Israeli Logic

I can't agree with this one. At this point there is no chance for peace. The Israeli's MUST apply the geneva conventions to the letter and segregate the combatants from whatever legitimate civilians there might be and repatriate the combatants.

Then maybe

But as it is now the culture of terrorism is so pervasive in Arab Muslim society in Israel there can never be peace. Its time to face the realities and stop coddling the Arab Muslims in Israel.

I was arguing ideals, not realities in that particular post. I agree with you. There is no chance for end-of-conflict or a Palestinian state at this moment. They simply aren't capable of doing what they need to create a state.

More and more, I am seeing the best hope as being an agreement and land swap between Israel, Jordan and Egypt. If only we could find some incentives for Jordan and Egypt. I'll start a thread on it.

I look forward to seeing it.

But "not another inch" is going to be my mantra on any peace deal. The Israeli's MUST maintain defensible borders and I think they are just perfect right where they are.

The real issue is, who's gong to take all these terrorists. Israel will eventually have to deport the enemy combatants if there's ever to be peace. And they can't just hand off areas of Israel to states with dubious intentions.

In any case Israeli logic at this point seems to be to coddle the Arab Muslims in Israel, which clearly isn't a policy thats working.
 
I look forward to seeing it.

But "not another inch" is going to be my mantra on any peace deal. The Israeli's MUST maintain defensible borders and I think they are just perfect right where they are.

The real issue is, who's gong to take all these terrorists. Israel will eventually have to deport the enemy combatants if there's ever to be peace. And they can't just hand off areas of Israel to states with dubious intentions.

In any case Israeli logic at this point seems to be to coddle the Arab Muslims in Israel, which clearly isn't a policy thats working.

Israel just can't absorb the Palestinian and Gazan populations without risk to itself. So, in the end there must be either a massive forced population transfer (an immoral solution) or a transfer of territory.

As for the terrorists, shrug, no one seems to care when Muslim Arab kills Muslim Arab. Let Jordan and Egypt handle it. Not Israel's problem.
 
There is nothing immoral about repatriation. The GC is clear that repatriation is required and the world body engages in forced repatriation regularly.

Look what is going on with the Syrian refugees in Europe right now.
 
You still haven't understand what the word repatriation means.
 
You still haven't understand what the word repatriation means.

Means to send back to ones country of origin, although under the Geneva Conventions it can also mean being sent back to just about anywhere as its not the responsibility of the host nation to determine the final destination of POWs

Why ?
 
The country of origin of the Muslim and Christian Palestinians is Palestine, which includes Israel. Geneva Conventions use the same definition of repatriation.
 
The country of origin of the Muslim and Christian Palestinians is Palestine, which includes Israel. Geneva Conventions use the same definition of repatriation.
No actually they're Jordanians, Egyptians, Syrians, etc. and Gazans are mostly Egyptians.

Even the Hamas leader admitted it. Ooooops:

 
The country of origin of the Muslim and Christian Palestinians is Palestine, which includes Israel. Geneva Conventions use the same definition of repatriation.

Horse shit

The last citizenship they held was Jordanian. ;--)

And what definition would that be Monty ole bean.

And tell me all about the conventions ;--) I'd be shocked if you've even read them

And you might be interested to know that repatriation is discussed in more than one area of the conventions ;--)
 
View attachment 69952

Yep. Truth is the truth.

The US invades countries, wants to build a wall, steals natural resources, kills women and children and say it is the victim of Muslims.

Maybe the Israelis learned from the US, maybe the US learned from the Israelis.

Certainly the way Sharon and Bush were working, you'd have to assume they were on the same page.
 
View attachment 69952

Yep. Truth is the truth.

The US invades countries, wants to build a wall, steals natural resources, kills women and children and say it is the victim of Muslims.

Maybe the Israelis learned from the US, maybe the US learned from the Israelis.

Certainly the way Sharon and Bush were working, you'd have to assume they were on the same page.
If we stole resources why in the hell are gas prices so damn high? We didn't get shit out of the invasions other than doing Israels work for them. Other than I agree with you. That shit needs to stop and we need to stay the hell home and fix shit here. The Wall NEEDS to be built to save America.
 
View attachment 69952

Yep. Truth is the truth.

The US invades countries, wants to build a wall, steals natural resources, kills women and children and say it is the victim of Muslims.

