Hamas—not Israel—is responsible for obstructing the flow of humanitarian aid to Gaza civilians.

[Sherlock Holmes]

There is no country of Palestine. My ancestral homeland is Israel.

Not Judah?

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

can you tell me who the leader of this ancient country of Palestine was?

When? before WW1 it was the Ottomans, before that in the distant past it was the Romans, after WW1 it was the British...

 

[rosends]

Not Judah?

Judah was the name of a kingdom and, yes, that would be my heritage. But the country of Israel (which currently exists and did in the past) is the land which is my ancient homeland.

 

[rosends]

When? before WW1 it was the Ottomans, before that in the distant past it was the Romans, after WW1 it was the British...

exactly! thank you!

 

[John Edgar Slow Horses]

so no ancient country or nation. Unless you think 1988 is ancient. Good work.

Yes, an ancient land called Palestine.

The professionals define the terms, not amateurs like you.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

Judah was the name of a kingdom and, yes, that would be my heritage. But the country of Israel (which currently exists and did in the past) is the land which is my ancient homeland.

But you call yourself a "Jew" and that term refers to members of the Jew tribes (Judah et-al) as opposed to the Israelite tribes with whom the Jews were at war, so your heritage includes fighting against Israel, you have more in common with Palestinians than you know.

You have no legitimate claim to anything.

 

[John Edgar Slow Horses]

But you call yourself a "Jew" and that term refers to members of the Jew tribes (Judah et-al) as opposed to the Israelite tribes against whom the Jews were at war.

You have no legitimate claim to anything.

Since both nations were Jewish, you are wrong.

 

[sartre play]

little to no help being done by politicians. Just humans who offer aid.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

Since both nations were Jewish, you are wrong.

I'm not wrong, go and educate yourself.

 

[John Edgar Slow Horses]

Your education is lacking, Holmes. All of the Jewish tribes had claims on Judea, Israel, and Samaria.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

Your education is lacking, Holmes. All of the Jewish tribes had claims on Judea, Israel, and Samaria.

All I see are claims made about claims.

Judah was once at war with Israel, go and check, do you know when the term "Jew" first appears in ancient history?

 

[Frankenstein]

Of course there was.

Don't be a dweeb and play games.

And I believe in a one-state Greater Israel, but I believe in staying accurate.

Well that's out the window Palestine has never been a country it was a province of Rome
Yes, Palestine, as a region, was part of the Roman Empire. Following the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 CE, the Roman province of Judaea was reorganized and renamed Syria Palaestina, according to Wikipedia. This renaming was a deliberate act by the Romans to minimize Jewish identification with the land and erase the connection between the Jewish people and their homeland, according to the Hudson Institute

 

[Frankenstein]

When? before WW1 it was the Ottomans, before that in the distant past it was the Romans, after WW1 it was the British...

Yes, Palestine, as a region, was part of the Roman Empire. Following the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 CE, the Roman province of Judaea was reorganized and renamed Syria Palaestina, according to Wikipedia. This renaming was a deliberate act by the Romans to minimize Jewish identification with the land and erase the connection between the Jewish people and their homeland, according to the Hudson Institute

 

[Mac-7]

Lies.

No, its the truth

The Pals are starving their own children to make propaganda

 

[John Edgar Slow Horses]

All I see are claims made about claims.

Judah was once at war with Israel, go and check, do you know when the term "Jew" first appears in ancient history?

View attachment 1148299

It is what it is. They all shared the genetic markers we call Jewish today.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

No, its the truth

The Pals are starving their own children to make propaganda

Odd how a person who decries holocaust denial is more than happy to engage in it, using the very same trickery and lies that the Nazis and latter day Nazis use today, sickening.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

It is what it is. They all shared the genetic markers we call Jewish today.

Yes people who are related share genes, that's not being questioned.

So there is no "Jew" DNA, tribes and clans have cross bred for thousands of years. No Jew can prove he is a descendant of Judah, it's ridiculous, mumbo jumbo.

The claim "I have these genetic markers, therefore I have a right to evict people without those markers and occupy their land" is for fools.

 

[Mac-7]

Odd how a person who decries holocaust denial is more than happy to engage in it, using the very same trickery and lies that the Nazis and latter day Nazis use today, sickening.

Everyone agrees that the gaunt, hungry Pal children are turning world opinion against Israel

So who has something to gain from starving the kids?

Only Hamas

 

[rosends]

Yes, an ancient land called Palestine.

The professionals define the terms, not amateurs like you.

Well, no professional has defined it as a nation or a country back then. The AI write up you presented said so -- "Palestine has never existed as a fully sovereign, independent country with internationally recognized borders and governance in the traditional sense."

 

[rosends]

But you call yourself a "Jew" and that term refers to members of the Jew tribes

that's not true. The name "Jew" derived from the kingdom of Judah's population which included members from many tribes>

(Judah et-al) as opposed to the Israelite tribes with whom the Jews were at war

the better term would be "with whom the Judeans (or Judahites) were..."

, so your heritage includes fighting against Israel, you have more in common with Palestinians than you know.

And Unionists fought with separatists in which civil war again?

You have no legitimate claim to anything.

sure I do. You have no standing to say otherwise.