"Senator Kennedy, I Refuse to be Shackled by Your Question."

[meaner gene]

Do you or do you not condone abortion for any reason at any time? Yes/No. Where's the 'flip?'

Already answered

Which is why it wasn't a simple yes/no question.
Abortion up until birth for any reason by the mother - NO!
Abortion up until birth for any reason by the doctor - YES!

 

[meaner gene]

If you say 'no' it doesn't mean abortion in dire circumstances can't be done. Which is what I already told you. Yes means you WOULD condone an abortion for convenience which is also what I already said.

Actually it does.

 

[Leo123]

Already answered

Your answer was bullshit.

 

[meaner gene]

Your answer was bullshit.

I gave the conditions for Yes and the conditions for No

 

[Leo123]

I gave the conditions for Yes and the conditions for No

Kennedy did not give conditions. You're trying to change the subject.

 

[meaner gene]

Kennedy did not give conditions. You're trying to change the subject.

That was the problem. It's like my question, should police have the power to shoot totally unarmed people with no criminal record and not previously wanted by the police.

It should be a simple Yes / No.

 

[Seymour Flops]

That was the problem. It's like my question, should police have the power to shoot totally unarmed people with no criminal record and not previously wanted by the police.

It should be a simple Yes / No.

The answer is no 99% but with a caveat that if someone is applying deadly force or inflicting severe injury without being armed, cancel Christmas.

 

[meaner gene]

The answer is no 99% but with a caveat that if someone is applying deadly force or inflicting severe injury without being armed, cancel Christmas.

So the answer is YES 1% of the time.
and the answer is NO 99% of the time.

That's not a single answer, that's two answers. Kennedy wanted them to pick just one with no qualifications.

 

[meaner gene]

This proves that very few questions can be answered with a simple Yes / No, when it involves a wide range of situations to be covered.

 

[Leo123]

So the answer is YES 1% of the time.
and the answer is NO 99% of the time.

That's not a single answer, that's two answers. Kennedy wanted them to pick just one with no qualifications.

Kennedy asked a different question.

 

[meaner gene]

Kennedy asked a different question.

My question was even simpler. With fewer exceptions, and people couldn't and people couldn't answer it with just Yes / No.

 

[meaner gene]

Kennedy would ask Schrödinger if his cat was alive, yes / no.

 

[Leo123]

My question was even simpler. With fewer exceptions, and people couldn't and people couldn't answer it with just Yes / No.

The thread is not about you.

 

[Leo123]

Kennedy would ask Schrödinger if his cat was alive, yes / no.

Not the subject.

 

[meaner gene]

The thread is not about you.

Not the subject.

Actually it is. As the OP points out. Some questions can't be answered with a simple Yes / No.

 

[Leo123]

Actually it is. As the OP points out. Some questions can't be answered with a simple Yes / No.

We’re talking about Sen. Kennedy not you and your pretend world where you change the subject because you’re losing.

 

[meaner gene]

We’re talking about Sen. Kennedy not you and your pretend world where you change the subject because you’re losing.

It's funny, how many questions that you cry as being "off topic", are examples of questions like what Kennedy asked. And all phrased so as not to be answerable by a simple yes / no.

And meant to make it look like the person doesn't have an answer, and not that they can't give an exacting answer, but for having to answer with only yes / no.

Since Kennedy's question didn't address any exceptions.

 

[Leo123]

It's funny, how many questions that you cry as being "off topic", are examples of questions like what Kennedy asked. And all phrased so as not to be answerable by a simple yes / no.

And meant to make it look like the person doesn't have an answer, and not that they can't give an exacting answer, but for having to answer with only yes / no.

Since Kennedy's question didn't address any exceptions.

No, you gave no similar examples and, yes, Sen. Kennedy's questions can be answered with a simple yes or no. You just want the option for infanticide apparently. Sen. Kennedy's question did not say no exceptions either, you're lying.

 

[meaner gene]

No, you gave no similar examples and, yes, Sen. Kennedy's questions can be answered with a simple yes or no. You just want the option for infanticide apparently. Sen. Kennedy's question did not say no exceptions either, you're lying.

Kennedy mentioned a woman who supposedly asked for an abortion in her 34th week of pregnancy.

“Should the mother at that juncture have the right — clearly a viable child — to abort the child?” Kennedy asked one witness, who said he didn’t want to engage in hypotheticals.

 

[meaner gene]

How do I know Kennedy posed a question that couldn't be answered by a simple yes/no.

Because Senator Kennedy put it on his senate website.

Democrat witnesses refuse to answer Kennedy question: “Do you support abortion up to the moment of birth?”

Watch full video of Kennedy’s exchange here. WASHINGTON – Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.), a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee, today questioned hearing witnesses about whether they support making it legal to abort, with unfettered discretion, an unborn child up to the moment of birth. Two...

www.kennedy.senate.gov

PRESS RELEASES

Democrat witnesses refuse to answer Kennedy question: “Do you support abortion up to the moment of birth?”