Federal Judge Greenlights Lawsuit Against California for Hiding Child Gender Transitions from Parents

I've got a question for you. Have you ever TALKED to a trans person? Not screamed at them loudly, but just straight up talked to them? Any one of them would tell you they knew they were different at an early age, and not because anyone told them they were trans.



Same question to you, Marty. Have you ever talked to a trans person?

And also, the biggest increase in "trans" identity these days is with pubescent girls who never had the issue but now all of a sudden think they are boys.

Rapid-onset gender dysphoria controversy - Wikipedia
 
What is your medical degree in?



65 million women who got reproductive health care in those 50 years would disagree.



Right, funny, I thought that had more to do with our failure to address global warming.


Yes. Not relevant to this topic.



Again, if you know that telling the parents is going to result in that child being harmed, is it a good idea?
how would you know moron ! if the kids showing up at school with cuts and bruises for no obvious reasons sports playground accidents ECT .. then you notify child services .. under no condition should a parent be kept in the dark about an important trend or activity their child is partaking in ..
 
What is your medical degree in?



65 million women who got reproductive health care in those 50 years would disagree.



Right, funny, I thought that had more to do with our failure to address global warming.


Yes. Not relevant to this topic.

If we're talking about whether the school should notify parents about issues involving their child, yes, it is most definitely relevant.
Again, if you know that telling the parents is going to result in that child being harmed, is it a good idea?
Two questions here:

1.) How would one know the child will be harmed if the parents are notified?

2.) Does this mean you should notify them if you don't know?

Your argument here is woefully superficial and wholly based on what-ifs.
 
Not required. This is an overall social issue, and you idiots crossed the line when you went after kids.

Nobody went after kids.

This is a silly social issue everyone will forget about after Trump tanks the economy.

Just like everyone forgot about gay marriage after Bush tanked the economy.

History doesn't repeat itself, but it often rhymes.
 
Okay, so here's a scenario.

Little Timmy thinks he's Little Sally. The minute he gets to school, she changes clothes into a dress, and changes back to boy's clothes before she gets home.

In your world, you think the teacher should report that the parents.




ATLANTA — A candlelight vigil was held Monday night for a transgender woman who police say was killed by her own father.

Dozens of people showed up to honor Kathryn Newhouse, 19, in Atlanta’s Piedmont Park.

Now, Newhouse’s friends are using her tragedy to spread awareness about the threat the trans community is facing.


“She was like a little sister to me. She was a real sweetheart,” Journey Jennings said.

Police say Newhouse, an Asian American transgender woman, was killed by her father inside their family home last month.

Investigators say her father shot and killed her before turning the gun on himself.

“I would’ve never imagined something like this happening to her,” Jennings said.

So, where did little Timmy get the dress to change into?

how does "little timmy" know he's a girl? Is he old enough to make that distinction? Does he even know? Is he being influenced in some way to think that? Or get confused because of teachers encouraging a specific behavior?

And yes, if a child starts exhibiting signs of this nature, the parents need to be notified so they can take their child to a psychologist and get to the bottom of it. It's not the teachers responsibility to nurture this behavior, or make any decisions about that child's behavioral situation.
 
I've got a question for you. Have you ever TALKED to a trans person? Not screamed at them loudly, but just straight up talked to them? Any one of them would tell you they knew they were different at an early age, and not because anyone told them they were trans.



Same question to you, Marty. Have you ever talked to a trans person?
There's a difference between knowing you're different and knowing you're trans. Kids go through phases you know, right? Even if they might show tendencies of liking same sex kids other than opposite sex kids...may not be anything, or, depending on age, might be a sign of just same sex attraction. I think when you are a little boy (or girl) it's too soon to be making those decisions. There are varying degrees of serial orientation, even in the straight community.

In any case, it's not the teachers place to try and navigate these things. Only the parents should be making these decisions.
 
So, where did little Timmy get the dress to change into?

how does "little timmy" know he's a girl? Is he old enough to make that distinction? Does he even know? Is he being influenced in some way to think that? Or get confused because of teachers encouraging a specific behavior?

And yes, if a child starts exhibiting signs of this nature, the parents need to be notified so they can take their child to a psychologist and get to the bottom of it. It's not the teachers responsibility to nurture this behavior, or make any decisions about that child's behavioral situation.

Well, good thing they aren't doing that, then. Which isn't what the law in CA calls for.

There's a difference between knowing you're different and knowing you're trans. Kids go through phases you know, right? Even if they might show tendencies of liking same sex kids other than opposite sex kids...may not be anything, or, depending on age, might be a sign of just same sex attraction. I think when you are a little boy (or girl) it's too soon to be making those decisions. There are varying degrees of serial orientation, even in the straight community.

Okay, and I'm all for giving schools the tools to make those determinations. (Of course, we can't even get our schools enough textbooks to go around, but never mind.)
 
Well, good thing they aren't doing that, then. Which isn't what the law in CA calls for.



Okay, and I'm all for giving schools the tools to make those determinations. (Of course, we can't even get our schools enough textbooks to go around, but never mind.)

Well, but it does:




Okay, and I'm all for giving schools the tools to make those determinations.

The only action schools should take is talking to the parents. Why do you leftys think it's OK to take liberties with other people's kids?

Teachers teach, leave the behavioral issues to the parents and their doctors.
 
Well, but it does:

Well, no, it doesn't. When your kid grows up trans, It's pretty easy to find ANYONE else to blame.


The only action schools should take is talking to the parents. Why do you leftys think it's OK to take liberties with other people's kids?

Teachers teach, leave the behavioral issues to the parents and their doctors.

Teachers are required to get Master's degrees to understand behavior issues.

It doesn't take a Master's degree to teach a kid how to finger-paint.
 
Well, no, it doesn't. When your kid grows up trans, It's pretty easy to find ANYONE else to blame.




Teachers are required to get Master's degrees to understand behavior issues.

It doesn't take a Master's degree to teach a kid how to finger-paint.
Stay away from the children, Joey.
You're a disturbing person.
WTF is wrong with you?????
 
Religion was nothing to do with it you fucking asshole bigot.
Stay away from the children, Joey.

it has everything to do with it.

Take out religion, people wouldn't care if their kids were gay or trans. They'd be able to deal with it.

You guys lost on gay rights a long time ago.

You'll lose on trans rights, too.

And you churches will pretend they weren't the assholes here. (Just like they do now on segregation.)
 
it has everything to do with it.

Take out religion, people wouldn't care if their kids were gay or trans. They'd be able to deal with it.

You guys lost on gay rights a long time ago.

You'll lose on trans rights, too.

And you churches will pretend they weren't the assholes here. (Just like they do now on segregation.)
No, in FACT it is YOUR RELIGION that you want to utilize.
The religion of THE STATE.
You fucking cultists want to mutilate children and oppress EVERYONE with your climate DOGMA.
You want the power of THE STATE to override the natural RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE PARENTS OF CHILDREN.
Yea, YOUR RELIGION has EVERYTHING to do with it.
Stay away from the children, Joey.
 

Forum List

Back
Top