Zone1 so where in the Bible does it say it's a sin to talk to Mary?

[LeroyDumonde]

Jesus established ONE Church, the Catholic Church

It was called Catholic at least as early as 107 AD, probably earlier but records don't always go back too far.

In any case, we can blame Luther for all the different denominations. He broke with the CC, then people who followed him broke with him and started their own churches, then people broke with those ones and so on and so on...

Chaos

God is not the author of chaos

Weren't you already informed on this board that long before the Protestant Reformation there was the Great Schism? Long before that you had earlier splits like Arianism. Even Peter and Paul had disagreements about circumcision. Interestingly, Peter, the alleged first Pope of the RCC, admitted to being wrong. So much for papal infallibility.

 

[1miseryindex]

Weren't you already informed on this board that long before the Protestant Reformation there was the Great Schism? Long before that you had earlier splits like Arianism. Even Peter and Paul had disagreements about circumcision. Interestingly, Peter, the alleged first Pope of the RCC, admitted to being wrong. So much for papal infallibility.

Infallibility has nothing to do with being wrong on mundane matters or even seemingly non-mundane

Outsiders don't understand Infallibility

or much of anything re catholicism

 

[LeroyDumonde]

Infallibility has nothing to do with being wrong on mundane matters or even seemingly non-mundane

Outsiders don't understand Infallibility

or much of anything re catholicism

It wasn't a mundane matter. It strikes at the heart of the relationship between Christians and the Mosaic Law.

 

[Blackrook]

Mary is a good woman. It's weird how the Protestants hate her so much.

 

[ninja007]

Mary is a good woman. It's weird how the Protestants hate her so much.

youre a liar. nobody hates Mary.

 

[BS Filter]

Talking to the dead is witchcraft.

 

[marvin martian]

I've read the entire DR Bible, most reliable version known to man

Never have I seen it there that we cannot talk to Christ's Mother. That said, I actually naturally talk to Jesus and the Father more than I do Mary, but still...

Yeh... If we are to always go by the Bible (and not so much the Church that produced it)

I say we Catholics are good to talk to Mary

since it is not forbidden in the Bible...

Never heard that before. In the Orthodox church we venerate and pray to the Theotokos (Mother of God) all the time, in every service.

 

[1miseryindex]

Mary is a good woman. It's weird how the Protestants hate her so much.

it's weird how they hate all things Catholic, including Catholic individuals

they haven't even personally met or gotten to know

 

[1miseryindex]

Talking to the dead is witchcraft.

you should spend your time attacking ACTUAL witchcraft

or maybe you're afraid the witches will attack you.. whereas Catholics will not

 

[1miseryindex]

Talking to the dead is witchcraft.

I tend to think those who hate Catholicism probably don't like Christianity of any form

as much as they claim

just a thought

 

[1miseryindex]

Talking to the dead is witchcraft.

weird to say that Mary is dead

totally WEIRD

never heard of Fatima, I guess... the thief on the cross is in paradise but Mary is dead

please

 

[BS Filter]

you should spend your time attacking ACTUAL witchcraft

or maybe you're afraid the witches will attack you.. whereas Catholics will not

Your Bible says talking to the dead is witchcraft. Read it once in a while.

 

[1miseryindex]

Your Bible says talking to the dead is witchcraft. Read it once in a while.

I've read the whole thing. I doubt you have. Mary is in Heaven and there is NO death there

Check it out once in awhile

 

[BS Filter]

I tend to think those who hate Catholicism probably don't like Christianity of any form

as much as they claim

just a thought

Just quoting the Bible.

 

[BS Filter]

I've read the whole thing. I doubt you have. Mary is in Heaven and there is NO death there

Check it out once in awhile

Since you've read the entire Bible, show us the Scripture that tells us to pray to Mary.

 

[onefour1]

Matthew 6:9
9 After this manner therefore pray ye: Our Father which art in heaven, Hallowed be thy name.

 

[Woodznutz]

I've read the entire DR Bible, most reliable version known to man

Never have I seen it there that we cannot talk to Christ's Mother. That said, I actually naturally talk to Jesus and the Father more than I do Mary, but still...

Yeh... If we are to always go by the Bible (and not so much the Church that produced it)

I say we Catholics are good to talk to Mary

since it is not forbidden in the Bible...

Talk away, she doesn't hear ya.

 

[BS Filter]

Talk away, she doesn't hear ya.

It's forbidden to talk to the dead.

 

[Carl in Michigan]

I've read the entire DR Bible, most reliable version known to man

Never have I seen it there that we cannot talk to Christ's Mother. That said, I actually naturally talk to Jesus and the Father more than I do Mary, but still...

Yeh... If we are to always go by the Bible (and not so much the Church that produced it)

I say we Catholics are good to talk to Mary

since it is not forbidden in the Bible...

Mary is dead and buried, awaiting the Resurrection of the Dead at Christ return.

 

[JustAGuy1]

I've read the entire DR Bible, most reliable version known to man

Never have I seen it there that we cannot talk to Christ's Mother. That said, I actually naturally talk to Jesus and the Father more than I do Mary, but still...

Yeh... If we are to always go by the Bible (and not so much the Church that produced it)

I say we Catholics are good to talk to Mary

since it is not forbidden in the Bible...

It doesn't, it's just she can't do anything for you. Just go straight to the source.