One State solution

[elektra]

There is no race of people called Palestinians. Seems stupid to refer to Arabs as such.

 

[aris2chat]

Give the Palestinians their own state, and those Jews who choose to stay can become citizens of that state. There is no reason for the new state to be Jew free since Israel is certainly not Arab free. I realize that there are those who are salivating over a one-state solution because they feel that eventually the Arabs will take over.

The Palestinians won't agree to a Swiss-Cheese state that doesn't give them access to Jerusalem, and surrounds them with settlements that cannot be accessed.

Better to just make the place one big state with autonomy for each community.

Without a good faith effort at negotiation then the Palestinians will get only what Israel will give them. They will be isolated to their two plots, no refugee will be allowed. Israel will occupy the mount and there will be a christian and a jewish place of prayer along side the muslims. The only muslims allowed on the mount will be tourist and Israelis. PA/G will not get foreign aid or service from Israel. Jordan, Egypt and Israel will be checking any cargo in or out of the PA/G for contraband. Palestinians will not be allowed entry to Israel without proper visas and documents. They will likely be given a hospital like arm bands, or under the skin implants that will tract them within Israel.
PA/G will need to buy their water and electricity, since they can't maintain their own facilities. Jordan, Israel and Egypt will set the price and if they don't pay will unplug them. Garbage and sewage services will have to be paid for as well to avoid disease and parasites.
PA/G will become the siberia of the middle east. Arab state will either absorb the palestinians, keep them in minimal conditions or end up using them as near indentured servitude labor.
They will become less than the kurds, syrians or afghani on the food chain of muslim identity. They literally will become forgotten people, stateless, vagrants eating from trash cans and sleeping in cardboard boxes with in the "ghettos" camps.
As a drain in the arab's state economy, it might even be considered to limit the number of children they can have, or be expected to afford a child before being allowed to mate.
Marriage, mating will not be allowed if the couple are cousins unless at least three times removed to try and avoid birth defects.
They will live under such circumstances because they will have no choice. Weapons of any kind will be forbidden to them, so they cannot rise up against what ever state they are stuck in. They might well be traced when they are outside the camp/ghettos, and if they don't return on time their family will be held accountable. They will be much like the untouchables of India. They will be like lepers of the biblical era. Begging will not be staged as it is out side many camps, but the only way they will be able to live. No UN support, no large checks from the oil rich, no foreign aid from the west. Smuggling and stealing will result in Islamic punishment, hands and feet by the sword.

They can negotiate with the Israelis, come to some "compromise" instead of demands. Make peace and stop teaching hate and violence of their neighbors. They can build their economy side by side with Israel, or........ they can have nothing at all. They have been living off the world charity long enough.