Meanwhile, in fdr's Concentration Camps....

[francoHFW]

As usual the liberal FDR defenders have the argument upside down and backwards. You have to scratch your head when FDR defenders claim that revenge based on foreign atrocities justifies the most notorious race based violation of the Constitution since slavery.

Of course no families were separated like Trump is doing, and separated for good in many cases. Great job, scumbag GOP and silly dupes like you...

 

[francoHFW]

actually that is the very definition of mitigation“Would have” is pathetic, guilt-ridden speculation. Only democrats HAVE done.

.

What about republican-led discrimination laws against Asians? Limits on immigration Etc. And they would have done worse in 1941.

“Yeahbut” and “would have” do not mitigate the scumbag fdr’s crime.

Actually that is the very definition of mitigation

Actually, you need to go take a remedial English class.

There were only one or two Republicans that had any problem with it at all, dumbass.
https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-Republican-response-to-FDRs-Japanese-internment-camps

 

[whitehall]

As usual the liberal FDR defenders have the argument upside down and backwards. You have to scratch your head when FDR defenders claim that revenge based on foreign atrocities justifies the most notorious race based violation of the Constitution since slavery.

Of course no families were separated like Trump is doing, and separated for good in many cases. Great job, scumbag GOP and silly dupes like you...

Families? You mean kids illegally entering the U.S. escorted by coyote slave traders? Even Obama thought it was a good idea to separate them. Anyway it still doesn't justify a president depriving U.S. citizens of their liberty without due process on a freaking executive order.

 

[Unkotare]

Thus far, only democrats HAVE done that thing in the US. Spew all the idiotic nonsense you want, it won’t change that FACT, shitstain.

And the Republicans would have done the same thing or worse, but vote for the lying thieving brainwashing give away to the rich screw the rest GOP...

“Would have” is pathetic, guilt-ridden speculation. Only democrats HAVE done.

.

What about republican-led discrimination laws against Asians? Limits on immigration Etc. And they would have done worse in 1941.

“Yeahbut” and “would have” do not mitigate the scumbag fdr’s crime.

.

 

[Unkotare]

.

What about republican-led discrimination laws against Asians? Limits on immigration Etc. And they would have done worse in 1941.

“Yeahbut” and “would have” do not mitigate the scumbag fdr’s crime.

Actually that is the very definition of mitigation

Actually, you need to go take a remedial English class.

There were only one or two Republicans that had any problem with it at all, dumbass.
https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-Republican-response-to-FDRs-Japanese-internment-camps

Whose name is on the EO, suckass?

 

[francoHFW]

As usual the liberal FDR defenders have the argument upside down and backwards. You have to scratch your head when FDR defenders claim that revenge based on foreign atrocities justifies the most notorious race based violation of the Constitution since slavery.

Of course no families were separated like Trump is doing, and separated for good in many cases. Great job, scumbag GOP and silly dupes like you...

Families? You mean kids illegally entering the U.S. escorted by coyote slave traders? Even Obama thought it was a good idea to separate them. Anyway it still doesn't justify a president depriving U.S. citizens of their liberty without due process on a freaking executive order.

It was extremely rare under Obama, super duper, not like this disgraceful mess. I'm not familiar with your last phony scandal...

 

[ThunderKiss1965]

Battling fascism and oppression around the world, and that villain fdr was building concentration camps right here in the US.


Survivor recalls life in internment camp for Japanese-Americans Japan Today Japan News and Discussion


http://www.japantoday.com/category/...ul-truths-about-japanese-american-internment/


"Attempting escape, resisting orders, and treason were all punishable by death in internment camps. Guards would face little consequence for killing without just cause.

A mentally ill man in his mid-forties, Ichiro Shimoda, was shot trying to escape in 1942. He’d attempted suicide twice since entering the camp, and the guards were well aware of his mental illness. That same year, two Californians were killed during an alleged escape attempt from the Lourdsburg, New Mexico camp. It was later revealed that Hirota Isomura and Toshiro Kobata were both extremely weak upon arrival—too weak to walk, much less escape.

