So what you have are horseshit numbers that are all over the feild, that a lot of people died in either the Russian Civil War or World War II.
It's war, dumbass. People die in wars.
And the real numbers, save those killed in WWII, which really were high, aren't anywhere near that.
No. It was not war, dumbass!
Once again you lie.
None of these estimates are war related, including the 15 to 20 million Russians he murdered. Mostly civilians. Political enemies. I'm talking about the people he slaughtered for years mostly
before the war and the additional five million he killed throughout Eastern European
after the war, you know, more political enemies of the state. I'm talking about the victims of the Great Purge and The Subjugation, not the casualties of war.
We know they were born. We know they disappeared. Shut up!
As for the Russian civilians he killed, the reason the 15 to 20 million number is murky is because Soviet officials destroyed the official documentation attesting to many of these people's existences. However, the existence of approximately 7 million are directly accounted for via documentation that escaped destruction, birth certificates and other official documents preserved by counter-operatives and gotten out of Russia. We also have the court documentation for many of those who were tried, of course, on trumped up charges and executed out right or died in prison. Also, some of the information about these was gleaned during "The Thaw" of Khrushchev's tenure.
So we have you denying the slaughter of 7 million that are beyond all reasonable dispute! But I suppose that number's too large to be a tragedy for you, just a statistic. Right?
Approximately 6 to 7 million of the "erased" are known to have existed based on the cross-referenced accounts of family members, letters, bills, regional censuses and, yes, the word of defectors, moles and operatives.
Stalin created a special "erasure group" of several hundred that hunted down the official documentation of the people he killed and destroyed it. He even had a staff consisting of several dozen whose sole job was to sit at tables and ink over the names of the people he killed on censuses. While all other official documentation of their existence was destroyed, he did not always destroy these. Instead, they were returned to the various regional offices of record, blacked out names and all! Stalin took particular pleasure in this. Naturally, he did this to instill fear and obedience.
As for the other 6 to 7 million, that estimation is based on uncorroborated, second-hand accounts coupled with a mathematical probability of reliability. These include the unknown millions believed to have died in the man-made famine campaigns, and the erasures of the inhabitants of whole villages that were raised and buried, plowed and planted over. Several hundred-thousand of these were finally corroborated from official records after the fall of the Soviet Union. Clearly, certain VIPs in intelligence defied Stalin's orders, hid documentation of the massacres, the orders, the reports of the various operations and then, under Khrushchev, who hated Stalin, stored them with the rest of the regime's secrets. The mass graves that had not been heavily built over and could be located were unearthed.
Further, there is no justification for continuing to hold, torture, deprive and, consequently, kill the common line soldiers of a defeated and subdued nation for 10 years. There is no justification for rounding up defenseless, unarmed civilians of a defeated nation and killing them for sport and revenge.
I'm talking about those this paranoid, psychopathic narcissist murdered out of spite and for pleasure.
I'm talking about a monster who missed being on the other end of the Allies' wrath only because he was played by Hitler in a treacherous scheme to violate and divvy up Poland, a monster who didn't liberate Eastern Europe from that other monster's tyranny, but stole millions of people's lands and lives. Hell, I didn't even count the million or so members of the various armed resistances he killed, those who struggled to throw off his occupation
after the war.
This sick bastard murdered his own wife! Personally. With his own hands. The official story: suicide. You know, the wife who feared and loathed him, as did his children, the people who, unlike the propagandized "rabble", knew him to be a cruel and abusive monster, prone to unpredictable outbursts of rage. The man who psychologically terrorized the members of his own family, that benevolent father looking down at the children gathered around him as shown in drawings plastered on the walls of villages and cities. He was a true psychopath in the clinical sense from youth, a man without a conscience, lizard eyes, devoid of empathy or compassion, elevated to a position of leadership over the barbaric Bolshevik hoard by Lenin because of his sadism, for his skills, those of an assassin and enforcer, skills plied and honed during his criminal career of robbery, rape and murder before the Revolution.
Only a sociopath would justify the life and times of this worthless, loathsome cretin of pure evil.
The best and most reliable works regarding Stalin's reign of terror and crimes against humanity are
The Great Terror: Stalin's Purge of the Thirties,
The Great Terror: A Reassessment,
Victims of the Soviet Penal System in the Pre-War Years: A First Approach on the Basis of Archival Evidence and The Dewey Commission's
Not Guilty.
Correction: from my notes and studies of various works on the matter I see that I misremembered an important detail. Those who died in the various gulags and detention camps are counted among the estimated 15 to 20 million Russian civilians of the Great Purge proper, not in addition to.
Sorry.