FA_Q2
Gold Member
It will be tested but if they follow the constitution it is pretty crystal clear that the states can run their elections however they want. SCOTUS is not known for caring about the constitution all that much though...You are talking about the National Popular Vote Compact, and that will have to be tested in court if they try it.
I am not convinced the SCOTUS will accept a State assigning it's EV's based on the voters in some other States. That is a State disenfranchising their own voters.
I don't see why it would create any chaos whatsoever. It would if demanded by the feds - they would have to unify our 50 systems and that would be a huge problem as well as making our system much more vulnerable.The US does not have a national election. We have 50 State elections on the same day. There is no national standard for how an election is held, and attempting to make the popular vote the method of choosing the President and Vice President would create chaos.
Done at the state level is seamless though, nothing changes with the system whatsoever. Not a single thing. The only change is outside of the election system, who the chosen electors cast their votes for.
