish history. Where is your family from? Mine is from the Netherlands... Originally England.

This is about who is Indigenous.

Not who ended up becoming part of the history of the area.

 

[surada]

This is about who is Indigenous.

Not who ended up becoming part of the history of the area.

Arabs are semites and they are indigenous to the Levant... Just like the Syrians and Lebanese. 4 Arab tribes were settled in Samaria by Sargon 2. Sargon 1 was an Akkadian Arab.

 

[surada]

Stop telling that lie. It works only for people like yourself.
False comparisons. Always.

The population of Palestine doubled in a period of 15 years with the influx of European Jews. Then the Zionists forced Palestinians into Lebanon and Lebanon's demographic changed almost overnight.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Arabs are semites and they are indigenous to the Levant... Just like the Syrians and Lebanese. 4 Arab tribes were settled in Samaria by Sargon 2. Sargon 1 was an Akkadian Arab.

Arabs speak a semitic language. They are indigenous to the ARABIAN Peninsula, as the name should give anyone who is honest, a hint.

They know it.

You know it.

You can stop lying for Islam.

Islam and Christianity are not going to destroy Israel and drive the Jews away and murder them all at will.

Whatever the wish of extremist Christians and Muslims is to do with Jews, as they want, will not be realized in this century or any other century in the future.

The population of Palestine doubled in a period of 15 years with the influx of European Jews. Then the Zionists forced Palestinians into Lebanon and Lebanon's demographic changed almost overnight.

You are discussing what belongs in the other thread . Are you afraid of the other thread that you refuse to go to it?

 

[surada]

Arabs speak a semitic language. They are indigenous to the ARABIAN Peninsula, as the name should give anyone who is honest, a hint.

They know it.

You know it.

You can stop lying for Islam.

Islam and Christianity are not going to destroy Israel and drive the Jews away and murder them all at will.

Whatever the wish of extremist Christians and Muslims is to do with Jews, as they want, will not be realized in this century or any other century in the future.

You are discussing what belongs in the other thread . Are you afraid of the other thread that you refuse to go to it?

Arabs migrated to Mesopotamia and the Levant long before there was Judaism. No one is going to destroy Israel. Treat people decently and you won't have a problem. Jews lived all over the Arab world for 2500 years. Why?

 

[Sixties Fan]

Arabs migrated to Mesopotamia and the Levant long before there was Judaism.

You do not have one grain of evidence for it, as you have shown in all the other threads.

 

[surada]

You do not have one grain of evidence for it, as you have shown in all the other threads.

There's plenty of evidence of all kinds. The Arabs began to Mesopotamia and the Levant over 10,000 years ago as the glaciers retreated and Arabia became more arid. Have you forgotten about the Amorites and Akkadians? Have you forgotten that Abraham and Moses had Arab wives?

 

[Sixties Fan]

There's plenty of evidence of all kinds. The Arabs began to Mesopotamia and the Levant over 10,000 years ago as the glaciers retreated and Arabia became more arid. Have you forgotten about the Amorites and Akkadians? Have you forgotten that Abraham and Moses had Arab wives?

Your words are endlessly empty. Arabs, indigenous of Arabia, migrated all over the place. It does not make them indigenous of ANY other place on the planet but the ARABIAN Peninsula.

You showed no proof of 10,000 years ago before, on any thread, not now, not ever because there is none.

It is just a lie to make it look like the Palestinians are the "indigenous" people of ancient Canaan.

"Palestinians" know that the are Arabs indigenous from Arabia.

It is only Israel that is making the leaders want the land as "part of the Islamic Empire"

When the Hashemites took TransJordan. Not a word.

When the Egyptians and the Hashemites took Gaza and Judea and Samaria.....NOT A WORD.

You do know very well why the Arabs keep screaming at the Jews not being indigenous.

And that is WRONG.

When are you going to stop helping with the lies which are only meant to provoke ignorant people to attack Jews, as Jews are being attacked AROUND the WORLD.

And not a sigh from you as it continues to happen.

Stop Antisemitism.

Stop Jew Hatred.

It starts with you.

 

[Open Bolt]

The European Zionists were not indigenous.

History and DNA says that they are.

Jews were a tiny minority.

Because most of them had been forcibly expelled against their will.

 

[surada]

History and DNA says that they are.



Because most of them had been forcibly expelled against their will.

In 70 AD? Omar invited them to return. They are all the same people although many of the European Jews have light colored hair and blue eyes.

 

[Open Bolt]

In 70 AD?

I forget the exact year. A lot were expelled by that Hadrian guy who built the wall in England.

Omar invited them to return.

Well now they have.

 

[Sixties Fan]

In 70 AD? Omar invited them to return. They are all the same people although many of the European Jews have light colored hair and blue eyes.

Such racism, prejudice. Beware of what you ask for.

You do not get to decide who is a Jew and what Jews ought to look like.

Christian learned prejudice against the European Jews, and ONLY after 1948.

Hitler had no problem murdering millions of European Jews, knowing that they were indigenous of Ancient Canaan. He wanted them to leave Germany and be free to return to their homeland.

Al Husseini had other ideas, since before Hitler, in 1920.

 

[surada]

Such racism, prejudice. Beware of what you ask for.

You do not get to decide who is a Jew and what Jews ought to look like.

Christian learned prejudice against the European Jews, and ONLY after 1948.

Hitler had no problem murdering millions of European Jews, knowing that they were indigenous of Ancient Canaan. He wanted them to leave Germany and be free to return to their homeland.

Al Husseini had other ideas, since before Hitler, in 1920.

Jews were also persecuted in the US. The mufti wanted to slow foreign immigration because the European Jews had already doubled the population. Anyone who calls themselves a Jew are Jews in my book ..

 

[Sixties Fan]

Jews were also persecuted in the US. The mufti wanted to slow foreign immigration because the European Jews had already doubled the population. Anyone who calls themselves a Jew are Jews in my book ..

You are discussing something other than someone's indigenous status.

Hatred for Jews does not give anyone the right to stop the Jews from immigrating, returning to their ancient homeland.

 

[surada]

You are discussing something other than someone's indigenous status.

Hatred for Jews does not give anyone the right to stop the Jews from immigrating, returning to their ancient homeland.

You all stopped the Palestinians from returning with guns.