Maybe the Israelis learned from the US, maybe the US learned from the Israelis.

Certainly the way Sharon and Bush were working, you'd have to assume they were on the same page.
If we stole resources why in the hell are gas prices so damn high? We didn't get shit out of the invasions other than doing Israels work for them. Other than I agree with you. That shit needs to stop and we need to stay the hell home and fix shit here. The Wall NEEDS to be built to save America.

So high? High?

1m_small.gif
$35 isn't high for a barrel of oil.

world_oil_prices.png


Lower oil prices since 2003.

Actually, the US got a lot out of the invasion of Iraq. It got cheaper oil prices. Why? Because OPEC was becoming stronger, led by Hugo Chavez. The attempted coup against him, the invasion of Iraq, sanctions against Iran, then the bombing of Libya, all part of a policy the US has of making sure OPEC doesn't control oil prices.
 
You guys are idiots if you think the collapse of oil prices is because of some ingenious US foreign policy.

Our foreign policy is a cluster fuck at this point. Obama may have run a clean presidency and have been pretty good with domestic policy but his foreign policy leaves a lot to be desired.

And Israel certainly had exactly nothing to do with it.
 
You guys are idiots if you think the collapse of oil prices is because of some ingenious US foreign policy.

Our foreign policy is a cluster fuck at this point. Obama may have run a clean presidency and have been pretty good with domestic policy but his foreign policy leaves a lot to be desired.

And Israel certainly had exactly nothing to do with it.

No ingenious foreign policy at all. Taking out OPEC members in no ingenious.

However you only need look at what the US has done to the four OPEC members who were opposed to the US in 2001, to see where US foreign policy lies.

Syria? Fuck Syria, who cares about Syria? Not worth invading. The Ivory Coast? Where?

Libya, hell yeah, Libya is bad and evil and needs to be taken down instantly.

However it's not just this that has led to lower oil prices. However this has helped massively.
 
You guys are idiots if you think the collapse of oil prices is because of some ingenious US foreign policy.

Our foreign policy is a cluster fuck at this point. Obama may have run a clean presidency and have been pretty good with domestic policy but his foreign policy leaves a lot to be desired.

And Israel certainly had exactly nothing to do with it.

No ingenious foreign policy at all. Taking out OPEC members in no ingenious.

However you only need look at what the US has done to the four OPEC members who were opposed to the US in 2001, to see where US foreign policy lies.

Syria? Fuck Syria, who cares about Syria? Not worth invading. The Ivory Coast? Where?

Libya, hell yeah, Libya is bad and evil and needs to be taken down instantly.

However it's not just this that has led to lower oil prices. However this has helped massively.

Well we're miles off topic but everyone else does it so why not.

I'd be tempted to disagree. first the Iraq oil is hitting the world market. The Iran oil is hitting the world market. Saudi can't afford to stop pumping, neither can Russia. And then there's the good ole USA. Drill baby drill. We're eeking every last drop from every last well right now and to hell with the future. The USA is swimming in oil at a time when renewables are growing by leaps and bounds.

Oversupply and lack of demand = collapse

And there's no end in sight.

Hell I read several articles today about prices going even lower over the next year or so and its effects on oil dependent economies.

US foreign policy should have foreseen this and made accommodations both at home and abroad. Now we have way to many well producing, way to few left for a time of need and renewables storming ahead regardless. The only thing that could have happened was a collapse in oil prices.
 
You guys are idiots if you think the collapse of oil prices is because of some ingenious US foreign policy.

Our foreign policy is a cluster fuck at this point. Obama may have run a clean presidency and have been pretty good with domestic policy but his foreign policy leaves a lot to be desired.

And Israel certainly had exactly nothing to do with it.

No ingenious foreign policy at all. Taking out OPEC members in no ingenious.

However you only need look at what the US has done to the four OPEC members who were opposed to the US in 2001, to see where US foreign policy lies.

Syria? Fuck Syria, who cares about Syria? Not worth invading. The Ivory Coast? Where?

Libya, hell yeah, Libya is bad and evil and needs to be taken down instantly.

However it's not just this that has led to lower oil prices. However this has helped massively.

Well we're miles off topic but everyone else does it so why not.

