Do democrats agree with Mamdani's desire to seize the means of production ?

[fncceo]

Do democrats agree with Mamdani's desire to seize the means of production ?​

Relax. NOTHING is produced in New York.

 

[Care4all]

watch the video [ its only 1 minute long ] where he states the end goal is to seize the means of production ..

By who, the mayor of New York? The NY Post wants to scare you....and sell papers....

 

[ColonelAngus]

You gotta love a FAKE NEWS reaction to a post of Mamdani speaking.

 

[Stryder50]

What workers is Mamdani trying to chain? MAGA scaremongering!

Like most Leftists, you keep displaying the depth of your ignorance combined with stupidity.
Clearly manifest in how you fail to understand the point of my post.

Mamdani having government of NYC 'seize and own' the 'means of production' is of no value unless those who work 'the means of production' are willing to still do such. His socialist delusional scheme will fail UNLESS he FORCES the workers to stay on their jobs, hence the metaphor of chaining the workers to their machines=means of production.

 

[Carl in Michigan]

Loaded question. He does not want to seize the means of production. Did he say the government will seize factories?

He's a Democrat. You will not condemn him

 

[Nuthin' Fancy]

Like most Leftists, you keep displaying the depth of your ignorance combined with stupidity.
Clearly manifest in how you fail to understand the point of my post.

Mamdani having government of NYC 'seize and own' the 'means of production' is of no value unless those who work 'the means of production' are willing to still do such. His socialist delusional scheme will fail UNLESS he FORCES the workers to stay on their jobs, hence the metaphor of chaining the workers to their machines=means of production.

The companies in which the U.S. government has a financial involvement are:

• Intel: The government has a 10% equity stake after converting a portion of the grants provided under the CHIPS Act into an ownership stake, a move aimed at boosting domestic semiconductor production for national security.
• MP Materials: The Department of Defense holds a 15% equity stake in the rare-earth miner, part of an effort to secure the domestic supply chain for rare-earth elements, which are critical for various technologies and largely dominated by China.
• Lithium Americas: The Department of Energy holds a 5% stake in the company (and one of its projects) related to a $2 billion loan provided to develop U.S. lithium resources.
• Trilogy Metals: The Department of Defense has a 10% stake in this company in exchange for approvals related to the development of a strategic metals mining project.
• U.S. Steel: As part of the deal allowing Japan's Nippon Steel to acquire U.S. Steel, the U.S. government secured a "golden share," which grants it veto power over specific major strategic decisions, such as closing plants or reducing jobs.
• Nvidia and Advanced Micro Devices (AMD): The administration has an arrangement where it receives 15% of the revenue from the sale of certain advanced chips to China, effectively a revenue-sharing agreement in exchange for export licenses.

Will Trump control the means of production?

Sounds like Trump loves socialism, just as long as it's all corporate.

 

[Stryder50]

The companies in which the U.S. government has a financial involvement are:

Will Trump control the means of production with these companies?

• Intel: The government has a 10% equity stake after converting a portion of the grants provided under the CHIPS Act into an ownership stake, a move aimed at boosting domestic semiconductor production for national security.
• MP Materials: The Department of Defense holds a 15% equity stake in the rare-earth miner, part of an effort to secure the domestic supply chain for rare-earth elements, which are critical for various technologies and largely dominated by China.
• Lithium Americas: The Department of Energy holds a 5% stake in the company (and one of its projects) related to a $2 billion loan provided to develop U.S. lithium resources.
• Trilogy Metals: The Department of Defense has a 10% stake in this company in exchange for approvals related to the development of a strategic metals mining project.
• U.S. Steel: As part of the deal allowing Japan's Nippon Steel to acquire U.S. Steel, the U.S. government secured a "golden share," which grants it veto power over specific major strategic decisions, such as closing plants or reducing jobs.
• Nvidia and Advanced Micro Devices (AMD): The administration has an arrangement where it receives 15% of the revenue from the sale of certain advanced chips to China, effectively a revenue-sharing agreement in exchange for export licenses.

It's almost like the Trump cults definition of socialism.

You are an equal dumb and ignorant along with konradv as pointed out above in #24.

These 5-15% you claim* are not controlling~owning amounts, more like mutual investments.
Mamdani, as typical to socialist-communists is speaking of 100% ownership & control.