A handful of guards went to court for their wrongdoings but with disappointing results. One guard was tried for the 1943 murder of an elderly chef named James Hatsuki Wakasa. He was found not guilty. Private Bernard Goe was also tried after killing Shoichi James Okamoto. Goe was acquitted and fined for unauthorized use of government property. The amount: $1—the cost of the bullet used to kill the victim."

You should know that the US interred German and Italian Americans as well during the war.

 

[Unkotare]

Battling fascism and oppression around the world, and that villain fdr was building concentration camps right here in the US.


Survivor recalls life in internment camp for Japanese-Americans Japan Today Japan News and Discussion


http://www.japantoday.com/category/...ul-truths-about-japanese-american-internment/


"Attempting escape, resisting orders, and treason were all punishable by death in internment camps. Guards would face little consequence for killing without just cause.

A mentally ill man in his mid-forties, Ichiro Shimoda, was shot trying to escape in 1942. He’d attempted suicide twice since entering the camp, and the guards were well aware of his mental illness. That same year, two Californians were killed during an alleged escape attempt from the Lourdsburg, New Mexico camp. It was later revealed that Hirota Isomura and Toshiro Kobata were both extremely weak upon arrival—too weak to walk, much less escape.

A handful of guards went to court for their wrongdoings but with disappointing results. One guard was tried for the 1943 murder of an elderly chef named James Hatsuki Wakasa. He was found not guilty. Private Bernard Goe was also tried after killing Shoichi James Okamoto. Goe was acquitted and fined for unauthorized use of government property. The amount: $1—the cost of the bullet used to kill the victim."

You should know that the US interred German and Italian Americans as well during the war.

That's true. You should look at the number of German-Americans and Italian-Americans who lived on the East Coast at the time and the relative proportions of them arrested compared with over 100,000 Japanese Americans on the West Coast thrown into fdr's concentration camps. You should note this discrepancy mindful of the fact that Germans on the East Coast actually did engage in espionage and sabotage, whereas no Japanese-American was ever convicted of such during the war. German Americans were (and are) the largest ethnicity by family background in the US at the time and there was a vocal pro-Nazi element among them, but proportionately so, so, so many fewer were incarcerated when in fact there was a (feeble and constitutionally indefensible) argument for doing so. What was the difference? Hmmmmm? What could it have been...?

 

[regent]

As I understand it, the Germans and Italians that were considered a potential problem had been identified for some time and they were picked up pretty quick. No such ID
had been made on the Japanese and Japanese- Americans and that solution was not feasible. I wonder if those picked up and interred voted Republican or Democratic after release? How do Japanese and Japanese-Americans vote today?
Another problem the internment created was for some posters to keep up the criticism of a deed long past.

 

[Unkotare]

The sickening, illogical apologists for that scumbag son of a bitch fdr are as shameless as they are un-American.

 

[regent]

The sickening, illogical apologists for that scumbag son of a bitch fdr are as shameless as they are un-American.

Yep, FDR put millions in camps during the war, but then War is often described as Hell.

 

[Unkotare]

The sickening, illogical apologists for that scumbag son of a bitch fdr are as shameless as they are un-American.

Yep, FDR put millions in camps during the war, ...

No, not millions, but over 100,000 innocent, loyal, brave AMERICANS were thrown into fdr’s concentration camps.

 

[regent]

It was millions that went into U.S army camps, naval camps, Marine Corp camps, stockades, without their families, and thousands of lives lost, and you want us to feel guilty because we put some Japanese and Japanese-Americans, whose status was unknown, into camps? War is hell.

 

[Unkotare]

Trying too hard to play the apologist leads to statements of illogical and anti-American nonsense like that. ^^^^^^^

What a shameless disgrace.