I'd be tempted to disagree. first the Iraq oil is hitting the world market. The Iran oil is hitting the world market. Saudi can't afford to stop pumping, neither can Russia. And then there's the good ole USA. Drill baby drill. We're eeking every last drop from every last well right now and to hell with the future. The USA is swimming in oil at a time when renewables are growing by leaps and bounds.

Oversupply and lack of demand = collapse

And there's no end in sight.

Hell I read several articles today about prices going even lower over the next year or so and its effects on oil dependent economies.

US foreign policy should have foreseen this and made accommodations both at home and abroad. Now we have way to many well producing, way to few left for a time of need and renewables storming ahead regardless. The only thing that could have happened was a collapse in oil prices.


Well, the point here was that the US does steal and do all the other things the Israelis have been accused of.

Stealing oil? Well not quite, going around and making sure everyone does what the US does.

So, it's on topic, this isn't just Israeli logic, this is US logic too.

Yes, oil has gone down in price because of a lot of supply of oil. But why?

Well the US pumping out oil. However the US is not pumping out enough to cover 50% of its usage. China is there using a lot of oil too, growing and growing every day.

So, what happened? Well, OPEC decided to group together more tightly to make themselves lots of money from producing less.

The US and Bush reacted to this and decided to take out those leaders in countries that were not pro-US but OPEC. In 2001 that was Iraq, Iraq, Libya and Venezuela.

2002 was the coup d'etat against Hugo Chavez, the US didn't exactly hide its influence and money spending on this one, ironically by a part of the US govt devoted to developing democracy (by installing non-democratically elected leaders in place of democratically elected leaders. Go figure.)

2003 was the invasion of Iraq.

Sanctions against Iran and then Venezuela (the latter under Obama) and the bombing of Libya (again under Obama).

So, oil prices did rise because Iraq was taken off line, but Iraq is now pumping out far more oil.


petroleum_production_consumption.png


You see the dip post 2000 when Chavez was playing games? You see a rise from there on in, until today when the Iraqis are producing far more than they've done in a long, LONG time.

This helps to reduce prices. Libya has reduced production because of the war. However US production has helped to reduce prices. With Iraq and the US pumping it out, OPEC is weak and there isn't the resolve for them to keep prices high, without Iraq, with Chavez gone from Venezuela, with Gaddafi gone from Libya, the Saudis are powerless. This is the point of US foreign policy.

So, stealing it might not be, but it might as well be. The US has gone out there and made this happen.
 
View attachment 69952

Yep. Truth is the truth.

Hey, you're a Trump supporter. Trump wants to build a wall to keep out Mexican immigrants. Can't Israel build a wall to keep out bloodthirsty terrorists?
Forget that it if Israel had not invaded and stolen the land there would be no need to build a wall. They should invaded and colonized Madagascar. That way the world could block them from the mainland. The US always has been colonized and settled by whites. Indians that murdered off the first Americans which were Europeans NEVER owned the land here they just squatted on it.





So which country invaded again and when did this take place ?

I wondered when one of the neo Marxist idiots would come up with an excuse for the invasion and mass murder that was America. You could almost see the islamonazi's saying the same thing to justify their mass murders.
1. The nation of Israel was declared on land OWNED by Palestinians
2. Indians killed off the first Americans which were Europeans not Asiatic Indians,Also Indians never OWNED any land they merely squatted on the land.
3. I am no "neo marxist" whatever the hell that is.






1) under which treaty that was agreed after 1924 ? ( 1917 they lost the war and lost all rights to the land until the treaty of Lausanns made it international law ) The land was granted under the Balfour declaration by the lands legal sovereign rulers as the Jewish national home under the mandate of Palestine.

2) The Amerindians "owned" the lands of America by custom and practise and each tribe had its own separate section. So where do you get the false claim they did not own it from, some neo Marxist text book ?

3) Then why do you spout neo Marxist dogma and beliefs ( neo Marxist is a champagne socialist like Obama who believe the animal farm motto all men are equal, but some men are more equal than others. You see yourself as being more equal and so should have the best for doing nothing. neo Marxists support and defend islamonazi terrorism until they get enough power to wipe out the muslims, after they have wiped out the Jews and Christians
 
...The nation of Israel was declared on land OWNED by Palestinians...
... Indians never OWNED any land they merely squatted on the land...

