Gaza Genocide: 67% Gap Between What Elected Democrats and Their Voters Believe

[Toddsterpatriot]

No, you all did that yourselves when you stopped speaking Hebrew and switched to Aramaic, then Greek, then whatever European Language you ended up speaking.

The fact that modern Hebrew had to invent words for things the Ancient Hebrews didn't have proves that.

The fact that modern Hebrew had to invent words for things the Ancient Hebrews didn't have proves that.

Like modern English did?

 

[Shusha]

The fact that modern Hebrew had to invent words for things the Ancient Hebrews didn't have proves that.

Like modern English did?

Right?! Like every other language in the world didn't have to come up with words for newly invented technology or concepts. Sigh.

 

[Shusha]

No, you all did that yourselves when you stopped speaking Hebrew and switched to Aramaic, then Greek, then whatever European Language you ended up speaking.

The fact that modern Hebrew had to invent words for things the Ancient Hebrews didn't have proves that.

The Jewish people never stopped speaking, reading, and learning in Hebrew.

 

[JoeB131]

The fact that modern Hebrew had to invent words for things the Ancient Hebrews didn't have proves that.

Like modern English did?

English evolved organically over time, dummy.

When the Zionists started using Hebrew outside of ceremonies, they had to invent a whole shitload of new words to make it a workable language

The Jewish people never stopped speaking, reading, and learning in Hebrew.

Meh, not really. Hebrew was to the Ashkenazim what Latin was to the Catholic Goyim: a dead language used only for ceremonies, not for function.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

English evolved organically over time, dummy.

When the Zionists started using Hebrew outside of ceremonies, they had to invent a whole shitload of new words to make it a workable language



Meh, not really. Hebrew was to the Ashkenazim what Latin was to the Catholic Goyim: a dead language used only for ceremonies, not for function.

English evolved organically over time,

Right. English invented a whole shitload of new words.

 

[Shusha]

Meh, not really. Hebrew was to the Ashkenazim what Latin was to the Catholic Goyim: a dead language used only for ceremonies, not for function.

This is incorrect. Its use varied, of course, over time and in different places, but it was used as both a spoken and written language all through the diaspora.

Claiming that Jewish language and Jewish culture don't really exist, therefore the Jewish people can never have a national identity is demonstrably untrue. (Because Israel is certainly a State and Israeli is most definitely a nationality.)

But where your claim truly fails is when it is applied to the "Palestinian people".

 

[JoeB131]

Right. English invented a whole shitload of new words.

English evolved organically over time.

 

[JoeB131]

This is incorrect. Its use varied, of course, over time and in different places, but it was used as both a spoken and written language all through the diaspora.

The point is, that it is a dispora. No more a nationality than the Roma or the Sinti.

Claiming that Jewish language and Jewish culture don't really exist, therefore the Jewish people can never have a national identity is demonstrably untrue. (Because Israel is certainly a State and Israeli is most definitely a nationality.)

A religion isn't a national identity. It's a religion, with various localized languages and practices. There was no interest by Europe's Jews in returning to Palestine until Hitler started killing them off.

But where your claim truly fails is when it is applied to the "Palestinian people".

Nope. The Palestinians are the indigenous people.

The Zionists are colonial invaders cosplaying as Hebrews.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

English evolved organically over time.

English evolved organically over time.

By inventing new words.