* You fail to document these claims and numbers, so for the moment, they can be considered figments of your imagination = lies & disinformation.

​

 

[Nuthin' Fancy]

You are an equal dumb and ignorant along with konradv as pointed out above in #24.

These 5-15% you claim* are not controlling~owning amounts, more like mutual investments.

BS.
How long is it going to take for Trump to pour taxpayer $$$, into these companies when their stock drops?
A New York minute.

Mamdani, as typical to socialist-communists is speaking of 100% ownership & control.

YES, he did.
What you left out was if the warnings and fines for companies are ignored.
Much like if you didn't pay your property taxes for 3 years.
Your shit will go up for a tax deed sale.

* You fail to document these claims and numbers, so for the moment, they can be considered figments of your imagination = lies & disinformation.

​

You fail to provide proof, much like your dear leader.

 

[ColonelAngus]

Like most Leftists, you keep displaying the depth of your ignorance combined with stupidity.
Clearly manifest in how you fail to understand the point of my post.

Mamdani having government of NYC 'seize and own' the 'means of production' is of no value unless those who work 'the means of production' are willing to still do such. His socialist delusional scheme will fail UNLESS he FORCES the workers to stay on their jobs, hence the metaphor of chaining the workers to their machines=means of production.

The words of the prophets were written on the subway walls, and tenement halls.

Mamdani is going to MAKE NYC DISCO AGAIN!

IT WILL BE “THAT 70s SHOW”

“Starting on day one, we will expand the city's special enforcement programs - The city's gonna step in — and send them the bill If that doesn't work, the city's taking over the building”

THAT IS COMMUNISM, YOU STUPID LEFTY *****.

STAY THE **** AWAY FROM FLORIDA. YOU MIGHT GET EATEN BY AN ALLIGATOR OR BLOWN BY A HURRICANE.

 

[Nuthin' Fancy]

The words of the prophets were written on the subway walls, and tenement halls.

Mamdani is going to MAKE NYC DISCO AGAIN!

IT WILL BE “THAT 70s SHOW”

“Starting on day one, we will expand the city's special enforcement programs - The city's gonna step in — and send them the bill If that doesn't work, the city's taking over the building”

THAT IS COMMUNISM, YOU STUPID LEFTY *****.

STAY THE **** AWAY FROM FLORIDA. YOU MIGHT GET EATEN BY AN ALLIGATOR OR BLOWN BY A HURRICANE.

WTF?

There's more communism in Florida than most anywhere.

Thanks to another communist.

Governor Ron DeSantis and Cabinet Deed Land for the ...​

Office of Governor Ron DeSantis
https://www.flgov.com › ... › Newsroom › Press Releases
Sep 30, 2025 — “Having the Trump Presidential Library in Miami will be good for Florida, for the city, and for Miami Dade College,” said Governor Ron DeSantis.

A Trump presidential library in downtown Miami would be ...​

Yahoo News Canada
https://ca.news.yahoo.com › trump-presidential-library-...
Oct 19, 2025 — Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and his Cabinet agreed to donate land valued at more than $67 million for Trump's presidential library.

The only problem is DUHSantis and the state of Florida didn't own the property.

Trump library lawsuit casts cloud over Florida Sunshine Law​

Miami Herald
https://www.miamiherald.com › news › article312782314
3 days ago — The lawsuit, brought by historian Marvin Dunn, alleges Miami Dade College did not give “reasonable notice” under Florida law of its special Sept ...

 

[ColonelAngus]

NF,

It is ok to admit you are a communist.

If you do not already live in NYC, you should move there immediately.

 

[konradv]

Like most Leftists, you keep displaying the depth of your ignorance combined with stupidity.
Clearly manifest in how you fail to understand the point of my post.

Mamdani having government of NYC 'seize and own' the 'means of production' is of no value unless those who work 'the means of production' are willing to still do such. His socialist delusional scheme will fail UNLESS he FORCES the workers to stay on their jobs, hence the metaphor of chaining the workers to their machines=means of production.

You haven’t answered, what workers?

 

[Nuthin' Fancy]

NF,

It is ok to admit you are a communist.

That's your dear leader and his cult............

Donald J. Trump on X: "Congratulations to President Xi and ...​

X · realDonaldTrump
54K+ likes · 6 years ago
Congratulations to President Xi and the Chinese people on the 70th Anniversary of the People's Republic of China! 10:54 AM · Oct 1, 2019.

