The rescue mission was a disaster and Carter took the blame for it
Amazing the small differences between a successful mission and a disaster. Obamas bin Laden mission was considered a major success. But one of the helicopters crashed on the wall of the compound. A few feet either way and dozens of SEALS could have been killed
That's what it means to be the CiC. Remember Truman's "The Buck Stops Here"? Being the Commander in Chief means it's his responsibility. If the mission fails, it's his fault for calling it. If it succeeds, it means he get to pin the medals and give the credit to those who actually completed the mission.
the buck stop here is a great campaign slogan but the reality is that even the president cant control specific actions during war. He can get with his generals and work up a plan and he can approve it, but he does not pick the specific players. He also is not able to predict unforeseen or unplanned events that may or may not come about during any mission.
His buck stopped when he approved the mission as suggested by his advisers.
the only way the CIC could be considered at fault for things going wrong, unplanned things, would be if he put his old ass in the seat of the copter and lead the rescue himself. Im pretty sure he did not do that.
I personally did not like him as a president at the time, or as I reflect back years later, but in all fairness, he did, I think, everything he could do to get the hostages back alive.
Easy as shit to sit at my computer 30 years later knowing everything (that they tell us) that went wrong and suggest these things should have been considered, I am going out on a limb to say, the situation might be different if I had to have been the one making these decisions while the event was in play.
Still didnt like him though.I did like Reagan except for that horrific error of amnisty. Looking back (again) He should have known it was going to open a flood gate of illegals hoping to be here the next time it happened. But, looking back, we now have to realize that even suggesting its going to happen is going to cause a mad rush for our border. hillary knows this, and hillary is counting on it to increase the democrats numbers. She is selling out the country but this time she has the advantage of history to show her its a mistake, and she is going to do it anyway.
But back to Carter, the plan may have failed but I still think he tried and he showed the leadership that we expect from our president.