 

[Picaro]

The sickening, illogical apologists for that scumbag son of a bitch fdr are as shameless as they are un-American.

Yep, FDR put millions in camps during the war, ...

No, not millions, but over 100,000 innocent, loyal, brave AMERICANS were thrown into fdr’s concentration camps.

lol rubbish. over a third of them were not citizens and were never going to be citizens, and the Japanese community was famous for its patriotism and enthusiasm for the Homeland's military victories for the entire century. They also didn't feel compelled to report Japanese agents attempting to recruit spies and saboteurs among them immediately prior to the war, either.

You pieces of American hating dogshit just need to get new hobbies, or deport yourselves, is all.

 

[Picaro]

It was millions that went into U.S army camps, naval camps, Marine Corp camps, stockades, without their families, and thousands of lives lost, and you want us to feel guilty because we put some Japanese and Japanese-Americans, whose status was unknown, into camps? War is hell.

They all stayed after being released; we're still waiting to hear any real horror stories for the little bit of time they were detained. They would have faced a lot of violence from their neighbors if they were left on the coast anyway; Fillipino fishermen were already attacking them before Pearl Harbor. Then there are those Japanese in the interior and in the East who weren't interned, the numbers of which these lying idiots don't seem to know.

 

[Camp]

Abe would not disagree with you.

Japan was invading other countries from 1933 on. Burma, Korea onto China Wow. America stopped funding Japan, which pissed them of to the point they attacked us at Pearl Harbor. Sneak attack. What reason did Japan have for this? Long term comprehension, spelling and grammar optional. Japan was an international menace, killed millions, started the war in the pacific. Saying "We are sorry", priceless.

Citing Japanese atrocities is not a defense for placing innocent Americans in concentration camps. How can allegedly educated Americans possibly promote that idiotic argument? You could almost understand rounding up all the Japanese on Hawaii but they didn't. FDR's executive order only put middle class hard working Japanese American citizens in jail in California. It's unbelievable that the same people who are adamant about so-called "sanctuary cities" for illegal aliens would defend FDR's order to incarcerate American citizens.

Who knew where their loyalty was. .

No Japanese-Americans were convicted of espionage or sabotage throughout the war (unlike German Americans), and the 442 is still the most highly decorated unit in U.S. Military history.

Who was really loyal was pretty fucking clear, and it wasn't that scumbag fdr.

Calling FDR a scumbag for interning Japanese in WWII is the same as calling America and what we refer to as "The Greatest Generation" as scumbags.

The action to intern the Japanese was overwhelmingly supported by the American population. They believed and many still believe that if not for the US Navel victories in the Pacific against the huge overwhelming force of the Japanese Navy, the US west coast would have experienced major attacks.

The guy you call a scumbag was the guy responsible for insisting, promoting and eventually developing and producing advanced aircraft carriers and attack aircraft that defeated the Japanese Navy, which would have been greatly advanced technologically if FDR did not have the knowledge of Navel warfare and the skill to advance the US Navy in a way that would shock the Japanese Navel commanders. The US Navy would have most surely been defeated in the Pacific if FDR's advancement had not been supported and made during his first two terms in office during the 1930's.

Most people are not knowledgeable or ignore an important fact about FDR. He served as Assistant Secretary of the Navy for seven years, 1913 to 1920, before during and after WWI. Before becoming a politician he spent years working with and coordinating military affairs and spending time with military commanders. He was in fact, a military expert with a military background.

 

[Ravi]

The sickening, illogical apologists for that scumbag son of a bitch fdr are as shameless as they are un-American.

Fdr was wrong out of fear. trump is wrong because he caters to the fear of his supporters, that he has manufactured.

He's the bigger scumbag by far.

 

[Picaro]

FDR wasn't wrong.

 

[Unkotare]

FDR wasn't wrong.

He was an arrogant, irresponsible, dishonest, disloyal, anti-American scumbag.