'I want them to be like Xi's staff': Trump wants JD Vance to ...​

Firstpost
https://www.firstpost.com › World
2 days ago — Trump praised Chinese leader Xi Jinping's top aides for being so afraid of their boss that they would not speak in his presence.

If you do not already live in NYC, you should move there immediately.

 

[Stryder50]

You haven’t answered, what workers?

For the third time, mush for brains, the workers who work in those "means of production" that make it possible for there to be production.
No one there to work/run the machines and there is no production to seize.

You commies are so stupid and dense with mud in place of brains.

 

[Zincwarrior]

One of the most popular rising stars in the Democrat Party is self proclaimed Socialist Zohran Mamdani ... Many on the left claim he isn't a communist but a Democratic Socialist [communism with training wheels ].. One of the main tenants of Communism is the seizure of the means of production ,and Mamdani has expressed a desire to do just that ! Are Dems comfortable with electing a man that desires the seizure of production to lead the nations largest city ! ZIs the democrat party now a communist party electing communist leaders ?? It seems that that's exactly what is happening ! Mamdani states that the end goal is to seize the means of production !No matter what the left claims COMMUNISM IS THE END GOAL !

Zohran Mamdani’s ‘chilling’ call for ‘seizing the means of production’ draws outrage from Communist refugees: ‘Dangerous and scary’

In the resurfaced clip, Zohran Mamdani, a self-described Democratic Socialist, notes that certain issues socialists “firmly believe in,” such as boycotts, divestment and sanctions against Israel an…

nypost.com

AI Overview



Yes, a central tenet of communism is the seizure and common ownership of the means of production, such as factories and resources, by the public or the state, according to
Wikipedia, Britannica, and SparkNotes. This aims to eliminate the class-based system where a few own the means of production and wealth, as described by Karl Marx. Under communism, the means of production are intended to be collectively owned and operated for the benefit of all.

You realize this is the same thing that happens throughout history right, when the wealthy obtain the majority of assets. It goes all the way back to the Peasant's Revolt.

 

[Mac-7]

Loaded question. He does not want to seize the means of production. Did he say the government will seize factories?

36 seconds into the video Mandami declares the goal of socialism - his goal - is to seize the means of production

 

[konradv]

For the third time, mush for brains, the workers who work in those "means of production" that make it possible for there to be production.
No one there to work/run the machines and there is no production to seize.

You commies are so stupid and dense with mud in place of brains.

What production? He’s talking about real estate. If he really meant production, Trump beat him to it.

 

[Oddball]

One of the most popular rising stars in the Democrat Party is self proclaimed Socialist Zohran Mamdani ... Many on the left claim he isn't a communist but a Democratic Socialist [communism with training wheels ].. One of the main tenants of Communism is the seizure of the means of production ,and Mamdani has expressed a desire to do just that ! Are Dems comfortable with electing a man that desires the seizure of production to lead the nations largest city ! ZIs the democrat party now a communist party electing communist leaders ?? It seems that that's exactly what is happening ! Mamdani states that the end goal is to seize the means of production !No matter what the left claims COMMUNISM IS THE END GOAL !

Zohran Mamdani’s ‘chilling’ call for ‘seizing the means of production’ draws outrage from Communist refugees: ‘Dangerous and scary’

In the resurfaced clip, Zohran Mamdani, a self-described Democratic Socialist, notes that certain issues socialists “firmly believe in,” such as boycotts, divestment and sanctions against Israel an…

nypost.com

AI Overview



Yes, a central tenet of communism is the seizure and common ownership of the means of production, such as factories and resources, by the public or the state, according to
Wikipedia, Britannica, and SparkNotes. This aims to eliminate the class-based system where a few own the means of production and wealth, as described by Karl Marx. Under communism, the means of production are intended to be collectively owned and operated for the benefit of all.

The dirty little commie secret....

 

[konradv]

The dirty little commie secret....

View attachment 1182177

Intel? Westinghouse?

 

[yidnar]

What does New York City actually produce? Aside from finance, health care and life sciences, some high technology and biotechnology, real estate, and insurance, the main product of NYC is mass media, journalism, and publishing. The last three are already in the pockets of the Marxists, but I have no doubt Mandani will make the best use out of the media industry in order to push his vile Marxist ideology.

Mamdanis vision extends beyond NYC ..