Blues Man
Diamond Member
- Aug 28, 2016
- 35,513
- 14,899
- 1,530
That's not what I said. That's what you implied I said. I am not arguing for predestination. I am telling you that everything happens for a logical reason. I would assume a Buddhist who believed in science would accept cause and effect for what it is and wouldn't confuse it for what it isn't. Cause and effect is not a predetermination that something will happen. Cause and effect is an explanation for what did happen.You were born to die. Does it matter how you die? The Buddha taught his disciples not to fear death, right? That if they live well, their rebirth will be good, right?Correct. No one said you did. I couldn't care less which path you choose. It's your walk, not mine. In my worldview everything works out the way it is supposed to work out.I don't need to follow anyone
So people that die a horrible death were supposed to?
But putting all that aside, we live in a logical universe where there has never been an uncaused event. In that light, everything that happens has a logical reason for happening. So yes, if you die a horrible death, there will be logical reasons for why you died a horrible death.
But I don't think that a child who dies in a fire was supposed to die in a fire or that a person who is beaten to death by a psychopath was supposed to die that way. Saying there was a cause is not the same as saying that it was "supposed to be". By saying things work out as they are "supposed to" implies that everything that will ever happen has already been planned. And we all know that is not true.
I don't subscribe to the reincarnation stuff that some Buddhists do.
Unfortunately your beliefs are based upon beliefs concerning body and mind or spirit where reincarnation is integral to the basic belief that body and mind or spirit are one.
You said and I quote
" In my worldview everything works out the way it is supposed to work out."
Which means to as to be expected.
So when you say that a 5 year old girl who died in a fire was supposed to die in a fire there had to be some plan in place for that result to be expected.