Odium, your logic is...*cough*...fascinating. Tell me, how does one obtain ownership of land and from whom does one obtain it?
Well if yer a jew you just blackmail and scream ANTI SEMITE if you don't get your way and use a false flag attack to scare them into supporting you.




So in other words you don't have a clue and so resort to racist abuse to get out of the hole. That ladder will never be long enough
 
Most of the jews live in the west bank.........


No kidding. That is a new one on me.

I'll have to research the news and CIA world history book ( online ) and see if that is true. I don't believe you are right - but I will check.

-----------------------------------------------------------

the Zionist don't like to live by them.

A religious variety of Zionism supports Jews upholding their Jewish identity defined as adherence to religious Judaism, opposes the assimilation of Jews into other societies, and has advocated the return of Jews to Israel as a means for Jews to be a majority nation in their own state.
Zionism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia



Shadow 355

I am talking the religious Jews who practice Judaism and the Zionist who do not and are mainly secular. The gov is down on the Hasidic Jews because they do not work and they do not learn much in school. Most of their communities are in the West Bank. The non religious jews of Russia tried to put an end to all religions in Russia, even Judaism.
The only reason they allow the Hasidic Jews there is because the religious zealots want the temple mount to begin offering sacrifices once again and that helps the Zionist claim to Israel as a jewish state, and helps the Zionist to make Jerusalem their capital.

Here from Ynet itself:

Why are haedim most hated people in Israel?





So you are now saying that the Jews are a race again, and as such your whole post is a racist outburst.

Your definition of Hasidic Jews ( less than 0.1% of the worlds Jewish population are all unemployed, this sounds like the majority of islamonazi's in Europe. They are the unemployed by choice because they want to fund their terrorism without working.

What are you rambling on about the al aqsa mosque is built on top of the Christian church that was there, which was built on the top of the 2nd Temple. That shows who was there first and who has the greater claim. The only claim the Jews need to Jerusalm and Palestine is the Mandate of Palestine that gave them the land in 1923 and subsequently became International law in 1924. Your claims are just islamocatholic propaganda LIES and BLOOD LIBELS
 
...The nation of Israel was declared on land OWNED by Palestinians...
... Indians never OWNED any land they merely squatted on the land...

Odium, your logic is...*cough*...fascinating. Tell me, how does one obtain ownership of land and from whom does one obtain it?
Well if yer a jew you just blackmail and scream ANTI SEMITE if you don't get your way and use a false flag attack to scare them into supporting you.

And what if you are a Palestinian Muslim, or a European Christian?
Palestinians already owned/settled that land when Jews stole it. Must say something when your race has been kicked out of EVERY nation/land you ever settled in that you had to go the damn desert to live LOL. European Christians and Palestinian Muslims are not a parasitic race intent on world domination. Jews are.





WRONG as they were not the owners, they were the invaders. And the only Palestinians priors to 1960 were the Jews if you read your history books.
They were kicked out because the Christians and muslims wanted to be the only Abrahamic religion so started LIES and BLOOD LIBELS against the Jews. It was not because of anything the Jews had done, other than to be better when it came to certain occupations. Look at the tenets of their religions and you will see that they are both told to go out and conquer the world for their Gods by violent means if needed, the Jews don't even try to convert people to Judaism. You really need to get your facts right and stop posting LIES as it discredits your other posts
 
You guys are idiots if you think the collapse of oil prices is because of some ingenious US foreign policy.

Our foreign policy is a cluster fuck at this point. Obama may have run a clean presidency and have been pretty good with domestic policy but his foreign policy leaves a lot to be desired.

And Israel certainly had exactly nothing to do with it.

No ingenious foreign policy at all. Taking out OPEC members in no ingenious.

However you only need look at what the US has done to the four OPEC members who were opposed to the US in 2001, to see where US foreign policy lies.

Syria? Fuck Syria, who cares about Syria? Not worth invading. The Ivory Coast? Where?

Libya, hell yeah, Libya is bad and evil and needs to be taken down instantly.

However it's not just this that has led to lower oil prices. However this has helped massively.






So the nations in the Gulf that are the leaders of OPEC and produce the most oil are who exactly. Would it be Saudi, Oman, Qatar, Kuwait and the UAE by any chance ?
 
Back
Top Bottom