Againsheila
Gold Member
there are several myths about adhd
there are several myths about adhd that have become quite popular", default", but still to this day remain unproven.
Dispel the myths. There are several myths about adhd that have become quite popular, but still to this day remain unproven. Sadly, we continue to hear that parents are being told these same myths over and over again. Simply put, these myths are misinformation. Misinformation can cause confusion and frustration, and if heard enough times can cause a person to make the wrong choices.
Have you been told?
1. That there is an actual test to detect if your child has add/adhd?
answer: There is no test in existence to determine the diagnosis of adhd. there is no objective test (blood, urine, bodily fluids, bile, or brain) that a doctor can use as an indicator of add/adhd.
How we know this: In 1998 the national institute of health held a conference on adhd. At the end of this conference they issued this statement: “….we do not have an independent, valid test for adhd, and there are no data to indicate that adhd is due to a brain malfunction.”
2. Brain/pet scans as tests?
have you been told that there is a brain/pet scan that can determine that you child has adhd, but that this scan is so expensive that it is not affordable by the majority of people, and that insurance companies do not pay for it?
answer: There is no exact brain/pet scan that determines conclusively that a child has this disorder.
how we know this: On november 16-18, 1998, at the national institute of health consensus conference on adhd, it was revealed that the on-average, 10% brain atrophy, seen in adhd subjects, on mri (structural) scans, was due, not to the never-validated disease, adhd, but to the long-term methylphenidate/amphetamine “treatment” on all of the adhd subjects.”
there are several myths about adhd
okay, my information is older than this therefore, perhaps i'm wrong. There is nothing in the above that states adhd doesn't exist, and it ignores completely the blind studies where the children do better on the drug than off.
and now you reference more in-linked studies...there are studies that say steroid users run faster in your world it would seem logical to then assume before the drugs they had a medical muscular disorder...if you want to make the argument that there is nothing wrong with a little bit of speed to stay focused and get the job done you might have a case..but there is no case for ADHD is a brain disorder
The difference is that with the drug, it only works if the child IS ADHD. That's why the blind study. So the teachers nor the parents or even the doctor know if they are getting the drug that week or the placebo. After the test, they determine which week they did best, if it matches up with the drug then they are ADHD. Some people try the test again to be sure, I have no problems with that. My son couldn't sit still for 5 minutes without the drug when he was in 1st grade. I took him off it in 3rd grade due to side effects. There are other things to do to help, like behavioral modification and making sure they get plenty of exercise during recess, etc. My son's school didn't know and didn't suspect anything when I took him off the drug but boy were they made when a year and a 1/2 later they found out he was no longer on the drug. I was a pariah as far as they were concerned. And suddenly my son started having behavior problems again, problems he didn't have when they thought he was on the drug. I ended up removing him from that school and homeschooling him for a few years.
BTW, when my son was in 7th grade, I took him to a private psychiatrist and he was diagnosed with asperger's syndrome. Something I suspected back when he was in 2nd grade but of course, because I suggested it, he couldn't possibly have it. Oh, and hyperactivity, he still had that. So did my other Autistic son. For him, we paid a lot of money for a drug patch to keep him from being so hyper because it wasn't designed for that reason and the insurance company refused to pay for it even with a letter from his pediatric neurologist.
So we know Hyperactivity exists. Is it just the ADD part of it you believe is made up?

