Is Anti-Zionism the Same as Anti-Semitism?

[BackAgain]

I bet they absolutely despise jews
View attachment 1231480

Oh nozies! If TN can find Jewish people opposed to “Zionism” then it must be true that there is no absolute correlation between anti Zionism and anti Semitism.

Thankfully, I hadn’t said there was.

 

[ShahdagMountains]

I thought you just said you didn't care?

I did say it.
To your previous post. The one full of mumbo-jumbo.

 

[Churchill]

Let's just say they are a handful of race traitors.

Here's some more of these traitors:



Last time we saw that kind of stuff was Munich 1936

 

[ShahdagMountains]

Here's some more of these traitors:

Go for it!

 

[TNHarley]

However, if you scratch the surface of these anti Zionists, you find a solid core of anti Semitism just below the surface.

Oh nozies! If TN can find Jewish people opposed to “Zionism” then it must be true that there is no absolute correlation between anti Zionism and anti Semitism.

Thankfully, I hadn’t said there was.

 

[BackAgain]

Translation: Don't believe your own eyes and ears, these people really are antisemites don't be fooled.

View attachment 1231482

Once again, lame sophistry ^ from the Pooh.

Answer me this, Pooh. As for the relatively tiny set of ultra Orthodox Jews you love to display, is it their view that the Nation of Israel ought not exist?

In fact, when you jabber about your own opposition to “Zionism,” is it your view that Israel (as a Jewish nation) — the very fact of its existence — is a component of Zionism? And if so, what do you recommend about the existence of Israel as a nation?

 

[BackAgain]

As I noted: I had not made that claim.

 

[Churchill]

Once again, lame sophistry ^ from the Pooh.

Answer me this, Pooh. As for the relatively tiny set of ultra Orthodox Jews you love to display, is it their view that the Nation of Israel ought not exist?

I have no idea.

In fact, when you jabber about your own opposition to “Zionism,” is it your view that Israel (as a Jewish nation) — the very fact of its existence — is a component of Zionism? And if so, what do you recommend about the existence of Israel as a nation?

I think a good way to explore that question is to consider how we'd react to this question:

Did Nazi Germany and its occupied territories have a right to exist?

 

[TNHarley]

As I noted: I had not made that claim.

k

 

[ShahdagMountains]

Did Nazi Germany and its occupied territories have a right to exist?

What a stupid equivalence.

 

[Churchill]

What a stupid equivalence.

Just answer the question, are you struggling with it?

Of course you are, we both know that.

 

[ShahdagMountains]

Just answer the question, are you struggling with it?

Of course you are, we both know that.

Speak for yourself.

Your preoccupations are quite troubling.

 

[Churchill]

Speak for yourself.

Your preoccupations are quite troubling.

Look, if you don't want to discuss don't post, get a life, people disagree sometimes get over it, drama queen.

Does any state that exists have a right to exist?

Is even this question too hard for you?

 

[ShahdagMountains]

Does any state that exists have a right to exist?

Is even this question too hard for you?

Go away, you silly person.

 

[Churchill]

Go away, you silly person.

Very rational, very adult, fine let this be the end of our discussion.

 

[ShahdagMountains]

Very rational, very adult, fine let this be the end of our discussion.

There was no “discussion”.

 

[rosends]

They did that at Nuremberg, yet they executed them any way, they didn't believe the Nazis own "explanations".

that's not really accurate

Like those who issued an arrest warrant for Netanyahu?

No, like the lawyers who showed that there was no case.

Neither do you.

I do, on many levels. You have shown that you don't.

 

[rosends]

I bet they absolutely despise jews
View attachment 1231480

if you knew what they were actually saying and what they actually believed, you wouldn't post that.

 

[Churchill]

that's not really accurate

Yes, no summary written paragraph is as accurate as boxes of testimony.

No, like the lawyers who showed that there was no case.

Of course, silly me.

I do, on many levels. You have shown that you don't.

As I said I define Zionism much as I do Nazism, by the effects on its victims, that's my tried and trusted methodology.

 

[rosends]

Of course, silly me.

As I said I define Zionism much as I do Nazism, by the effects on its victims, that's my tried and trusted methodology.

you trust something that allows you to draw conclusions you want without having to do any real research. This leads you to the errors your are making. It is a weird choice, but at least you own it.