Palestine?
Independent state? Culture? Unique contribution to religion? Library of literature? Contribution to knowledge, science, medicine, building, math? Language? Law? Discovery or exploration? Economy or trade?
Not every country, district or sanjuk have a right to statehood. What of the slavery and oppression they inflict on their own kind or what they have done to their hosts and neighbors in the last 50 yrs? The cost to the world to absorb them, especially in the much of the muslim world would have been far less than the cost of wars and global charity to keep them as they are or perpetuate hope for their "demands". They should be contributing to society instead of draining it.
They did not have to leave, they could have taken settlement for lost property, they could have even had a state years ago if they had been willing to make some compromise.
The oppression they suffer is of arab making or their own. When Israel took control of gaza and WB the lot of the palestinians not in refugee camps improved considerably. Jordan and Egypt did little for them. Jordan tried to make them citizens so they could better provide for them, but palestinians attack them.
They won't even renounce violence or recognize Israel's right to exist. What have they don't to deserve the right to their own state? More than half of the called palestinians at the end of the mandate had been immigrated to the mandate and required only to have been there for two years. Most of those who were there pre-mandate were not registered land owns or tax payers. They worked the land for other people. They did no mandatory military service. They did not even recognize themselves as "palestinians" but as arab or syrian.
The mandate was made of many sanjuks, it was not a separate region with it's own government or sub-government. It had no supportable economy. Until the mandate it was under populated and under developed.
Jordan became an arab state. The UN offered the rest of the arabs their own state alongside Israel, but they refused. What gives them more right to their own state than a group like the Kurds?
What gives them more rights than dozens of tribes that had language, historical and cultural distinctions that were part of the Ottoman empire when it fell?
What makes the "palestinians" unique enough to independence and not just arabs that could be part of any nations in the region? Most were not born in the mandate or less than one or two generations from immigrants to the mandate. When were they ever a unique singular group of distinct people before the mandate?
What are they willing to do or give up in a peace agreement to have their own state? How are they going to support a state, and their people, if they had one?
Why do they deserve the right to stand before the UN as their own state? What contribution to the world will they make?
Maybe you should work with the other psychopath and figure out which biological weapon can eliminate these pesky people that are so inherently bad they don't deserve to live.
I spent a lot of time in the camps and years trying to help and represent the palestinians. I also got to learn truths they did not want told. Very nearly killed three times. Forced to leave to protect my family.
I don't advocate their extermination, never have. I won't support the lies and endless demands without giving up the violence and hate against Israel, jews and anyone that believes Israel has a right to exist. I've seen and experienced what both sides can do. I know what it is to be scared physically and emotionally by war.
I am not armchair quarterbacking about something I am not very familiar with. Close to fifty years I've been actively involved in event in the middle east, though now it is via my computer and through my contact there.
I doubt you or many others have been as involved. Spouting palestinian propaganda and lies is not really helping them, it just perpetuates the hate and destruction. It prolongs the suffering in the region.
I grew up in the military. I understand war. I've seen too much of it. I have always tried to work towards peace.