Certainly not FDR.
1. Arthur Schlesinger, Jr.,
liberal New Deal historian wrote in The National Experience, in 1963, “Though the policies of the Hundred Days had ended despair, they
had not produce recovery…” He also wrote honestly about the devastating crash of 1937- in the midst of the “second New Deal” and Roosevelt’s second term. “The collapse in the months after September 1937 was
actually more severe than it had been in the first nine months of the depression: national income fell 13 %, payrolls 35 %, durable goods production 50 %, profits 78% .
2. In 1935, the Brookings Institution (left-leaning) delivered a 900-page report on the New Deal and the National Recovery Administration, concluding that “ on the whole it retarded recovery.” Articles & Commentary
I understand that this bit of remediation will not change neither your thinking nor your posts, but I appreciate the fact that we, therefore, make a dynamite pair.
You go on fudging the truth, and I'll go on correcting you!
You are really just too funny, PC. You cite a
1935 Brookings Institution report (the series of economic programs called "The New Deal" took place over three years,
through 1936, so any "conclusion" by Brookings would have been premature.) But then you go on to post a link trying to prove that "conclusion" came from Brookings when in fact it's from the right wing American Enterprise Institute dated 2007!!!
"...when in fact it's from the right wing American Enterprise..."
What a great opportunity you have to eat crow, Mags....
...you couldn't be more wrong....and the honorable thing would be to apologize.
Now,
you're honorable, aren't you?
You really need to clean your specs....or find out what quotation marks mean. The phrase "on the whole it retarded recovery" is a direct quote from Brookings.
And, before your abject apology, you might wish to ruminate over the following:
"In February 1935, Roosevelt asked Congress that the NRA be extended another two years. Congress did vote for an extension, but only for one year because of all the complaints. Despite RichbergÂ’s efforts, opposition to the NRA grew stronger and stronger by the time the
U.S. Supreme Court struck it down as unconstitutional on May 29, 1935.
Economists at the Brookings Institution reported, “The NRA on the whole retarded recovery.” Roosevelt’s Brain Truster Raymond Moley was among the framers of the NRA who later acknowledged
the error of their ways. “Planning an economy in normal times is possible only through the discipline of
a police state,” he reflected."
Obama’s Link to “Old Iron Pants” by Jim Powell
And:
"Not only, did the NRA provide fewer advantages than unionists had anticipated, but it also failed as a recovery, measure. It probably even
retarded recovery by supporting restrictionism and price increases,
concluded a Brookings study."
Hist 221 FDR Bernstein « Gil Troy — Courses
So, it was a statement by the Brookings Institute, wasn't it?
And...did you get the reference to a "police state"... you down with that, too?
Isn't it a wonderful education you get here?
Did I just ruin your evening?