Lawsuit: Michigan teacher tried to force Palestinian American student to stand for Pledge

[Lisa558]

ummmm... this lefty left left leftist certainly is not. * can you name any on this board that said that?


* i am not 'ok' with it, but ummm they can.


per the constitution.


i am also not ok with the KKK chanting anything ... but they have the right to.

i wonder- do YOU think they have the right to, lisa?

And P.S. Are not allowed to call out posters by name, but yes….there have been many leftists who are OK with it. We even had one who said Jews who are criticizing the calls by the antisemites to kill Jews are advancing Islamophobia.

Get that? if I complain about a Muslim invoking Hitler’s desire to kill all the Jews, I am told that I am the bigoted one.

 

[Lisa558]

didn't say that, now did i, lisa?

anyhoo, is that mooooslem child involved in violence, lisa?

Have no idea what Muslim (I didn’t know they were called Moooslem when they’re young) you’re talking about. The starving one because HAMAS isn’t letting the food through in order to make Jew look bad?

I know you’re not talking about the toddler and infant who were kidnapped and tortured to death, and then had Palestinians celebrate at the sight of their coffins. Those were Jewish children.

 

[Lisa558]

get one, lisa.

I knew what YOU were implying with your seig heil comment. Duh.

I was pointing out that it is YOUR side marching around with the Hitler calls to kill the Jews.

 

[Jroc]

my father fought in the philippines during WW2 - served as a belly gunner

(' cause he was short ) & i am positive he's rolling over in his grave at how the US is now a fascist state.

I'm sure he embarrassed that you support Jew hate..child mutilation via the transgender movement wide open borders and America last ... People like you are an Embarrassment to the country

 

[playtime]

I'm sure he embarrassed that you support Jew hate..child mutilation via the transgender movement wide open borders and America last ... People like you are an Embarrassment to the country

ooooooOOOOOOOOOoooooo ... that took some brain cell sparks! kudos!!!!!


but you're wrong ... daddy was a lifelong (D), union dude - worked in a silverware factory, forging them. he had the burns on his arms to prove it. he wouldn't care who you were, as long as you weren't a (R).

 

[cnm]

I am sure Hamas is terrible as a form of government. BUt they came to power because Fatah was too busy sucking up to the Zionists and stealing Western Aid.

No, Hamas came to power as Nutty's device to reduce the influence of the Palestinian Authority. He facilitated their finance for years.

 

[cnm]

Leave the room and you're really adamant about the anti-American stuff find another school

So much for freedumb, eh?

 

[Lisa558]

ooooooOOOOOOOOOoooooo ... that took some brain cell sparks! kudos!!!!!


but you're wrong ... daddy was a lifelong (D), union dude - worked in a silverware factory, forging them. he had the burns on his arms to prove it. he wouldn't care who you were, as long as you weren't a (R).

So that just tells me you come from a family who hates Republicans. No wonder you’re so brainwashed against us.

P.S. I myself used to be a Democrat. But I woke up.

 

[Lisa558]

So much for freedumb, eh?

I would like the freedom to wear my Jewish Star again, but I live in a liberal area and the vile against Jews is bad here.

 

[Jroc]

So much for freedumb, eh?

The classroom is a dictatorship you fool

 

[Jroc]

ooooooOOOOOOOOOoooooo ... that took some brain cell sparks! kudos!!!!!


but you're wrong ... daddy was a lifelong (D), union dude - worked in a silverware factory, forging them. he had the burns on his arms to prove it. he wouldn't care who you were, as long as you weren't a (R).

Those Democrats don't exist anymore JFK wouldn't be a Democrat he'd be drummed out of the party ...the Democratic party has been taken over by the leftist they're not even liberal anymore.. they're leftist nut jobs ...your point is irrelevant ...your father's party doesn't exist anymore

 

[Jarlaxle]

How is forcing Jewish kids to sing some German song comparable to having American kids say the Pledge?

Are you playing stupid?

The classroom is a dictatorship you fool

No. You are wrong. This has been settled since 1943, and has been explained to you over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over. Just stop.

 

[irosie91]

Are you playing stupid?



No. You are wrong. This has been settled since 1943, and has been explained to you over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over. Just stop.

calm down kids-----lets take a clear look at the situation----my impression is that the ***** refused
to stand-----not that she refused to ENUNCIATE the pledge. My take is that the teacher should
not have forced her to RECITE----but had every right to insist that she STAND----it is a point of common
courtesy and decency-----if the ***** refused to stand, her muzzie ass should have been ejected from the
room

 

[Jarlaxle]

calm down kids-----lets take a clear look at the situation----my impression is that the ***** refused
to stand-----not that she refused to ENUNCIATE the pledge. My take is that the teacher should
not have forced her to RECITE----but had every right to insist that she STAND----it is a point of common
courtesy and decency-----if the ***** refused to stand, her muzzie ass should have been ejected from the
room

No, you're wrong.

 

[irosie91]

Are you playing stupid?



No. You are wrong. This has been settled since 1943, and has been explained to you over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over, over, and over, and over. Just stop.

calm down kids-----lets take a clear look at the situation----my impression is that the ***** refused
to stand-----not that she refused to ENUNCIATE the pledge. My take is that the teacher should
not have forced her to RECITE----but had every right to insist that she STAND----it is a point of common
courtesy and decency of conduct-----if the ***** refused to stand, her muzzie ass should have been ejected from the room nor would it have been remiss for the teacher to speak to her at HER LEVEL-----as in ----"your behavior is DISGUSTING and UNACCEPTABLE IN THIS CLASSROOM"

 

[Jarlaxle]

calm down kids-----lets take a clear look at the situation----my impression is that the ***** refused
to stand-----not that she refused to ENUNCIATE the pledge. My take is that the teacher should
not have forced her to RECITE----but had every right to insist that she STAND----it is a point of common
courtesy and decency of conduct-----if the ***** refused to stand, her muzzie ass should have been ejected from the room nor would it have been remiss for the teacher to speak to her at HER LEVEL-----as in ----"your behavior is DISGUSTING and UNACCEPTABLE IN THIS CLASSROOM"

No. You are wrong. This has been settled law since 1943.

 

[irosie91]

No, you're wrong.

wrong about what? Children are even graded on CONDUCT in grammar school. The muzzie girl
chose to breach the norms of decent conduct. If a Protestant child chose to spit on the ground every
time the muzzie girl came near------would that be his CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT? How about a kid
openly stating " I'm not sitting next to the muzzie *****"------freedom of expression?

 

[Jarlaxle]

wrong about what? Children are even graded on CONDUCT in grammar school. The muzzie girl
chose to breach the norms of decent conduct. If a Protestant child chose to spit on the ground every
time the muzzie girl came near------would that be his CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT? How about a kid
openly stating " I'm not sitting next to the muzzie *****"------freedom of expression?

OK...now you are just babbling. Are you having some sort of medical episode?

 

[irosie91]

OK...now you are just babbling. Are you having some sort of medical episode?

you are diverting in order to cover your inability to discuss the actual situation. To
what sort of medical episode do you imagine you refer?----try to be specific or are
you just babbling?-

 

[jbrownson0831]

‘A Palestinian American student in Michigan is suing a middle school teacher and Plymouth-Canton Community Schools, claiming in federal court that the educator violated the student's First Amendment right by attempting to force the student to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. The East Middle School teacher, Carissa Soranno, according to the lawsuit, allegedly told the student, “Since you live in this country and enjoy its freedom, if you don’t like it, you should go back to your country.”

The student, 14, is referred to as D.K. in the suit and is represented in the claim in U.S. District Court in Detroit by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Michigan and Arab American Civil Rights League. The student did not want to stand for the pledge because she believes the U.S. government has supported Israel in the Israel-Hamas war that has devastated Gaza and left thousands dead, according to the claim.

The suit, filed June 25, asks for a judgment that finds the educator's actions unconstitutional and awards damages, claiming Soranno's actions inflicted emotional distress on the student. A spokesperson for Plymouth-Canton Community Schools did not immediately respond to a request for comment from the Detroit Free Press, part of the USA TODAY Network. Soranno did not answer a voicemail left by a reporter at a phone number associated with her name.

"The right to freely speak — or not speak — is a form of protest that is fundamental to a well-functioning democracy — even when its exercise creates controversy or makes others uncomfortable," wrote Bonitsu Kitaba, interim legal director for the ACLU of Michigan, in a news release.’

Lawsuit: Michigan teacher tried to force Palestinian American student to stand for Pledge

A Palestinian American student in Michigan is suing a middle school teacher and school district, claiming the educator violated the First Amendment.

www.usatoday.com

West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette (1943): students can’t be compelled to say the Pledge of Allegiance in public school.

Scraping the bottom facediaper....